
Black Water, Sweet Cane
A Fiji Indian Family from the Indenture Lines to Sacramento
by V. Ashtapad
Foreword
This is a novel. Reshmi Narayan, her parents, her grandmothers, her cousins, Phulmati and Bechan, Valli and Kannan, and every other person, family, estate, shop, hall and grocery in these pages are invented. So are the village of Mahuawa, the Number Four lines, the farm at Nine Mile and every song and letter quoted here. No character is a portrait of anyone.
The history is real. Between 1879 and 1916 about sixty thousand people from India were taken to Fiji under indenture, the five-year agreement they called girmit, and more than a million went to plantation colonies around the world. Recruiters often misled them about the distance, the work and the pay. They passed through depots at Garden Reach in Calcutta and in Madras, were measured and given emigration passes, crossed the kalapani under sail and later by steamer, on ships such as the Elbe, which reached Fiji on 13 June 1896, were landed at Nukulau, and worked on sugar estates under the task system, with fines and prosecutions for unfinished work. The last ship arrived in November 1916, and the indenture system was abolished on 1 January 1920. Most girmitiya never went back.
Their descendants made Fiji Hindi, farmed leased land for generations, lived through the coups of 1987 and 2000 and the land leases that ran out around the turn of the century, and many settled in California, around Sacramento and the San Francisco Bay Area.
For every girl who walked away from the well, and every family that wrote back.
The Envelope from Suva
My great-great-grandmother was four feet ten and a half inches tall, and she had a scar on her left wrist the shape of a grain of rice.
I know this because a clerk at the Calcutta depot measured her against a wooden post on a morning in February 1896 and wrote the number down, and because someone else, another clerk in another century, laid the paper she was written on face down on a glass plate in Suva and made a copy for me. The copy came in a stiff brown envelope with a Fiji stamp of a red-and-green parrot on it. It was waiting on the porch on Thursday, the fifteenth of January, when I got home from work, propped against the door where my father leaves packages so the mail carrier will not have to walk to the side gate.
Sacramento had been under tule fog for nine days. The fog comes up off the Delta in winter and sits on the valley like a lid, so low and white that the streetlights stay on at noon and the tops of the sycamores on our street disappear. You can hear the freeway but you cannot see it. Our house in the south part of the city, a long yellow stucco ranch with a carport my father enclosed himself in 2006, was a gray shape with one window lit. That was the kitchen. That was Aaji.
I took the envelope inside under my coat as if it might get wet, which it could not, because tule fog does not rain. It just hangs there and soaks you slowly.
"Reshmi, ka hai?" my grandmother said without turning around. She was at the stove in her cardigan, the green one with the wooden buttons, rolling roti on a round board with a pin no thicker than a pencil. She is eighty-five and she has rolled roti every evening of my life. The board rocked a little on the counter, tock, tock, the sound I fall asleep to in my head.
"Something from Fiji," I said. "From the archives."
She turned then. She looked at the parrot stamp for a long time.
I had sent the request in October, through the National Archives of Fiji, with the number I had found on a scanned list of passengers who came on the sailing ship Elbe. The list had six hundred and some names in a clerk's slanted hand, and on the fourth page, between a man from Gonda and a widow from Fyzabad, was a name I already knew from Aaji's mouth: Phulmati. Daughter of Sitaram. Basti. Age nineteen. That was all the list said. The pass would say more. Aaji had told me for years that Phulmati was "itna sa," this small, and she would hold her hand flat at the height of her own shoulder, and I had thought of it as a way of speaking, the way she says a thing happened "ek dum jaldi" when it took six months.
Four feet ten and a half. She meant it.
I did not open the envelope in the kitchen because of the oil. I took it to the dining table, which in our house is a place where nobody eats except at parties. It is covered with a lace cloth under a sheet of clear plastic, and on the plastic sit my mother's papers from the clinic, my father's invoices from the shop, a stack of wedding cards in gold and red, a bowl of oranges from Kaka Anil's tree, and a framed photograph of my grandfather, Aja, in a white shirt in front of a cane field in Ba. I moved the wedding cards. Four of them were for weddings this spring. Two of the brides were younger than me.
The pass was one sheet, copied at actual size. The form was printed in English with Hindi below it in the Devanagari script, and the blanks were filled in brown ink that had gone the color of tea.
Emigration Pass. Depot Number 211. Name: Phulmati. Father's name: Sitaram. Age: 19. Next of kin: Jagdish, husband (absent). District: Basti. Thana: a word I could not read. Village: Mahuawa. Height: 4 ft. 10 1/2 in. Bodily marks: small scar left wrist. Then a signature from the registering officer, and a stamp, and a line in a different hand saying she had appeared before him and agreed to go to Fiji and work for five years. Under it, a printed paragraph about the agreement, about nine hours a day in the field and wages of one shilling for a man and nine pence for a woman, and at the bottom a square where there should have been a mark.
There was a mark. A small cross in the brown ink. Her hand had held that pen.
"Husband absent," I said out loud.
Aaji had come to the doorway with flour on her fingers. "Kaun?"
"Phulmati. It says she had a husband. Jagdish. Absent."
My grandmother did not look surprised. She looked at me the way she looks at a pot she knows will boil over if she leaves it, and then she came and sat at the dining table, on the plastic, which she never does, and wiped her hands on her cardigan.
"Uske admi Calcutta gaya rahin," she said. Her husband had gone to Calcutta. "To the jute mills. She went to find him. That's what she told me. She went to find him and she found a ship."
I had heard her say the last sentence before, the found-a-ship sentence. I had heard it at Fiji Day picnics, and in a hospital waiting room when my father had his knee done, and on long drives to Yuba City. I had heard it the way you hear the words of a song you never think about. Now there was a paper with a cross on it, and the sentence was a door.
My mother came home at seven. She works as a medical assistant at a clinic on Stockton Boulevard and she wears her scrubs home and changes in the garage so she will not bring anything in. I heard the garage door, then the washer, then her voice in the kitchen asking Aaji in Fiji Hindi whether there was any of yesterday's dhal, and Aaji telling her there was something from Fiji on the table and to come and see, and my mother saying, "Shipping papers again? Your father ordered parts from Suva?"
"Phulmati," Aaji said.
My mother came in drying her hair with a dish towel. She is Tamil on both her parents' sides, though she speaks only a dozen words of Tamil and Fiji Hindi is the language she dreams in. She read the pass over my shoulder. She read all of it, including the paragraph about wages. Then she put one finger on the cross at the bottom.
"So small," she said, and I did not know whether she meant the mark or the woman.
I have a folder on my laptop called Family. I made it in 2019 when my cousin Rohit asked me for help with a school project, and it grew. There is a tree in it now that my aunts and uncles can open from their phones, with the faces of everybody I could find a photograph of, and blank gray circles for everybody I could not. Phulmati was a gray circle with a name and the word "Basti" under it and the year 1896 with a question mark. That night I scanned the copy at my desk, tagged it, and attached it to her. The gray circle stayed gray. There are no photographs of her. But under the circle there was now a piece of paper with her height on it, and a mark her hand had made.
My father saw it before I told him. His phone buzzed while he was eating at the counter, still in his work shirt with VINOD stitched over the pocket in red, and he scrolled with one thumb and stopped chewing.
"Four ten," he said. "Aaji was right."
"Aaji is always right," my grandmother said from the stove.
"Not always," my father said, and grinned at her, and she smacked the back of his head with the flat of her hand, which is how they have loved each other for sixty years.
It was a good night. I want to say that first, before I say the other things, because people who have never been inside a family like mine hear the other things and think there are no good nights. There are a great many. My mother put on the old Fiji radio station from Suva on her phone and turned it low, and somebody was singing an old Hindi film song that made Aaji hum. The fog pressed on the windows. The kitchen smelled of cumin and burnt flour.
Then my mother, putting the dhal away, said, "Shanti Auntie called. About Saturday."
I knew what Saturday was. Saturday was the Prasad girl's engagement party at the community hall off Florin Road, the hall with the low ceiling and the brown carpet and the folding chairs that leave lines on the backs of your legs. It was the fourth engagement of the winter.
"She asked if you're coming," my mother said.
"I'm coming."
"She asked," my mother said, carefully, putting the lid on the container, "if you would wear the peach one. The salwar kameez. Because the Deo family from Stockton will be there. With their son. The pharmacist."
My father became interested in his phone. Aaji rolled a roti she did not need to roll.
"Mummy," I said.
"I'm only telling you what she said."
"I know."
"She means well."
"I know she does."
"Twenty-seven, Reshmi," my mother said, very softly, and it was not a reproach, it was nearly an apology, and that was the hardest part. "Twenty-eight in April. People are asking. They ask me at the clinic. Patients ask me. Women I don't even know from Ba."
I could have said what I always say, that I have a job I love, a master's degree I paid for myself, that I am the first person in my family on either side to read a document in an archive instead of being written down in one. I could have said that my brother Nitin is twenty-four and lives in San Diego with two roommates and a surfboard, and that no aunty has ever called my mother about the peach salwar kameez Nitin should wear. I have said all of that before. It ends the same way every time, with my mother crying in the bathroom and my father telling me I have upset her, and Aaji saying nothing at all.
So I said, "I'll wear the peach one."
My mother looked at me as if she had been expecting a fight and did not know where to put her hands.
Later, upstairs, I sat on my bed with the copy of the pass on my knees. Mine is the small bedroom at the back of the house, the one with the window over the carport roof. I have slept in it since I was born, except for two years at the dorms at Sac State, which are eleven minutes away by car, which my parents agreed to only because it was eleven minutes. I had been admitted to UCLA in 2016. I still have the letter. It is in a box in the closet with my high school debate trophies and a dried corsage.
I looked at the line again. Next of kin: Jagdish, husband (absent).
A girl of nineteen from a village in the plains north of the Ghaghara River, with a husband who had gone east to the mills and not written, had walked out of her village to find him. Everybody in her village would have known. Everybody would have talked. I know exactly what they would have said, because the words have not changed in a hundred and thirty years. They would have said she had no shame. They would have said, think of her family. They would have said, log ka bolega. What will people say.
And she went anyway. She got as far as the depot in Calcutta and then she got on a ship.
I do not know if she agreed to Fiji the way the paper says. I do not know if anyone explained to her that Fiji was not a town near Calcutta, that it was twelve thousand miles across the black water, the kalapani, that five years in the cane was five years, and that the return passage was not free until ten. I do not know what Jagdish was doing on the day she was measured against the post. I wanted to know. I wanted to know so badly that my hands were cold.
Downstairs Aaji was singing. She sings when she thinks the house is asleep, in Bhojpuri, the old language of her mother-in-law's mother-in-law, words that are not quite the Fiji Hindi we speak. I have recorded her a few times on my phone, always asking first, always with her saying, "Kahe? Who wants to hear an old woman?" and then singing for twenty minutes. The recordings sit in the same folder as the tree. I had never asked what the songs meant. I thought I had time.
I opened my laptop and started a new document and typed at the top: Things to ask Aaji. The first line was: Who taught you the songs?
The second line was: What happened to Jagdish?
The third line, after a long time, I typed and deleted three times before I let it stay: What did people say about her?
Outside, the fog had swallowed the streetlight. Somewhere in it a train went through on the Union Pacific line, long, slow, its horn coming in two notes off the river. I fell asleep with the pass on the pillow beside me, which is a thing an archivist should never do with a document, and which I did anyway, because it was only a copy and because she was so small.
Depot Number 211
Built from one sheet: the emigration pass of Phulmati, daughter of Sitaram, Depot Number 211, Calcutta, 1896. Height four feet ten and a half inches. Small scar, left wrist. Husband absent. A copy of it hangs now under her name in the family tree.
The scar came from a sickle in the winter she was nine, the year the rains failed and every child in Mahuawa who could hold a blade was sent into the fields to cut what little stood. The blade was her father's, too long for her, and it turned in her hand on a stalk of millet and opened the skin above her wrist bone. Her mother packed it with ash from the hearth and tied it with a strip of an old dhoti, and it healed into a pale seed of a mark that she rubbed with her thumb whenever she was frightened. She rubbed it a great deal in the winter of 1895.
Mahuawa sat on flat land north of the Ghaghara, in the district of Basti, two days' walk from the river and a long morning's walk from the railway. It had forty houses of mud and thatch around a well, a mango grove that belonged to the landlord, a pond that went green in the hot months, and fields of wheat, barley, peas, a little sugarcane, and rice in the low ground. In winter the mornings came up white with mist, and the smoke of cow-dung fires lay flat across the fields, and the mustard flowered so yellow along the field edges that it hurt to look at it after the gray of the houses. Women walked to the well in a line with brass pots on their heads. From the landlord's house came the sound of a hand mill grinding, all day, a stone noise like distant cartwheels.
Phulmati had been married at eleven and gone to her husband's house at fourteen. Jagdish was a quiet young man with a broad back who could not get enough work on his father's share of the land to feed the household, so in the cold season of 1894 he had walked to the railway with two other men from the village and taken a train to Calcutta, where the jute mills on the Hooghly were said to pay a man six or seven rupees a month. He had promised to send money by the spring. He had promised to come home for the wedding of his younger sister.
No money came in the spring. Nobody came for the wedding. In the summer one of the two other men came back with a cough and said he had lost sight of Jagdish at a mill at a place called Titagarh, where there were a thousand men in a single shed and the noise of the looms made your teeth hum. Perhaps he had gone to another mill. Perhaps to the coal fields. Perhaps, the man said, and then did not finish.
What a household says about a young wife whose husband has not come back is not very different from what a village says, and the village said it at the well. She heard it in the way the other women stopped speaking when she came with her pot. She heard it from her mother-in-law, who did not shout but counted. Every roti Phulmati ate was counted. Every hour she spent at her own mother's house across the fields was counted. When the sister-in-law was married without her brother present, the women of the groom's family sang the teasing songs that are sung at weddings, and one of the verses, which was only a verse and could have been about anyone, was about a wife who sleeps alone because her husband has run away from her cooking. Everybody laughed. Phulmati laughed too. She rubbed the scar on her wrist under her sari until it was hot.
In the cold season of 1895 a man came through the district who said he was going to Calcutta and could find people there.
He did not come to the village. He sat under a tamarind tree near the bazaar in Basti town, where she had gone with her father to sell a goat, and he wore a clean white dhoti and a short coat with brass buttons, and he spoke the language of the district with a soft voice, as if he were from there, which perhaps he was. He said his name was Lalji. He asked the goat-buyer about the price of grain, and he asked her father where they were from, and when her father said Mahuawa he said he knew a man from near Mahuawa who was doing very well in Calcutta. When she asked, before her father could stop her, whether he had ever been to the mills at Titagarh, he looked at her for the first time and said he had been there many times.
Years later, in the lines, a man who had been a recruiter's clerk told her what a man like Lalji was paid for every person who passed the doctor, and that it was more for a woman than for a man. She thought of his mended cuffs then. She thought of him for years after that with a hatred that slowly turned into something more tired.
That day he told her father, kindly, that a girl in her position might find her husband and also find work. There was work near Calcutta for women, he said, light work, sifting and sorting at a sugar place, sitting down in the shade. Good pay. Food given. If she came to the depot in Calcutta with him and the other workers, she could look for her husband from there. The depot was near the mills. Many women did it. In a year she would come back with silver on her arms.
Her father said no and took her home.
She went back to the tamarind tree alone eleven days later, after her mother-in-law told her in front of the neighbors that a woman whose husband has left her should stop eating like a wife. She took a brass lota, two saris, the silver ring from her toe, and a cloth bundle of parched gram. She did not tell her mother. That was the thing she would remember all her life, and tell the young wife of her grandson sixty years later on a veranda in Ba with rain falling on the iron roof: that she did not tell her mother, and so her mother had to hear it at the well.
Lalji took her and four men and another woman, a widow from the next district with a little boy, to a walled house on the edge of the town that he called the depot, though it was only a sub-depot, a yard with a cook-fire and mats under a roof. Within three days there were twenty of them. A clerk wrote their names. On the fourth day they were walked in a group to a government office in a brick building with a veranda, where an Englishman with a yellow mustache sat behind a table with an Indian clerk beside him who translated. The Englishman asked each of them their name and their father's name and their village and whether they wished to go of their own will. The clerk translated it as, "You are going willingly, yes?" Phulmati said yes. She was going to Calcutta, where the mills were. It was true. Nobody said the word Fiji in that room, or if somebody said it, it went past her like the name of a district she did not know, one more name in a day full of names.
The train to Calcutta took a day and a night. She had never been on a train. She sat on the floor of a third-class carriage with the widow's boy asleep across her feet, and through the bars of the window she watched the plain go by under its winter sun, fields and mango groves and brick kilns and villages exactly like Mahuawa, hundreds of them, each one with its own well and its own women talking at it. Then the river crossings. Then, toward evening on the second day, smoke on the horizon, and chimneys, and more people than she had seen in her life, and a smell of coal and river mud and frying oil and something sweet and rotten that she later learned was the smell of a great city's drains.
The Fiji depot was at Garden Reach, south of the city, on the bank of the Hooghly where the river is wide and brown and full of ships. It was a long walled compound with sheds of brick and tile, a cookhouse, a hospital, a bathing place, and a gate with a man at it who did not let you out. There were people from everywhere in it: Bhojpuri speakers like her from Basti and Gonda and Ghazipur and Shahabad, men from Fyzabad and Sultanpur in Awadh who spoke a little differently, a few from Bengal and Bihar and further. There were men alone and women alone and married couples and couples who had become married in the sub-depots on the way. There were children. There were people who had been brought there by an arkati and people who had come on their own because the harvest had failed, or a landlord had taken their field, or because of a debt, a quarrel, a shame, a beating, a dream.
On her second morning there a woman from Fyzabad, washing beside her at the trough, asked where she was going.
"To find my husband," Phulmati said. "At the mills."
The woman looked at her for a while with soapy hands.
"Bahin," she said. "This is the Fiji depot. Everyone here is going to Fiji."
"Where is Fiji?"
The woman did not know either. She knew it was across the kalapani. She knew it was where the ship was going. Someone in her shed had said it was a month's sail. Someone else said three months. Someone said it was near Mauritius, which people had heard of, and someone said it was not, and someone said that in Fiji they gave you land after five years, and someone said they gave you nothing. A man from Ghazipur who was sitting in the shade of the cookhouse wall mending his sandal with a strip of leather and a needle looked up and said, "It is an island. Many islands. Past the bottom of the world and up again. Five years' work and then you are free. Ten years and they send you home for nothing."
His name was Bechan. He had a mole on his right cheek and a cloth tied around his head against the river sun, and he was twenty-three, and he could read and write a little in the Kaithi script that the scribes and shopkeepers of the district used, because his father had sent him to a village teacher for two winters before the family lost its tenancy. He knew what Fiji was because he had made a man in the sub-depot at Ghazipur read his agreement paper to him twice. He did not say any of this then. He went back to his sandal.
Phulmati asked the man at the gate if she could go out to look for her husband at the mills. The man at the gate laughed, not unkindly, and said she had been registered. She asked a clerk. The clerk said she had signed. She said she had not signed, she could not write. The clerk said she had given her consent before the magistrate and that was the same thing, and anyway the mills were a long way up the river and the ship was nearly ready, and anyway, did she really think she would find one man among a hundred thousand? He said it the way you would tell a child the moon is far away. He had said it many times before.
She sat down against the wall of the women's shed and rubbed her wrist.
She could have refused. People did, sometimes. A few were sent home at the depot. Some ran. Some were found unfit by the doctor. She thought about her mother hearing it at the well, and about the way her mother-in-law would tell it, and about walking back into Mahuawa through the mustard with nothing in her hands, and about the verse at the wedding. She thought about Jagdish, whose face she had already begun to lose, though it had only been a year. She thought about the man mending his sandal, who said five years and then free.
The doctor examined them all in a long room with a window onto the river. He looked at her teeth and her eyes and pressed her belly and looked at her hands and made her stand against a painted post with marks on it, and a clerk read the marks aloud: four feet ten and a half. The doctor saw the scar and the clerk wrote it down. They gave her two new cotton saris, a blanket, a brass plate and a tin cup, a jacket against the cold of the southern sea, and a paper with her number on it. Then, on a table with an inkwell, they gave her a pen and showed her where to make the mark.
Outside the window a ship was lying in the river. It was a sailing ship with three tall masts, black-hulled, with its yards crossed and its sails furled in tidy bundles, much larger than any boat she had ever seen on the Ghaghara. The men in the shed called it the Elbe. Gulls turned over it. A little steam launch puffed around its stern.
She made the mark. It was a small cross, a little crooked, because her hand was shaking. She pressed hard. She wanted it to be there.
The Hall off Florin Road
The community hall off Florin Road was built in the 1970s for some other purpose, a lodge or a union local, and it has the soul of a place where men once played cards. It has a drop ceiling with brown water stains in the corners, wood paneling to waist height, a kitchen behind a roll-up counter, and a stage two steps high where the engagement couple sat on Saturday under an arch of plastic marigolds and fairy lights. By seven o'clock there were three hundred people in it and the windows had steamed so thoroughly that the parking lot outside, full of Camrys and pickups and somebody's rented white limousine, looked like a painting of a parking lot left in the rain.
I wore the peach one.
My mother did my dupatta in the car, pinning it at my shoulder with her lips pressed together around a safety pin, and when she was done she held my chin and turned my face to the dome light and said, "Pretty," in English, which she only uses for things she is unsure of. My father drove. Aaji sat in the back with a foil tray of gulgula on her knees, the fried sweet dough balls she makes for every gathering whether anyone asks or not, because in her view arriving without food is the same as arriving without clothes.
Inside, the noise hit like heat. A DJ was playing a Fiji Hindi wedding song remixed over a dance beat, and the little kids were already skidding across the dance floor in their socks. Along the side walls, on the folding chairs, sat the aunties. I say that with love and some terror. There were perhaps forty of them in silk and chiffon and good cardigans, in a long row, like judges at a show, with their handbags on their laps. They were the women who had come from Ba and Lautoka and Nadi and Labasa and Suva and Nausori in the eighties and nineties, after the coups, with two suitcases each and a sister's sponsorship, who had cleaned hotel rooms in Burlingame and packed peaches in Yuba City and worked night shifts at the post office sorting center in West Sacramento so their children could go to school. They had built this whole world, the halls and the groceries and the cricket club and the radio program on Sunday mornings, from nothing. They also kept track of every girl in it.
"Reshmi! Look at you!"
Shanti Auntie is not my aunt. She is not related to anyone in my family by blood or marriage, which has never once slowed her down. She is about seventy, very round, with her hair dyed a deep burgundy and a gold watch so loose it slides to her knuckles when she waves. She ran a sewing shop for twenty years and knows the measurements of half the brides in Sacramento County. She took both my hands and looked at me from top to bottom and then at my mother.
"Peach," she said, satisfied, as if she had personally caused it, which she had.
The Deo family was at a table near the stage. Mr. and Mrs. Deo were from Nausori originally and now owned a motel near the freeway in Stockton. Their son Ashneel was thirty-one and had his pharmacy license and a square, patient face, and he stood up when we came over, which I did not expect, and shook my father's hand and then, after a hesitation, mine.
The aunties watched the handshake the way people watch a free throw.
For forty minutes Ashneel and I sat side by side while the mothers talked across us about the price of houses in Elk Grove and whose daughter-in-law was from India and did not know how to make roti properly. We were given plates of goat curry, rice, dhal, pumpkin, puri, and a coleslaw that somebody had brought because coleslaw is somehow now Fiji food. We ate. He asked me what I did, and I told him about the state archives, about the reading room on O Street and the finding aids and the boxes of water board records that I was cataloging that winter, and he listened with real interest, and I liked him for it. He told me about the pharmacy, about elderly patients who came in for their blood pressure medication and stayed to talk because nobody else talked to them all week.
At the next table an uncle from Ba was telling the men about his trip home at Christmas, the potholes on the Kings Road and the price of fish, and then, in the same easy voice, about the Fijians. "Give them land, they sit on it," he said. "Grog all night, sleep all day. Our people did all the work in that country." The men laughed the way you laugh at a thing you have heard so often it has stopped being words. I had heard it my whole life too, in this hall and in our own kitchen. That winter, for the first time, I could not hear it without thinking of Sereana Koroi, who repairs paper in the conservation lab two floors below my desk. She is iTaukei and grew up in a village in Nadroga, near Sigatoka. She keeps a radio at her bench tuned to a Fiji station, she drives her younger son to rugby practice three evenings a week, and she had spent most of January rebuilding, one fiber at a time, a water board ledger that had been through a basement flood. I did not say anything to the uncle. I am not proud of that.
Then, during the speeches, when everyone was looking at the stage, he leaned toward me and said very quietly, "You should know I'm only here because my mother cried."
I laughed so suddenly that Aaji looked over.
"Same," I said.
"There's someone," he said. "In Modesto. She's not, you know." He made a small circle in the air that meant everything: not from Fiji, not Indian, not what his mother had in mind. "My parents don't know. Well. My mother knows. She doesn't know that she knows."
"I'm sorry."
"Don't be. I just didn't want you to think it was you."
When the dancing started he went to get his mother a soda and did not come back for a long time, and I did not mind. On the way out his mother kissed my cheek and told my mother that I was very sweet and very educated, and my mother took this home in the car like a bag of groceries and held it on her lap all the way down Florin Road.
"Very educated," she said in the dark. "Is that good? The way she said it?"
"It's true," my father said.
"I know it's true. I'm asking is it good."
Nobody answered. Aaji was asleep against the window with the empty gulgula tray on her knees.
I want to write down how it actually works, because people outside think it is a law, or a rule written somewhere, and it is not. Nobody in my family ever told me I could not go to UCLA. What happened was this. In March of my senior year the letter came, and I screamed in the kitchen, and my mother screamed with me and then went quiet. That night my father said, "Los Angeles," in the voice he uses for a car he does not trust. Over the next three weeks various things were said. That it was very far. That it was very expensive. That Sac State was a good school and close. That a girl alone in a big city. That the Singh girl had gone to college in Fresno and come home with a tattoo. That my grandmother was getting old and would miss me. That people would talk, a girl living away, what would they say, who would marry her. Nobody said no. They just made yes so heavy that I could not pick it up.
My brother Nitin applied to UC San Diego three years later. My father drove him down in the pickup with a mini fridge in the back. My mother cried for one night. No aunty called.
I do not blame Nitin. Nitin has said to me, more than once, that it isn't fair, and he means it, and he still lives in San Diego with his surfboard. Fairness does not move into your bedroom and change the lock.
There were other girls. Every family in our community knows the names of a few girls who could not pick the yes up and so did something else. Nisha Lal was two years ahead of me in high school. She was funny and loud and drew cartoons of the teachers in the margins of her chemistry book. Her parents found messages on her phone from a boy, a Filipino boy from her calculus class, and took the phone and took her out of school for a week and talked about sending her to Fiji to stay with an aunt in Labasa, to straighten her out. In March of 2014, when she was seventeen, Nisha got into a car with a friend and drove to Oakland and did not come back. She was not in danger, it turned out. She was at a friend's cousin's apartment, and then she was in a shelter for youth, and then she was eighteen and could not be made to do anything. But for months the aunties told her story to every girl in the community as a warning, and Nisha's mother stopped coming to the hall, and Nisha's father aged ten years in a winter. I was fifteen. I remember that in all the telling of it, at the weddings and the birthday parties, nobody ever once asked what Nisha had been so afraid of that she would rather sleep on a stranger's couch.
On the Monday after the engagement party I went to the Fiji grocery on Florin Road on my lunch break, because my mother needed cassava and a frozen kingfish and a tin of the cream crackers my father eats with butter and tea. The grocery is in a strip mall between a nail salon and a tax preparer, and it smells exactly like the market in Lautoka smells, my mother says, which I can now confirm, though I could not then. Turmeric, dried fish, incense from the shelf of brass lamps, the green smell of curry leaves and bele and dalo leaves in the cold case, the sweet heavy smell of coconut. Fiji radio was playing from a speaker over the register. A sign in English and Hindi said NO CREDIT, NOT EVEN FOR UNCLE.
At the register, Mrs. Chand, who owns the shop, rang up my cassava and asked how my mother was, and then asked how the Deo boy was.
I had been at the party fifty hours earlier. I had told no one anything. "He's very nice," I said.
"Very nice family," Mrs. Chand said, bagging the kingfish. "Motel business. Stockton is close."
Behind me a woman I did not know, about my mother's age, in a fleece jacket over a sari, said, "Which one is she? Vinod's girl?"
"Vinod and Kamala's girl," Mrs. Chand said. "The one with the government job."
"Oh," the woman said. "The older one."
The older one. As if there were a younger one coming up behind me in the line.
I drove back to O Street with the kingfish thawing in the car and sat in the parking structure for a while with the engine off. My phone buzzed. It was Daniel.
I have not mentioned Daniel yet, which tells you something. Daniel Ochoa is thirty and teaches tenth-grade world history at a public high school in the city, and I met him two and a half years ago in the reading room at the archives, where he came on a Saturday to look at the records of the Japanese American internment for a unit he was building for his students. He asked me so many questions that I missed my lunch. He has a soft voice and very good handwriting and a grandmother in Fresno who came from Michoacán and still makes him take tamales home in a cooler at Christmas. My family does not know he exists. My brother knows. Nisha knows. My father's younger brother's daughter Tanvi, who is fifteen, knows, because she found a photo on my phone, and she has kept it to herself with a fierce, solemn loyalty that I find both touching and alarming.
The message said: How was the motel prince?
I wrote back: Nice. Also secretly in love with someone in Modesto.
He sent back a laughing face and then, a minute later: Are you okay though.
I sat there with the windows fogging and the kingfish leaking through its bag onto the floor mat and did not know how to answer that.
That night, after everyone was asleep, I opened the family calendar that I had made two years earlier so my aunts and uncles would stop missing each other's birthdays. It has the birthdays and the anniversaries, Aja's death day in October, the dates of the big weddings, Fiji Day on the tenth of October, the date Aaji landed at San Francisco in 2001.
I added a new date in March, with a note: Around this week in 1896, the Elbe left Calcutta with Phulmati on it. She was nineteen.
Then I added one in June: 13 June 1896. Elbe arrived Fiji.
Then I sat for a long time looking at the March entry. In a hundred and thirty years nobody in my family had marked the day she left. They had marked the day she arrived, in a way, every time they told the found-a-ship sentence. But the leaving was the brave part. The leaving was the part where she walked away from the well and everything everyone would say, and nobody had ever thought it was worth a date.
I set the reminder to go to everybody.
The Black Water
Built from a page of the ship's register of the Elbe, 1896, copied into the colony's immigration records at Suva: departed Garden Reach in March, arrived 13 June. Landed, six hundred and fifteen. Under Remarks, in a small hand: No. 211 and No. 340, Phulmati and Bechan, declared themselves man and wife at Nukulau, allotted together. A copy of the page sits in the family's records now, under both their names.
The steam tug took the Elbe down the Hooghly on a falling tide, past the mud flats and the fishing villages on stilts and the long green line of the Sundarbans, and the river widened until it had no far bank at all and its brown water met a water that was gray-green and moved differently, lifting the ship from underneath like a hand. That was the moment the women in the aft quarters began to cry. Not all of them, and not loudly. They had been told it would be the kalapani, the black water, and they had expected it to be black. It was green. It was worse, somehow, that it was green.
The ship was laid out like a village with the walls taken down. The single men slept forward in the 'tween decks on long wooden platforms, two tiers of them, each person given a space a little wider than the shoulders. The married couples were in the middle. The single women and the girls were aft, behind a partition, near the hospital and the cabin of the surgeon-superintendent, a gray Scottish doctor named Harcourt who walked through the women's quarters every morning with a lantern and a notebook and a matron at his heels and asked in bad Hindustani whether anyone had a fever or a flux. On deck there were the galleys, where Indian cooks chosen from among the emigrants made rice and dal in great iron pots, and there were water casks, and a place to wash, and the whole open sea on every side.
Phulmati was sick for nine days. She lay on her platform with her lota beside her and her bundle under her head and listened to the timbers groan and the sea hiss along the hull a foot from her ear, and she vomited into a tin basin that the matron emptied over the side, and she thought she would die and was not sure she minded. The widow from Gonda, whose name was Ramdei, held her head. Ramdei's boy Chhotu, who was five and was not sick at all, sat at the foot of the platform and told her the names of the ropes, which he had learned from a lascar, getting them all wrong.
On the tenth day she went up on deck and the sun was out and the sea was a blue she had no word for. There was no green in it now and no brown, only blue, deep and moving and going down forever, with white along the tops of the waves and flying fish skittering over it like thrown stones. Bechan was sitting by the mainmast with his back against the fife rail, mending something again, a basket this time. He looked up and said, "You're alive."
"Nearly," she said.
He gave her a piece of dried mango from his bundle. It was the first food that stayed down.
People on that ship lost things and found things. They lost the rules of their villages, at least some of them, at least for the length of the voyage. There was one galley for everyone, one water cask, and people who in their villages would never have shared a well found themselves in the same line for the same ladle of dal, and after a week they stopped minding, or stopped minding as much, or minded in silence. They found new people. Girls who had come alone attached themselves to older women. Old men who had been nobody in their villages became the ones who knew stories, and young men sat around them in the evenings on the hatches while the sun went down red behind the ship and the sails above them turned from white to pink to gray.
They called each other jahaji. Jahaji bhai, ship brother. Jahaji bahin, ship sister. It was a word that would outlast the ship by a hundred years and more. On the island it would mean a kind of family that was stronger, in some ways, than the families they had left, because nobody had chosen it and everybody needed it.
Bechan sang. He had a thin, true voice that carried over the sea noise without being loud. He sang the songs of the Bhojpuri country that everyone on that ship already knew in some form, the bidesiya songs, songs of a wife whose husband has gone away to earn money in a far country, to the east, to Calcutta, to the mills, and does not come back, and she stands at the door every evening and watches the road. Everyone sang the refrain with him. Phulmati sang it once and then stopped, and he noticed, and the next evening he sang something else, a song about a parrot who flies away and lands on the wrong tree, which made everyone laugh.
Below the songs, at night, there were other sounds. A ship like that held hundreds of people who had been lied to in a dozen different ways and were only now, at sea, adding up the lies. A man who had been told he was going to work in a post office. A woman who had been told she would be a cook in a house in Calcutta. A boy of seventeen who had been told nothing at all, only given food and a place to sleep at a railway station and woken up in a depot. Some had come knowing exactly what Fiji was and choosing it anyway, because the landlord, the drought, the debt, the hunger at home were worse. Some had lied to the recruiter about their ages, their names, their villages, to get away from something. Some were fine. Some screamed in their sleep. Dr. Harcourt wrote it all down in his notebook as fever, flux, debility, homesickness, and gave out quinine and lime juice and kept the ship cleaner than most, which was why, on a voyage of three months, the register at the end would show fewer deaths than many other ships of that season. Fewer was not none. Two old men and one infant did not reach Fiji, and those nights the singing stopped, and Ramdei kept Chhotu close against her on the platform under her own blanket.
They crossed the line. They went south into a region where the wind died for days and the sails hung and the pitch softened in the deck seams under their feet, and then south again into a cold that none of them had known could exist. Somewhere far below Australia, in the roaring belt of the westerlies, the ship ran for two weeks before a gray sea as tall as a house, with the rain coming sideways and sleet in the rigging some mornings, and all the emigrants wore the jackets the depot had given them and were still cold. Phulmati, who had never been colder than a winter dawn in Basti, lay under her blanket and Ramdei's blanket and shook. Bechan came aft as far as he was allowed, to the partition, every evening, and called through it to ask if she was all right. The matron allowed it. She had seen a lot of it.
It was during those weeks, in the cold and the noise, that Phulmati told him about Jagdish.
She told him on deck, during a calm afternoon, with her back to the rail and her arms folded. She told him about the mills and the man with the cough and the wedding verse and her mother-in-law counting rotis. She told him she had left without telling her mother. She did not cry. She told it like someone reciting the price of grain.
Bechan listened with his hands still. When she finished he said, "So you are married."
"I don't know what I am."
He looked out at the sea for a long time. Then he said, "In Fiji, they say, nobody knows anybody's story. They say a man can be anybody there. A woman can be anybody."
"They also say they give you land," she said. "And they say they send you home for free."
He laughed, a short surprised laugh. "That's true," he said. "They say a lot."
Eleven weeks out the air changed again. It grew soft and warm and wet. Birds came, and floating seaweed, and once, far off, a green smudge that the sailors said was an island but not theirs. And then on the morning of the thirteenth of June, a Saturday, though nobody on the platforms knew what day it was, the people on deck saw mountains.
They came up out of the sea in layers, dark green and blue and gray, the far ones lost in cloud, the near ones so green they looked wet, which they were. A line of white surf ran in front of them where the sea broke on a reef. Rain hung over the hills in long gray curtains and the sun came through it in places and lit up the slopes like lamps. The air smelled of earth and rot and flowers. Someone said Fiji. Then everyone said it, up and down the deck, Fiji, Fiji, as if it were a word they had just learned, which in a way they had.
The ship did not go to the town. It anchored inside the reef off a small flat island near Suva harbor, a low sandy place with coconut palms leaning over the water and a cluster of white buildings and a jetty. Nukulau. That was where they were landed in boats, counted, washed, examined, fed, and kept for some days in the depot sheds while the doctors watched for fever. The ground did not move under their feet and many of them fell down the first time they stood on it. It rained most afternoons, a heavy warm rain that hammered the iron roofs, and steam rose off the grass and the palms dripped and the mosquitoes came out in clouds.
On the third day an official from the Immigration Department came with clerks and a list. It was time for the allotment. The plantations had already asked for so many men and so many women, and the department would decide who went where. The names were read out in the yard under the rain trees. Couples who had married or declared themselves married would be sent together. Single men and single women would be sent where the numbers said.
Phulmati stood beside Ramdei, with Chhotu holding her sari. She watched the clerk's mouth. She heard a man's name called for the Rewa, another for Navua, for Labasa across the sea on the other island, for Ba. She thought about the far side of a sea she had not known existed, about being a single woman in a line of strangers on one of those estates, about what people said a single woman was, on a ship or off it, and how much worse it was here, where there were more than two men for every woman.
Bechan came across the yard to her. He did not ask anything. He stood beside her. When the clerk came to the end of the list of single women and was about to read the next names, Bechan stepped forward and said, in a clear voice, in Bhojpuri, that number three hundred and forty and number two hundred and eleven were man and wife, and wished to be sent together.
The clerk looked up. The official looked at Phulmati. He asked her, through the interpreter, whether this was true.
She thought, for one second, of her mother at the well. Then she said yes.
That was what went into the Remarks. Man and wife. It was the second mark she had made in a book of the government, and it was made with her voice instead of a pen, and it was, she would say long afterward, the only time in those years that anybody asked her what she wanted and wrote down the answer.
Three days later a small coastal steamer took them around the western side of the big island, past mangrove swamps and grassy hills burned brown, past beaches and reefs and a long dry coast where the cane began, green and endless, all the way to the hills. At the mouth of a wide brown river they were put into punts and poled upstream. On the bank, through the cane, they saw a tall brick chimney with smoke coming out of it, and heard the sound of machinery that never stopped. The mill at Rarawai. A cart track led away from the river between walls of cane twelve feet high. At the end of it, on a bare patch of trodden earth, stood a long low building of wood and corrugated iron divided into many doors, with a cookhouse behind it and a row of latrines and a water tank on a stand. A man on a horse was waiting for them in a white helmet. Beside him on foot was an Indian man with a stick.
The man with the stick read their numbers from a paper. Then he said, in Hindustani with an accent from Awadh, "This is the Number Four lines. This is where you live. Tomorrow you work."
Aaji's Voice
In March the fog burned off and the valley turned green almost overnight, the way it does here, as if somebody had been waiting behind a door with a paint bucket. The almond orchards out toward Galt went white with blossom. The mustard came up in the vineyards along Highway 99 between the bare black rows of vines, so yellow it looked lit from below. I drove past it every weekend that month on the way to nowhere in particular and thought about Mahuawa, which I had never seen, and the mustard along its field edges, which I knew only from one sentence in an old district gazetteer.
I asked Aaji on the first Saturday of March if I could record her properly. Not on my phone in the kitchen while she sang to herself. Properly, sitting down, with the little microphone I borrowed from work clipped to her cardigan, telling the stories from the beginning.
"Kahe?" she said, which is what she always says. Why.
"For Tanvi," I said. "For Rohit. For my kids, if I have any."
"If," said Aaji, and gave me a long look, and then said, "All right. But you ask first every time. And if I say stop, you stop. And if I say something about somebody who is still alive, you don't play it to anybody."
"Agreed."
"And I am not wearing my teeth."
"Aaji, it's sound only."
"I know what it is," she said. "I'm telling you."
So we sat in the back room that used to be my father's den and became Aaji's room in 2001, with the bed made tight with a Fiji bedspread printed with hibiscus, and the window open to the yard where my father's lemon tree was in flower, and the small heater ticking. She sat in her chair. I sat on the floor with the recorder on the carpet between us. Tanvi was there too, the first two Saturdays, cross-legged on the bed with her phone face down beside her as a sign of great respect. Tanvi turned sixteen on the eleventh of March. She is tall already, taller than her mother, with long arms and a laugh like a car horn, and she builds robots with her school team and wants to study engineering at a school as far from Sacramento as the map allows. She has not told her father that last part.
Aaji's voice on those recordings is lower than it is in life, and slower. When I play them now I can hear the heater ticking under it, and the mockingbird in the lemon tree, and Tanvi breathing.
"I was born in 1940," she says on the first one, "in Ba. Not in the town. On my father's farm on the Tavua side, on leased land. My father grew cane and rice. Ten acres. My mother had nine children and six lived. I was number four."
She tells about school. There was a school three miles away, first a little country school and then one the Indian community built itself with money they raised one shilling at a time. She walked there barefoot with her brothers. She loved it. She loved arithmetic most, and she loved the English reader with the pictures of children in coats in snow. In class six, when she was thirteen, her father took her out.
On the recording I ask why.
"Why," she says, and laughs, a dry little laugh. "Because a big girl walking three miles past the Fijian village and past the Gujarati shop and past the men cutting cane, people talk. Because who will marry a girl who walks around. Because my brothers needed the school fees more. Because. You know the because. You know it better than me."
I did not say anything on the tape. You can hear me not saying anything.
"I wanted to be a teacher," she says. "In the school in Ba town there was a lady teacher, Miss Devi, she wore a watch. I wanted the watch more than the teaching, maybe. No. I wanted the teaching."
She tells about her marriage in 1958, at eighteen, to Ramsewak Narayan, who was twenty-four and had his own bullock team and the lease on twelve acres up the Ba river at a place everyone called Nine Mile, because it was nine miles from the town by the river road. She saw him twice before the wedding. Once at a cousin's wedding across a yard full of people, once through the window of a bus. The marriage was arranged by her father and his father over three visits and a great deal of grog. She left her father's house in a hired truck with a trunk and a sewing machine.
"And that," she says, "is where I met Phulmati."
Phulmati was eighty-one in 1958, Aaji says, and the paper in my folder agrees, more or less. She was the grandmother of the man Aaji had married. She lived in the farmhouse at Nine Mile, which was a wooden house on posts with an iron roof and a long veranda facing the river, and she sat on that veranda all day on a mat with her knees up, because her hips were bad, and her eyes were going, one of them white already. She had been a widow for twelve years. Bechan had died in 1946.
"Small," Aaji says. "Itna sa. Like a girl. Her arms were like this." On the tape there is a pause while she shows us with her fingers. "But her voice. Baap re. Her voice was loud. She could call the cows from the river."
The new bride was given the hardest work and the least food, which was how it was done. She woke at four to grind the spices and light the fire. She fetched water from the tank. She did the washing at the river with a paddle. Her mother-in-law, Phulmati's daughter-in-law, a tired, hard-pressed woman with six children of her own, did not speak to her except to correct her for most of the first year.
The only one who talked to her was the old woman on the veranda.
"She called me over the first week," Aaji says. "She said, You. New bride. Come here and shell these peas with me, I can't see them. So I went. And she started talking. Talking, talking. All about Calcutta, the ship, the lines. Every afternoon. Maybe because nobody else would listen any more. They had heard it. Her son had heard it fifty years. Her grandson, your Aja, he would say, Aaji, enough, the ship again. So she told me. And she taught me the songs while we shelled the peas, because she said I sang too badly to be left alone with them."
Tanvi laughed on the bed. On the recording you can hear it, a short bark.
"What songs?" I ask.
"The old ones. The village ones. The ones from over there. Biraha, the long ones the men sang in the fields. Kajri for the rain. The songs for the wedding, the gaari, the cheeky ones where you insult the groom's family. Sohar, when a baby comes. And the bidesiya ones. She had a lot of those. The wife waiting for the husband."
There is a long pause on the tape.
"She told me about her first husband one day," Aaji says. "Only once. Jagdish. She said she went to Calcutta to find him and found a ship. You know that. Then she said she used to think about him in the cane, the first years. Whether he was looking for her. Whether he came back to Mahuawa and heard at the well that she had run away to the islands. What he thought. Whether he married again. And then one day, she said, in the lines, after her son was born, she was cutting cane, and she realized she couldn't remember his face at all. Not at all. And she felt so free, she said, she sat down in the cane row and laughed until the sirdar came."
"Did she ever find out what happened to him?"
"Never. How? No letters. She couldn't write. Later Bechan wrote one letter for her, to her mother, to Mahuawa, through a man going home. No answer ever came. Maybe the letter didn't arrive. Maybe her mother was dead. Maybe they didn't want to answer a woman who had crossed the kalapani. You understand? To them she was gone. Finished."
I stopped the recorder there because Aaji asked me to, and she sat for a while with her hands in her lap, looking at the lemon tree. Then she said, "Turn it on again," and sang one of the bidesiya songs straight through, all the verses, in a voice that had gone thin and high. I understood perhaps half of it. The Bhojpuri of the songs is older than the Fiji Hindi I grew up with. Words have shifted, grown together, dropped off. Tanvi understood less. She sat with her knees pulled up and her chin on them and did not move until it was done.
That night I made a list, a list that has since grown to over three hundred lines: every word from the recordings that I did not know, with Aaji's own voice saying it, clipped out of the long recording and set beside it, and the meaning as best she could give it. Bidesiya, a man gone to a far country. Kalapani, the black water. Jahaji, ship brother, ship sister. Kulambar, the overseer, the white man on the horse. Sirdar, the Indian foreman with the stick. Girmit, the agreement, the five years, the word the whole thing was named for, because the people who signed could not say agreement and so said girmit, and their children and grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren became girmitiya, people of the agreement. Lain, the lines, the long buildings with many doors. I typed Tanvi's name on the list as an editor and she added a word the next day, a word from one of the songs that she had asked Aaji about separately, by herself: bhauji, brother's wife. I do not know why that one. I did not ask.
On the second Tuesday of March I drove Aaji to the mandali at the hall. The women's group meets every Tuesday afternoon, about thirty older women and a few men, and they sing and drink tea and eat whatever somebody brought and exchange the week's news, which is the main thing. Aaji has gone for nearly twenty-five years. I sit in the car and read until she calls.
That Tuesday I went in to bring her the cardigan she had forgotten, and I saw Usha Auntie.
Usha Raj sat at the end of the second row of folding chairs, a little apart. There were two empty chairs on either side of her. She is about sixty, thin, with very short gray hair that she stopped dyeing nine years ago. She held her teacup in both hands and looked at the floor.
Her son Avinash, Avi, was a year ahead of me in school. He was gentle and very funny and he could draw anything, cars, faces, the cartoon of the principal that got him suspended in ninth grade. His father had a small electronics store on Stockton Boulevard and wanted Avi to be a doctor, and when Avi got into a pre-med program at a college in the city, his father told everyone at every wedding for a year. In February of 2017, during his second year, Avi died. He was nineteen. The family said at first it was an accident, and then they stopped saying anything, and the community understood, and the understanding went around the hall and the groceries and the weddings in a whisper that never once said the word.
The funeral was enormous. After that the family was not invited to things for a long time. Not on purpose. Nobody decided it. People just did not know what to say to them, so they did not say anything, and then they did not call, and then they did not invite, and nine years went by. Avi's father sold the store and works at a warehouse in West Sacramento on the night shift. Usha Auntie comes to the mandali every Tuesday and sits with two empty chairs on either side of her.
Aaji saw me see it. She took the cardigan out of my hands. Then she walked down the row of chairs, slowly, with her cane, and sat down in the empty chair next to Usha Auntie, and put one hand on Usha Auntie's knee, and left it there, and started talking about the weather.
On the way home I asked her about it.
"Nobody sits with her," Aaji said. "They talk to her. Very sweet. But they don't sit. Like it's catching."
"Was it always like that? In Fiji?"
She thought about it for a whole traffic light on Mack Road.
"In Fiji," she said, "in the lines, when someone died like that, the old ones said it was the girmit that killed them. Not the person. The girmit. Too much work, too much shame, too far from home, too many men and too few women, too much drink. They blamed the girmit." She was quiet. "Here we have no girmit to blame. So we blame the family. And the family blames itself. And nobody sits."
"Aaji."
"I'm old," she said. "I'm allowed to sit wherever I want."
At home I played the day's bidesiya recording for my mother while she chopped onions. She listened to the whole thing with her back to me. When it ended she said, without turning, "My Paati used to sing like that. Not those songs. Tamil ones. I don't know the words to any of them."
It was the first time in my life I had heard her say it like a loss.
The Room Ten Feet by Seven
Built from a line in a printed government return, Prosecutions under the Indian Immigration Ordinance, Ba District, 1899, found in a bound volume at the archives in Suva: Phulmati, No. 211, Number Four estate, Rarawai. Charge: failure to complete task. Fined five shillings. And from the brass lota she carried from Mahuawa, dented on one side, which now sits on a shelf in Sacramento with its history written on a card beside it.
The room was ten feet long and seven feet wide. Phulmati paced it the first night in the dark because she could not believe it, heel to toe, heel to toe, and then across, and it was true. It had an earth floor and walls of rough sawn planks that did not reach the iron roof, so that the sound and the smoke and the smells of the rooms on either side came over the top all night. It had one door and no window. It had a shelf. There were sixteen rooms in the long building, back to back, eight facing the cane and eight facing the cookhouse, and in that first season there were forty-one people living in them: married couples, and single men four to a room, and three single women in one room at the end, and a family with a baby, and Ramdei and Chhotu in a room with a woman from Shahabad who wept every night for a month and then stopped and never wept again.
They called it the lain, from the English word lines. Everyone on every estate in Fiji called it the lain. The sound of it was the sound of the whole life: the bell at four in the morning, the sirdar banging a stick on the iron at half past four, the cough of forty people waking in a single building, the fires lit in the cookhouse, the smell of smoke and parched rice and the latrines, the cane rustling all around in the dark like water, and the first light coming up red over the hills behind the mill.
The task was the measure of everything. Each morning the overseer, the kulambar, an Australian named Fenwick who sat a big gray horse and wore a white helmet and a pistol and rarely got down, gave out the day's work through the sirdar. A task was a length of field: so many chains of cane to weed, so many yards of drain to dig, so many rows to trash or to hoe or to plant. The law said a task was what an able-bodied worker could finish in six hours of steady labor. The task was set by the estate. If you did not finish it, you were not paid for the day, and you might be charged in the court at Ba for failure to complete task, and fined, and the fine was more than the day's wage. Men were paid a shilling a day when they finished. Women nine pence. For the first six months the estate took the cost of rations out of the wage, rice and dal and ghee and salt and a little oil, and so in the first six months many of them ended the week with nothing at all, and some with debts.
Phulmati was put on weeding with the women. They worked in a line under the high cane with their saris tucked up and their heads wrapped against the sun, pulling grass and creepers from between the young plants with their hands and with small hoes, and the leaves of the cane cut their arms with a hundred fine cuts that stung with sweat and closed and opened again. The heat in the cane rows in the wet season was a heat she had not known existed even in the worst May in Basti. There was no wind down there. The air was wet and heavy and full of the green smell of growing cane and the black smell of the soil. Rain came in the afternoons in a roar, warm as bathwater, and the drains filled, and the women kept working in it because the task was the task.
Bechan was put on digging. He came back to the room at night with his hands bloody and his shoulders so stiff he could not lift his arms to wash his face, and Phulmati washed it for him with water from the lota, and he slept like a dropped stone. In the first month he was fined twice. The second time he spent a night in the lock-up in Ba because he could not pay, and came back with a look on his face that did not leave it for a long time.
They were not married in any book but the immigration register, and the immigration register said they were, so they were. They became married the way people do, slowly, by being tired in the same room. He could read, which almost nobody in the lines could, and so he became the one people came to with papers, with a letter that someone had got from home through the post office at Ba and could not open alone. He read them aloud in the evening outside the room, and she sat beside him and listened to other people's news from villages she would never see. Sometimes the news was good. More often it was a death, a debt, a field lost, a wife remarried, a mother asking when the money would come. Then he would read slowly, and fold the letter carefully, and give it back with both hands.
There were things that happened in the lines that people did not say out loud even there. There were too few women, and too many men, and the men were young and far from home and worked half to death and drank the cheap rum from the canteen when they could. There were sirdars who gave light tasks to women who did what they wanted and heavy tasks to women who did not. There were overseers like that too. Phulmati learned early which field to avoid being sent to alone and which sirdar to keep another woman beside her near, and when Ramdei came back one evening from the far field without speaking and lay down in her room with her face to the wall, Phulmati took Chhotu into her own room for the night and sat in the doorway between the two rooms until morning with a cane knife across her knees, and nobody asked her why, and Ramdei never told, and she never asked.
These are the things, Aaji would say to me a hundred and twenty years later, that Phulmati told her once on the veranda and then said, now forget them. Aaji never forgot them. She only told me a few. I have written down fewer.
But it is not true that there was nothing else. That is the other thing Aaji insisted on, and I believe her. There were the evenings. After the cookhouse fires were banked and the light went from gold to violet over the cane, people sat outside the rooms on the trodden earth and somebody had a drum, a dholak made from a hollowed log and goatskin, and somebody had a pair of small brass cymbals, and somebody always started singing. Men from five districts and women from seven, with their seven kinds of Bhojpuri and Awadhi and the bits of Bengali and the bits of Hindustani from the depot, sang the songs they all half knew, and changed the words where they differed, and argued about it, and laughed. Within a year the singing at Number Four was its own thing, a little different from anyone's village. Within a generation the language was its own thing too. Fiji Hindi was being made out there in the evenings, in the lain, out of everybody's broken pieces.
Phulmati started making up verses. They were small and rude and very funny. They were about the overseer's horse, which was fat, and about the sirdar's walk, and about the canteen rum, and about a particular cane field so full of creepers that the women called it the mother-in-law's hair. People repeated them. On Sundays, the one free day, women from Number Three lines came to sit with women from Number Four, and they sang Phulmati's verses back to her, wrong, and she corrected them.
On Sundays too there were the Fijians.
The land the estate was on had been Fijian land, and the villages were still there, on the hills behind the cane and along the river, with their thatched houses and their gardens of dalo and yams and cassava and bananas. In the first year the people of the lines were afraid of them, because the estate had told them to be, and because nobody in the lines understood a word of their language. Then a man from the nearest village, a big man named Seru with a gray beard and a boatman's shoulders who worked sometimes as a boatman on the river for the mill, came walking along the cart track one Sunday with a bundle of dalo on his shoulder and stopped at the cookhouse and made signs that he wanted to trade for salt and for a little of the cooked dal, which he had smelled from the road. Bechan traded with him. Seru did not work in the cane. The government kept the Fijians in their villages under their chiefs, and the estates were not to hire them for field work, so Seru had his own work that nobody at Number Four ever saw: the village gardens, the fishing, the house he was building for his married daughter, the share of the crop the village owed the government as tax. The next Sunday Seru came back with bananas and a woman who wanted cloth. In a year people from Number Four were going up to the village with salt and cloth and coming back with dalo and fish, and a few words of each language had crossed over in each direction. Ni sa bula, the Fijians said, which the people of the lines shortened to bula, hello, life. Vinaka, thank you. The people of the lines taught them roti. The Fijians taught them to eat dalo leaves cooked in coconut cream, which the people of the lines called by the Fijian name and later made with their own spices, so that the dish belonged to both. Seru's great-grandson, seventy-odd years later, would sit across a table in the district office at Ba from Phulmati's grandson on the day the last lease on Nine Mile was signed, and they would shake hands as if they had known each other all their lives, which they had.
In the third year Phulmati was pregnant.
She did not tell the sirdar for a long time, because pregnant women were given lighter tasks but also lower pay, and she needed the pay, and because she had seen how the sirdar looked at pregnant women, as though they were a bad bargain. She kept up her task through the fifth month and into the sixth. In the seventh month, in the hot wet weeks before Christmas of 1899, she fell behind on a field of heavy weeds and could not finish, two days in a row, and on the third day the sirdar wrote her name in his book.
The court at Ba was a wooden building with a veranda, near the river, with a flagpole and a clock. She stood in a room full of people from many estates, all charged with something, failure to complete task, unlawful absence, refusal to work, insolence, and when her number was read she stood up with her hands on her belly and the magistrate looked at her over his spectacles for perhaps four seconds and said five shillings. The interpreter said five shillings. Nobody asked her anything. It was more than she earned in a good week. Bechan paid it out of the money he had been saving in a tin under the floor of their room for a pair of bullocks for when they were free.
Their son was born in March of 1900, in the room in the lain, at night, in the rain, with Ramdei and the woman from Shahabad helping and Chhotu, who was nine by then, sent outside to sit with Bechan under the cookhouse roof. They named him Ramdeo. He was small and furious and very loud. The women of the lines sang the sohar for him, the birth songs, the ones from home, all night, over the sound of the rain on the roof, and the men sat outside and smoked and argued about whether the baby looked like the father, and Phulmati lay on the earth floor of the room ten feet by seven with her son on her chest and thought that nobody in Mahuawa would ever know his name.
Their five years ended in June of 1901.
A clerk came out from the immigration office and checked their numbers and their records, and gave them each a paper, a certificate saying they had completed their term of industrial service. They were free. They could re-indenture for more money, which many did. They could go to the towns. They could take up land. If they stayed in the colony another five years as free workers, they would earn the right to a passage back to India at the colony's expense. That was the agreement. Ten years and home.
Bechan held the two papers in his hands outside the room in the lain with the baby asleep inside and read them to her twice.
"Ten years," he said. "Five more, and we can go home."
Phulmati looked at the cane, which was in flower that month, a sea of silver-gray plumes moving in the trade wind all the way to the hills.
"Home where?" she said.
He did not answer. He folded the papers and put them in the tin under the floor with what was left of the bullock money. They stayed at Number Four for four more years as free workers on wages, and then, in 1905, with Seru standing beside them at the district office because the land belonged to his people, they took a lease on eight acres of river flat at Nine Mile, and built a house of wood on posts with an iron roof, with a veranda facing the river.
Ten years came, in 1906. Some of the people from the Elbe took the passage home. Ramdei did, with Chhotu, who was fifteen and spoke Fiji Hindi and three words of Fijian and remembered nothing of India but a railway carriage and a gate. Phulmati walked with them to the jetty at Ba and watched the punt go down the river toward the steamer and the sea, and went back to Nine Mile, and did not go.
The lota went to Nine Mile with her. It went everywhere. It held the water she washed Bechan's face with in the lain, and the water she washed Ramdeo with the night he was born, and later the water for the cows, and much later the water her grandson's widow sprinkled on the dust of the yard when the house at Nine Mile was given up. It has a dent in one side from the day Phulmati threw it at the sirdar. Aaji says that is a different story, and that she will tell it to me when I am married. I have told her that may be a long time. She says she is in no hurry.
The Horse Song
I turned twenty-eight on the third of April, a Friday, at my desk in the reading room with a cupcake my coworker Lorna had left by my keyboard with a single candle she was not allowed to light.
My cousin Rohit had made a page for the day, the way the cousins do for each other now, a private page only the family can open, with an old photo of me at four in a frilly yellow dress on my father's shoulders at the Fiji Day picnic in William Land Park, and a place under it for wishes. By noon there were thirty-one. Nitin had written: Happy birthday to the only person who has ever read the instructions. Tanvi had written a long paragraph in Fiji Hindi, misspelled in three places, which made me put my head down on the desk. Paati had sent a voice message from Lautoka singing the birthday song in English and then saying something in Tamil that my mother later translated as "May you live long and keep your hair." Kaka Anil had written: Happy birthday beta. Shanti Auntie, who is not my aunt, who is not related to me, who should never have been given the link, had written: Happy Birthday dear Reshmi!!! May you find a good boy SOON!!!
I read it nine times. Then I laughed out loud in the reading room, and a researcher turned around and stared at me over his reading glasses.
The wedding was two weeks later, at a banquet hall in Elk Grove with a fountain out front and a parking lot as big as a cane field. The bride was Priyanka Kumar, the daughter of my mother's oldest friend in Sacramento, a family from Lautoka who had lived two streets over from us since before I was born. Three nights of it. Thursday the haldi, with turmeric paste and the bride in an old yellow sari and all the women smearing it on her and each other and then on the cousins who came too close. Friday the mehndi night, women only, in the Kumars' garage, which had been emptied and hung with orange and pink cloth and had a rented heater going and fifty women sitting on rugs on the concrete floor. Saturday the wedding.
It was at the mehndi night that I sang.
I had not planned to. The singing that night was the old kind, the women's songs, sung to a dholak played by an auntie from Nadi who had played every mehndi night in Sacramento for thirty years, with a spoon tapping on a steel water pot for the beat. They sang the wedding songs and then they sang the gaari, the teasing songs that insult the groom's family. The bride's side sings that the groom's mother has a mouth like a drain, the groom's father snores like a bullock, the groom himself was found under a cabbage. The groom's side was not there to answer, so they insulted themselves, which is also traditional. Aaji sat in a plastic chair near the heater, because her knees do not do rugs, and sang every song in her high thin voice, and looked as happy as I have ever seen her.
During a pause, while the dholak auntie drank her tea, Aaji poked me with her cane and said, "Sing the horse one."
"Aaji, no."
"Sing it."
The horse one is one of Phulmati's verses. Aaji had taught it to me in March during the recordings. It is about an overseer's horse that is so fat it can only walk downhill, and so the overseer can only inspect fields that are lower than the lines, and so the women who work uphill have the easiest life on the estate. It is not a great song. But it has a good tune, and the last line, which is about what the horse eats, is very rude.
I sang it. My voice shook for the first verse. By the third the dholak auntie had found the beat and was playing under me. When I got to the rude line, there was a shriek from the back of the garage, and an old woman I had never seen before, tiny, in a white sari and a man's gray cardigan, pushed herself up off the rug with both hands and shouted, in Fiji Hindi, "That's a Ba song! Who taught you that? My mother sang that! In Ba!"
She was ninety-one. Her name was Mrs. Bhagwati Prasad. She had grown up on an estate two miles from Number Four. Her mother had been born in those lines in 1912, to parents who came on a ship in 1905. She knew a different version of the verse, with a different overseer and a different rude line, and she sang it for us, standing, holding the back of Aaji's chair, and the whole garage roared. Then she and Aaji sat together for an hour comparing versions, two very old women from the same river valley who had never met, arguing about a horse that had been dead for a hundred and twenty years.
I recorded it. I asked first. Mrs. Prasad said, "Record, record! Who cares! Put it on the radio!"
It was also at the mehndi night that I saw the Union City sisters, Radhika and Seemi and Kimi, for the first time in a couple of years.
Everyone in the Fiji community between Sacramento and the Bay knows everyone else at one remove, through a wedding or a cousin or a school in Lautoka. The Kumars were related on the bride's mother's side to a family in Union City who had come over from Fiji in about 1984, early, before the coups, when Radhika, the eldest daughter, was eight. Radhika was born in Nadi. Her father was a Suva man, born and raised there, and my mother's older sister had been in the same class at school in Lautoka as Radhika's mother's cousin, which, in our world, makes them practically sisters. I had grown up seeing that family at three or four weddings a year: the father in a pressed shirt doing the dancing nobody else would do, the mother cool and kind and watchful, the three daughters.
Radhika is small, about Aaji's height, with long curly hair that she wears loose and that has not gone gray anywhere I could see, though she must be fifty. She had married into a big Punjabi family over on the coast years ago and had come up for the wedding on her own, she said, because the coast lot were all busy with something. She sat on the rug with her legs folded under her and a pair of small girls from the bride's side asleep against her, and when the dancing started she put the girls down on a pile of cushions and danced better than anyone in the garage. Her sister Seemi, the middle one, who was born in Fiji and came over as a toddler, was there too, and the youngest, Kimi, who was born here, in the Bay Area, after the family had come, and is about ten years older than me.
I knew the facts about them the way you know the facts about the people in your community: that all three girls had gone to college, and then further, and had careers they had chosen and liked and were good at; that none of them had been married off at twenty-one, and the sky had not fallen; that their parents had never seemed, at any wedding, to be ashamed of anything. I knew the aunties discussed them. I had not known, until that night, how the aunties discussed them, which was with a kind of baffled respect, the way people talk about a neighbor whose tomatoes do better than theirs. The aunties had their explanations. The parents had known each other before they married, they said, as if that settled it. And both of them had worked in Fiji, the mother as well as the father, in proper jobs, back when hardly any married women there did. "So what do you expect," Shanti Auntie said once, at a wedding, and nobody could tell whether she meant it as a complaint.
Kimi found me by the table of sweets in the driveway. She had a paper plate with three pieces of barfi on it and was eating them in order of color.
"That horse song," she said. "Is that real? Is that from an actual estate?"
I told her about the pass, the four feet ten and a half, the line in the immigration return. I told her about Mrs. Prasad's mother. She listened with her whole face.
"My grandmother used to tell us stuff like that," she said. "About the lines. My mother has some of it written down. Not the songs, though. We lost the songs." She ate the pink barfi. "You should get all of that down while they're alive. Both of them. Your grandmother and that tiny lady."
"I'm trying."
She looked at me sideways. "Are you getting the marriage talk?"
I must have made a face, because she laughed.
"I got it too," she said. "Not from my parents. From everybody else. Our parents never once did that to us. My mother always said, You girls study. You work. You'll get married when you get married. The culture's not going anywhere. You're not going to lose it by going to school. And people said, oh, the Union City girls, they're too free, they'll never marry, they'll forget everything. And look." She waved her plate at the garage, where her eldest sister was teaching a row of teenage girls the steps to an old Fiji Hindi film song, laughing, her curls flying. "Nobody forgot anything. My mother still makes the best lolo bhaji in the Bay. We all speak it. We all still come to this. We just also have jobs we like."
"How did your parents do it?" I said. "With everyone talking?"
Kimi thought about it.
"I think they just decided," she said, "early, that they cared more about us than about the talking. They held on to the culture. They let go of us."
I wrote that down in my phone in the driveway. I still have it.
On Saturday, at the wedding itself, I spent most of the reception doing what I had come to do, which was get my uncle to agree to something.
Tanvi's robotics team had qualified for a national competition in Houston, the last week of April. Four days, three nights, a hotel, a coach and two parent chaperones, a team of eleven kids, two of them girls. Tanvi wrote half the code that made their robot pick things up. She had stopped eating properly when she found out they had qualified, from pure joy, and then she had stopped eating properly again when her father said no.
Kaka Anil is my father's younger brother. He came over in 2002, after the coup of 2000. He is fifty-six and drives a delivery truck and is the softest man in my family when he forgets to be hard, and the hardest when he remembers. He said no because a sixteen-year-old girl in a hotel in Texas with boys. He said no because what would people say. He said no in a voice that meant he was frightened, not angry, though he did not know the difference.
I sat down next to him at the table near the bar, where the men drank whisky out of plastic cups and talked about cricket and the price of houses, and I said, "Kaka. What if I go."
He looked at me.
"I'll go as a chaperone. I'll take the days off. I'll share a room with her. I'll text you every two hours. I'll send you a photo of her at every meal."
"Reshmi."
"She wrote the code, Kaka. The robot doesn't work without her."
He looked down at his whisky. Across the room Tanvi was dancing with her mother, both of them laughing, Kaki Prem's dupatta slipping off her shoulder. My uncle watched them for a while.
"Every two hours," he said finally.
"Every two hours."
"And no boys in the room."
"No boys in the room."
He sighed through his nose for a long time, the way my father does, the way Aja did, I am told, a sigh that has crossed an ocean.
"Okay," he said. "Okay. You go."
There was one more thing at that wedding. Near midnight, when the older people were leaving and the DJ had put on the songs only the young people knew, I went outside to get some air and found Rakesh by the fountain, smoking.
Rakesh is a cousin of the groom's and was three years ahead of me at school. He is thirty-one. For four years in his twenties, after he hurt his back loading trucks at a warehouse in West Sacramento, he was dependent on pills that he was first given by a doctor and then got from places that were not doctors. His family hid it. They told the community he was working in Los Angeles. He is two and a half years clean now, he works as a counselor's assistant at a recovery program in the city, and his mother still stands near him at every gathering as if he might float away.
"Good wedding," he said.
"Good wedding."
"Your grandmother's a legend. That horse song."
"That was me singing."
"I know," he said. "I meant your grandmother taught you a horse song." He smoked for a while. "You know what nearly finished me? It wasn't the pills. It was the Los Angeles story. Four years of everybody saying, How's LA, Rakesh? And me saying, Good, good, working hard. When I was in my old bedroom on Mack Road the whole time. You can't get better from something everybody's pretending you don't have."
I didn't know what to say. He didn't need me to say anything. He put out the cigarette in the sand of the planter, carefully, and picked up the butt and put it in his pocket.
"Anyway," he said. "I'm telling people now. Somebody has to start."
His mother came out the door behind us with her shawl and her handbag and looked at him the way you look at a candle in a draft. He held out his arm to her and walked her to the car.
The Madras Pass
Built from the emigration pass of Valli, wife of Kannan, Madras depot, 1910, now in the family collection beside her husband's: Age 19. District North Arcot. Taluk Arni. Height 4 ft. 11 in. Marks: three tattoo dots on chin, small. Ship: the name is lost in a fold of the paper. And from a lullaby her great-granddaughter Kamala could not sing.
The rains did not come to the country around Arni in 1908, and then they came wrong in 1909, too much at once and then none, and the tank behind the village of Pudupalayam cracked across its bed like a dropped plate. The paddy failed. The millet failed. The landlord's men came for the share and took it anyway, out of the grain kept back for seed. By the Tamil month of Thai, in the cold dry January of 1910, Kannan, who was twenty-four and owned nothing but a plow blade and his own back, owed the moneylender in the town more than he could earn in three good years, and there were no good years in sight.
Valli had come to him at sixteen from a village two miles off. She was small and very straight-backed and had three blue dots tattooed in a little triangle on her chin, done by her grandmother with a needle and lampblack when she was seven, which she said made her look fierce, which it did. Every morning before light she swept the earth in front of their house, sprinkled it with water mixed with cow dung to settle the dust, and drew on it with rice flour from a pinch held between her thumb and fingers. Kolam. Dots first, in a grid, then lines looping around them without ever lifting her hand, a pattern that closed on itself like a knot. Some mornings a lotus. Some mornings a pattern of interlocking diamonds that her mother had taught her and her mother's mother had taught her mother. By noon the ants had carried half the rice flour away and the feet of the passing goats had smudged the rest, and the next morning she drew another.
The man who came to the weekly market at Arni was a Tamil, from the coast, and he called himself a maistry, a labor contractor, and he had a paper with a picture on it of a ship. He talked to a group of men under the shade of a neem tree. He said there was work on an island across the sea where the British were growing sugar. Fiji. Good wages, paid in silver. Free passage. Land after five years for anyone who wanted it. Wives were welcome, he said, wives were especially welcome. There was a depot in Madras where you would be fed and given clothes. You could go in a month.
Kannan asked how far.
The maistry said, about as far as Rangoon. Perhaps a little farther.
Kannan had a cousin in Rangoon. People went to Rangoon and came back. People went to Ceylon to the tea gardens and came back. People went to the rubber in Malaya and came back. Some of them did not come back, but many did, with silver and stories. Kannan went home and told Valli, and Valli listened with her arms folded and the three blue dots very dark on her chin, and asked whether there was a moneylender in Fiji.
"No moneylender," Kannan said. "Only work."
"There is always a moneylender," Valli said.
They went anyway. There was nothing else to do. They walked to the railway at Arni Road with two bundles and a brass pot and Valli's grinding stone, the small flat one for chutney, which she refused to leave and which Kannan carried on his head the whole way, complaining. They were registered at a sub-depot in a dusty town where an Englishman asked them through a clerk if they went of their own will, and they said yes, because it was true, in the way that it is true that a man jumps from a burning house of his own will.
The Madras depot was near the harbor, in the hot north of the city, a compound of long sheds behind a wall where you could hear the sea and smell it, salt and tar and rotting fish, and see over the wall the masts and funnels in the harbor and the long white line of the surf. It was full of Tamils and Telugus, people from North Arcot and South Arcot and Chingleput and Tanjore, from Vizagapatam and Godavari and Kistna, speaking two languages and a dozen dialects. A clerk measured Valli against a post: four feet eleven. A doctor looked at her teeth and her eyes and at the dots on her chin, and the clerk wrote those down too. She was given a number and a jacket and a blanket and two saris and a plate. She held the paper with her number on it and could not read it. Nobody read it to her.
The ship was a steamer. That was the first difference from the old days, though they did not know about the old days. For some years now the Fiji ships had been steamers, with tall black funnels and iron hulls, and the voyage that had once taken three months under sail took about a month. Hers had started at Calcutta and stopped at Madras for the southern emigrants. When Valli and Kannan came aboard in the June heat, climbing a ladder from a lighter that rocked in the harbor swell, the 'tween decks were already full of people from the north, Bhojpuri and Awadhi speakers, nearly a thousand people altogether. The northerners looked at the southerners and said a word that Valli would hear every day for the rest of her life and that her daughter and granddaughter would hear after her. Madrasi. Not Tamil, not Telugu, not from Arni or Pudupalayam. Madrasi. It meant anyone from the south, anyone who did not speak properly or ate strange food, and sometimes it meant nothing at all, only a name for a person you did not know.
She did not understand a word the northerners said. She understood the tone.
The steamer was faster and also hotter. It throbbed. The engines were in the middle of it like a heart that never slowed, and the iron decks were hot to the touch by midmorning, and the smoke from the funnels blew back over the people on deck and left grit in their eyes and hair. Valli was not seasick. Kannan was seasick for the whole voyage, from the Bay of Bengal across the Indian Ocean and past Australia and up into the Pacific, and she sat by him on the platform and fed him rice water with a spoon and told him, in Tamil, what she thought of maistrys and moneylenders and husbands who believed things at markets.
She made one friend on that ship who did not speak her language at all: a girl of seventeen from Gonda in the north named Sukhia, who was traveling alone and who, on the fourth day, sat down on the platform next to Valli without a word and stayed there. They had no language at all between them. In a month they had forty words of each other's, and a way of looking at each other across the deck when the northern men said something stupid, and that was enough.
The ship came into Suva harbor on a morning in July. The mountains were the green that every girmitiya who ever arrived in Fiji has tried to describe and failed, a green so deep it looked blue in the shadows and so bright where the sun hit it that it seemed lit from inside. There was a town now, a real town, with a wharf and warehouses and white government buildings and a hotel with a long veranda and Fijian police in white sulus. They were taken to Nukulau as all the ships' people had been for thirty years. Then they were allotted. Valli and Kannan, who were married in Arni before the sun and the village and both their families, were sent to an estate near Lautoka, on the dry western side of the island, where the big new mill had been built a few years before.
Lautoka in 1910 was a mill and a wharf and a few streets of shops on the flat by the sea, with the cane all around it and the hills behind going brown in the dry months and gold in the evening. The lines on Valli's estate, near a place called Drasa, were built of wood and iron like every lines in Fiji. Their room was ten by seven. Their neighbors were northerners. The sirdar was a northerner. The kulambar, the overseer, was a New Zealander who shouted in English and a few words of Hindustani. Nobody in the whole lines spoke Tamil except Valli and Kannan and one old man from Tanjore who was nearly deaf.
So she learned Hindustani. Or rather she learned the language that was being made in the lines, the Fiji Hindi, which had already been growing for thirty years on every estate in the colony and which was the only language that every girmitiya, from every district, could come to share. She learned it in the cane, from the other women. She learned it badly at first and was laughed at, and then she learned it well and laughed back. Kannan learned it slower. In a year they spoke it to their neighbors and Tamil to each other. In five years they spoke it to their neighbors and Tamil to each other when they were angry or tender or tired. When their daughter Lakshmi was born in 1913, in the room ten by seven, Valli sang to her in Tamil.
The lullaby was the one her own mother had sung, and her mother's mother, a thalattu, a cradle song. It goes, in its refrain, aararo aariraro, sounds without meaning, sounds that mean sleep. The verses in between are different in every family. In Valli's family they were about a little girl who is called a parrot, and a pearl, and the moon, and a lamp that her uncle will bring her from the town. Lakshmi slept to it every night of her childhood. Lakshmi sang it to her own children in a Tamil that was already thinner than her mother's. Lakshmi's daughter Saroja sang it to her children, Kamala among them, knowing only the refrain and a single verse and the tune, and understanding the verse because her grandmother had once explained it.
Kamala, my mother, knows the tune. She can hum it. She does not know the words. She told me this in May of 2026, standing at the kitchen counter in Sacramento with a knife and an onion, and she had to put the knife down.
In the lines Valli drew kolam. The first morning, before light, she swept the earth in front of the door of the room ten by seven and sprinkled it and drew a grid of dots with rice flour she had saved from the ration and looped a pattern around it, the interlocking diamonds. The northern women coming back from the latrines stopped and looked at it. The sirdar, on his way to bang the iron, nearly stepped on it and then did not. That evening Sukhia, the girl from Gonda, who had been sent to the same estate by the luck of the allotment, came and crouched beside the faded pattern and traced it in the air with her finger and asked, in the forty words, how it was done.
By the end of the first year half the women in that lines had a kolam in front of their door in the mornings, badly drawn, cheerfully wrong, and the overseer complained that his horse was stepping on rice flour. Nobody in the lines knew any longer that it was a southern thing. It was a lines thing. It was a Fiji thing.
Their girmit ended in July of 1915. Kannan took his certificate and stayed on wages. That year there were people in the towns, educated Indians and a few Europeans and Fijians and some men in India, who were making a noise about the girmit. People came from India and asked questions in the lines and wrote things down. In 1916 the ships stopped. The last one came into Suva in November with its eight hundred people from the north and the south, and after that no more came. In 1920, on the first day of January, the government in Suva announced that every indenture still running was cancelled. Nobody was bound any longer. Kannan and Valli were already free. They heard the news at the shop in Lautoka, read aloud by the shopkeeper from a newspaper, and Kannan said, "So it's finished," and Valli said, "For them," and went back to cutting her vegetables, because Lakshmi was six and had a cough, and there was still a moneylender, as there always is, and his name was Mr. Gopal and he had a shop in Lautoka and charged twenty-five percent.
But Valli had been right about the moneylender and wrong about the rest. They did not go back. Kannan leased six acres of cane land from the Fijian owners at Drasa and paid off Mr. Gopal in nine years and grew old on that land, a big slow man with white hair, still seasick in a punt. Valli drew kolam in front of the house on that land every morning until she died in 1952. Her granddaughter Saroja, who was six, took the rice flour out of her grandmother's tin the next morning and drew a crooked grid of dots in the dust, and looped a line around it the wrong way, and closed it.
She still draws them. She is eighty and lives in Lautoka in a concrete house off Drasa Avenue, and every morning she draws one on the step. I have the photos. Two hundred and eleven of them. I asked her for one a day for a year and she sends them, with the date and a line in Fiji Hindi about the weather. Today: rain. Today: very hot, the dog sat on it. Today: I am tired, only a small one.
The Biscuit Tin
Houston was ninety-four degrees and so humid that the air felt like a wet towel someone was holding over your face. I sent my uncle a photograph every two hours for four days. Tanvi at breakfast in the hotel with a waffle shaped like the state of Texas. Tanvi in the competition arena, a hangar-sized hall full of noise and blue carpet and kids in matching shirts, bent over a laptop with her braid over one shoulder and her tongue between her teeth. The robot, which was the size of a small dishwasher and looked like one, picked up foam rings and put them on posts. The team came eleventh out of sixty-four in their division. On the last day a judge in a gray fleece stopped by their pit and asked who had written the vision code, and Tanvi's teammates all pointed at her, and the judge asked her three questions and wrote something on a clipboard and gave her a card.
I sent Kaka Anil a picture of the card. He did not answer for an hour. Then he wrote: Good. Then, a minute later: Very good. Then, after another minute, a photograph of the card printed out and stuck on his refrigerator with a magnet shaped like a pineapple from Fiji.
We came back on a Sunday. On Wednesday my mother called Paati.
My mother calls Lautoka every Sunday and every Wednesday, at nine in the evening our time, which is four or five the next afternoon in Fiji, depending on the time of year. I have heard those calls through the wall of my bedroom my whole life. They are in Fiji Hindi with English for things like medications, and they are about rain, prices, who has died, who has married, who has gone to Australia, whether the neighbor's dog has been at the rubbish again, and whether Paati has been taking her pills. Since March I had begun sitting in on them, at the kitchen table, with my mother's phone propped on the fruit bowl, because I wanted to ask Paati about Valli.
Paati's face on the screen is round and brown and very close, because she holds the phone too near. Behind her, in every call, are the same things: a louvered window with a lace curtain, a calendar from a Lautoka hardware store, the corner of a glass cabinet with her good plates in it, and a framed photograph of my grandfather in a white safari suit at somebody's wedding in 1979. Paati is eighty. She worked for thirty-one years as a cook at a school in Lautoka and has the forearms to show for it. Her husband, my Thatha, died in 2015. She has refused three times to come to Sacramento, once to my mother's face, once to my father's, once to mine. She says Sacramento is too flat and nobody walks anywhere and you cannot buy a decent fish.
That Wednesday I asked her about the lullaby.
"Which one?" she said.
"The Tamil one. The one Valli sang."
She looked at me through the phone for a while. Then she said, "Hold on," and put the phone down on the table so that for a minute we were looking at the ceiling of her living room, the fan turning, a gecko by the light. We heard her blow her nose. Then she picked it up again and sang.
It was very short. The refrain, aararo aariraro, three times. One verse, about a little girl, a parrot, a pearl. Then the refrain again. Her voice was cracked and much deeper than Aaji's. It sounded like something being pulled up out of a well.
My mother sat with her hand flat on the table and her eyes shut.
"That's all I have," Paati said. "My Aaya, my grandmother Valli, had all of it. My Amma had more than me. I have this much." She held up her thumb and finger with a little gap between. "It's going, Reshmi. All the Tamil is going. You know in my childhood, the Tamil families in Lautoka, we had a school, a little Tamil school, Saturday mornings? Learn to read and write. My father sent me. I hated it. Now there's no one to teach it, and no one to send." She laughed. "Now I would go."
"Can I record it, Paati? What you just sang?"
"Record," she said. "Record. What's the use? Who will sing it?"
My mother opened her eyes.
"I will," she said.
That night I added a new section to the list of words, under the three hundred lines of Fiji Hindi and Bhojpuri: Tamil. Aararo aariraro. Thalattu, lullaby. Kolam. Paati, grandmother, father's or mother's mother. Thatha, grandfather. Aaya, grandmother, which is what Paati called Valli. Amma, appa. Kanna, darling. Vanakkam, hello. Each with Paati's voice beside it, clipped from the calls, and under the lullaby, my mother's voice, recorded later in the kitchen, singing it back too slowly, one word at a time, with Paati correcting her through the phone. It is not a good recording. You can hear the refrigerator. You can hear my mother laughing at herself halfway through and then going on.
The fourteenth of May fell on a Thursday that year. It is Girmit Day, the day the Leonidas, the first indenture ship, anchored off Levuka in 1879. In Fiji it is a public commemoration now, after many years when it was not. In Sacramento the Fiji community marks it with an evening at the hall: speeches, a slideshow of old photographs, children reciting poems, a meal. I had been going since I was little and never listened to a word.
That year the committee asked me to speak, because Shanti Auntie had told the committee that I worked at the archives and had found a real emigration pass, and the committee had decided it would be educational for the children.
I stood at the front of the hall, under the drop ceiling with the water stains, with the copy of Phulmati's pass projected six feet tall on the screen behind me so that her small cross in the corner was the size of my hand. I told them she was four feet ten and a half. I told them about the scar. I told them what the pass said about wages, a shilling for a man and nine pence for a woman. I told them about the court at Ba and the five shillings. I told them that she went to find her husband and found a ship.
I had meant to stop there. Instead I heard myself say: "Everybody in her village would have talked about her. A young wife, alone, walking out to the town. They would have said she had no shame. They would have said, think of her family. They would have said, what will people say. And she went anyway. And because she went, all of us are sitting in this room."
It was very quiet. Somebody's baby said something. In the second row, Usha Auntie, who had not come to an evening at the hall in years, sitting next to my grandmother, was looking at the screen with her hand over her mouth.
Afterward, in the line for food, nobody said anything about what I had said. They said it was very educational. They said the slides were very clear. Mrs. Chand from the grocery said I had a lovely speaking voice. Then, at the dessert table, I heard Shanti Auntie behind me tell another auntie, in the cheerful whisper she uses that carries across parking lots, that Vinod's girl was going to Fiji in June.
"To Fiji? For what?"
"Who knows. A boy, maybe," said Shanti Auntie. "Lautoka. On the mother's side. They're keeping it quiet."
I had told no one but my parents that I wanted to go to Fiji. I had not even bought a ticket.
It had come up at dinner the week before Houston, when I said, carefully, that I had saved enough for the airfare and wanted to see Ba and Nine Mile and Lautoka and the archives in Suva, and to meet Paati in person while she was still well. My father put his fork down and said "Alone?" in the car-he-does-not-trust voice. I said I was twenty-eight. My mother said nothing. My father said a girl alone in Fiji now, after everything, with the crime in Suva, with the way things are. I said I would be staying with Paati. My father said Paati was eighty and could not protect anybody. I said I did not need protecting, I needed a ride from the airport. Then my mother said, quietly, "I'll go with her."
We both looked at her.
"I haven't been back since 2015," she said. "Since Appa's funeral. Eleven years. My mother is eighty." She looked at my father. "We'll go together. Two weeks. You and Aaji can eat at Anil's."
So now we were going. Two weeks, the nineteenth of June to the third of July, Sacramento to Los Angeles to Nadi, my mother and me. And Shanti Auntie had found a boy for me in Lautoka without consulting either of us.
When I told my mother about the boy in the car going home, she laughed so hard she had to pull into the parking lot of a tire shop on Florin Road and put her forehead on the steering wheel.
"A boy," she said. "In Lautoka. Who? Which boy? I want to meet this boy."
"There is no boy, Mummy."
"I know there is no boy," she said, wiping her eyes. "That's why it's funny." Then she stopped laughing and looked out the windshield at the tire shop's sign, which was buzzing. "Thirty years," she said. "Thirty years I'm in this country, and they still decide everything about us before we know it ourselves."
I almost told her about Daniel then. I had my mouth open. A truck pulled in behind us and honked, and my mother started the car, and the moment went.
Daniel and I had dinner the following Saturday at a Vietnamese place on Stockton Boulevard, where nobody from the community ever goes because they all go to the Indian place two blocks down. I told him about the trip.
"That's huge," he said. "Your mom going with you."
"I know."
"Are you going to tell her? On the trip?"
"Tell her what?"
He just looked at me. He has a way of waiting that is a teacher's, patient and a little stubborn, the way he waits for a fifteen-year-old to finish a sentence.
"I don't know," I said. "Maybe. Probably not. It's her first time home in eleven years. I don't want to wreck it."
"Okay," he said. Then: "Reshmi. It's been almost three years."
"I know how long it's been."
"I'm not pushing. I'm just saying it out loud so we both heard it."
We finished our pho in a silence that was not a fight but was in the same family as one. Outside, the evening was warm for May and smelled of jasmine from somebody's fence and exhaust from the boulevard. He walked me to my car and kissed me on the forehead and said, "Bring me back something," and I said, "Like what," and he said, "A story."
In the first week of June I went to a twenty-first birthday in West Sacramento.
It was for Sereana's older son, Isikeli, who had just finished his second year at the state university and played for its rugby club. Sereana had asked me in the elevator in May, the way she asks everything, as if it were already decided. "You come Saturday. Bring your mother if she wants." My mother had a shift. When I told Aaji where I was going, she said, from the stove, "Fijian party? They'll drink grog till morning. Monday, nobody goes to work."
"Sereana's at her desk before I am, Aaji. Every day."
"I'm not talking about her," Aaji said, which is what people always say.
Sereana had told me what to bring. Not a present for Isikeli; his aunties had that covered. Bring waka, the dried kava root, for the house. I bought a half-kilo bundle tied with string at the Fiji grocery on Florin Road, and Mrs. Chand raised her eyebrows and said, "Take two. They'll like you more." I took one.
The party was in a backyard near the river, under a white tent strung with lights, with a hundred people in it and the smell of smoke from a lovo, an earth oven that Sereana's husband Jone and his brothers had dug in the lawn at dawn, lined with hot stones and covered with banana leaves and wet sacks, with pork and chicken and dalo and fish in leaf parcels cooking underneath. Jone drives a truck long-haul, Sacramento to Salt Lake City and back, and had taken the whole week off. There were women in bright dresses with flowers behind their ears, cousins with guitars and a ukulele, little boys in sulu and white shirts racing between the tables, and at one end, on a woven mat, a wide wooden bowl, the tanoa, with old men sitting cross-legged around it.
Sereana took me to them. She showed me how to sit, legs folded to one side, and had me lay the bundle on the mat in front of the bowl, and then her cousin, kneeling beside me, spoke a few words for me, the sevusevu, my family's greeting to theirs. Her uncle, gray-haired, in a sulu and a pressed shirt, took it up in both hands and spoke over it in Fijian for about a minute in a low, rhythmic voice, and the men around the bowl clapped together, three slow cupped claps that sounded like something dropped into water.
"He says thank you," Sereana said. "And that you came from your family to his, so now there is a road between the two houses. Something like that. It's nicer in Fijian."
They gave me a bilo, half a coconut shell, of kava. I clapped once. I said bula. I drank it in one go, as I had been told, and my lips went numb, and everybody clapped three times, and the uncle said, "Maca," empty, and nodded as if I had passed something.
Later, when the lovo had been opened and eaten and the band had started on songs everybody knew, Sereana and I sat on the back step with paper plates on our knees, and I told her what Aaji had said. I do not know why. It had been sitting in my mouth all afternoon like the kava.
She did not seem surprised. She ate a piece of dalo.
"My bubu used to say the Indians would take everything," she said. "When she was a young woman there were more of them in Fiji than us. In our own country. She thought one day they would have the land too, and then what are we? For us the land is not only land. The vanua is the land and the people and the old ones under it, all one word. You lose it, you lose yourself. So she was frightened. Frightened people say things." She wiped her fingers. "Your Aaji, I think, was frightened too. Different things."
"She'd say she wasn't."
"Mine also." Then she said, "You know why it was your people in the cane and not mine? The governor, back then. He kept the Fijians in the villages under the chiefs, growing food, paying their tax in what they grew, and he would not let the planters work them. So the planters went to India. My great-great-grandfather worked his whole life in that village. Gardens, fishing, building, whatever the chief said. Nobody paid him a shilling. Lazy is what you call people who work at things you don't get paid for." She stood and stacked my plate on hers. "Also some of my uncles are very lazy," she said. "Like some of yours. Come. They're doing the speeches."
His father spoke, and his uncle, and his grandmother spoke on a phone held up to a microphone from her village in Nadroga, in Fijian, and cried, and Isikeli, who is six foot three, cried too, and then his teammates lifted him onto their shoulders and nearly put him through the roof of the tent.
On the last Sunday before we left, Aaji called me into her room and closed the door.
She had the green cardigan on, though it was eighty-six degrees outside. She was sitting on the hibiscus bedspread with a flat tin box on her knees, the kind that once held biscuits, rusted at the corners, with a faded picture of a ship on the lid. I had seen that tin my whole life, on the top shelf of her closet, and never thought about it. She opened it.
Inside, wrapped in a piece of old red cloth, was a notebook. A small one, hand-sewn, with a cover of brown card gone soft as felt. The pages were the color of weak tea and the writing on them was in brown ink, a script I did not recognize. It was not quite Devanagari. It had no line along the top.
"Bechan's," she said. "Kaithi. The old writing. He wrote down Phulmati's songs. All of them, the ones she made. And other things." She closed her hands over it. "She gave it to me in 1961. Two weeks before. She said, You keep it. Your husband will lose it, his father will use it to light the fire. You keep it."
"Aaji. Why didn't you ever show me?"
She looked at me for a long time. "Because nobody can read it," she said. "I can't. Your father can't. Who reads Kaithi? Nobody. I thought, what is the use. Then you came with your paper from Suva, with her height on it." She held the notebook out to me in both hands, the way Bechan gave letters back. "Take it with you. Maybe in Fiji somebody knows. Maybe somebody knows somebody."
I took it. It weighed almost nothing.
Ba in the Rain
The plane came down into Nadi at a quarter past five in the morning, out of a sky that was going from black to violet over the sea, and the first thing I knew about Fiji was the air. It came into the cabin when they opened the door, warm and thick and wet and smelling of jet fuel and cut grass and the sea and something sweet underneath, flowers or rotting fruit or both. My mother, in the seat beside me, closed her eyes and breathed it in the way you would breathe in the neck of a baby.
In the arrivals hall three men in flowered shirts with guitars and a ukulele were singing a Fijian welcome song at six in the morning to a planeload of exhausted people, and doing it as if it were the best idea anyone had ever had. The song went up and down in harmony and the passengers from Los Angeles, Australians and Americans and Fiji Indians coming home and Fijians coming home, all went quiet as they passed it with their luggage carts. My mother stopped in front of them and listened to the whole thing and then put a five-dollar note in the guitar case and said, "Vinaka vakalevu," and the oldest one said, "Bula, Bubu," and she laughed, because she is fifty-five and he had called her grandmother.
Paati had sent her nephew's son, Ravin, to get us, a heavy, cheerful man of about forty in a rugby shirt with a minivan that rattled. We drove north on the Queens Road with the windows down, past the cane fields standing silver-green in the early light, past roadside stalls with pyramids of pineapples and watermelons and bundles of long beans, past Fijian villages with their wide lawns and their kids walking to school in blue and white uniforms with their shoes in their hands, past the mountains on the right going pink at the top. A cane train was crossing the road at a level crossing near Lautoka: a little diesel engine painted yellow pulling forty small iron trucks heaped with cut cane on narrow rails no wider than my arm span, rattling slowly over the road while the traffic waited. Ravin turned off his engine. "Could be ten minutes," he said. "Could be twenty. Cane time." My mother was crying again, very quietly, looking at the cane train.
Paati's house is concrete, painted pale green, raised a few steps off the ground, with louvered windows and a corrugated iron roof and a mango tree in the yard as big as the house. A brown dog with a curly tail was asleep on the top step, and under the dog, partly, was a kolam: a grid of white dots and a looping line in rice flour, smudged at one corner where the dog had turned around. Paati was in the doorway. She was smaller than on the screen. Everybody is. She had on a blue floral dress and a cardigan, though it was already eighty degrees, and her hair was white and pulled back tight, and she held on to the door frame with one hand and held the other out.
My mother went up the steps two at a time, stepped over the dog and very carefully not on the kolam, and put her arms around her mother, and they stood like that in the doorway rocking a little for so long that Ravin went and sat in the van and played with his phone.
Then Paati looked at me over my mother's shoulder and said in Fiji Hindi, "Too thin. Come inside. Eat."
I will not write down everything about Lautoka because I would never stop. The way the town smelled in the evening, of sugar from the mill, a burnt sweet smell like caramel left on the stove, that hung over everything in the crushing season and got into your hair. The market on Saturday morning, a huge open shed by the bus station full of piles of everything, dalo and cassava and breadfruit and eggplants and bitter gourds and bundles of bele leaves, and fish laid out on wet sacking, and a whole section for yaqona root in bundles and powder, and Fijian and Indian women side by side behind their tables calling to each other across the aisle in a mixture of both languages and English that I could follow almost entirely. The one afternoon it rained, out of season, so hard and loud on the iron roof that Paati and my mother had to stop talking until it was over, and then stopped as if somebody had turned off a tap, and the whole yard steamed.
I took photographs of everything and pinned them to the family map as we went, the map that has the dots for Ba and Lautoka and Suva and Basti and Arni and Sacramento and Union City and Yuba City, every place anybody in the family has lived. Until that week Paati's house was a dot with no pictures. I added sixty. The kolam with the dog on it. The mango tree. My mother and Paati on the back step shelling peas, which I did not plan, which just happened, and which I photographed from behind so neither of them would notice and stop.
On the fourth day Ravin drove us to Ba.
Ba is forty minutes north and east along the coast road, through more cane. It is a town of two long streets beside a wide brown river with the mill at Rarawai on its edge, the mill where everything began, a tall complex of rusted iron sheds and pipes and a chimney with smoke going straight up into a white sky, and a smell of sugar so thick you could almost chew it. My father had told me the river would be brown and it was. He had told me the town would be smaller than I thought and it was. He had not told me that it would be full of people who looked like my uncles. Every second man on the main street of Ba had my father's walk.
Nine Mile is nine miles up the river by the old road, a dirt road between cane on one side and the river on the other, through a flat green valley with hills rising behind it, tall, sharp, green-black, with clouds caught on their tops. The house was gone. I knew it would be. When the lease on the land ran out in 1999, Aja had already died, and Aaji and Kaka Anil, who were still living there, could not get it renewed, and in 2001 they sold the bullocks and the furniture and gave the keys back and left. The house stood empty for some years and then was pulled down. All that was left was the concrete pad that the water tank had stood on, cracked and grown through with grass, and a mango tree, enormous, older than anything around it, that Aaji says Phulmati planted in 1905 the week they moved in.
The land is farmed now by a Fijian family from the village up the hill. They grow cane and dalo and a little rice, and they keep cattle on the river flat. I had written to them through a cousin of a cousin of Ravin's, and they had said yes, come. The head of the family was a man of about sixty named Mesake, with very large hands and a soft voice, who met us at the gate with his wife and a granddaughter of about ten who stared at me with frank curiosity the entire visit. His great-great-grandfather was Seru, the boatman who traded dalo for salt at the Number Four lines. Mesake knew this. He knew all of it. His father had sat across the table from my grandfather at the district office in Ba in 1969, the day the last lease on Nine Mile was signed.
"Ramsewak," Mesake said, carefully, the way you say a name you have heard in your family since childhood. "And the wife. The Narayan nana. She used to bring my mother roti. Every Sunday. My mother used to bring her fish."
He showed us where the house had stood. He showed us where the veranda had been, facing the river. He stood with us under the mango tree, and his wife brought out a plastic chair for my mother and a tray of tea in mugs and a plate of cassava boiled and then fried, with salt, and we sat in the shade and talked for two hours in English and Fiji Hindi and some Fijian that the granddaughter translated for her grandfather when he forgot the English word for something, which was not often.
"When your family left," Mesake said, near the end, "it was a bad time. Everybody's leases running out. Everybody's families leaving. Then in 2000, the trouble in Suva. A lot of bad feeling. A lot of it on both sides." He was quiet. "My father used to say, if we don't take the land back now, our grandchildren will be strangers on it. He believed that. He still believed it when he died. And he was sorry. He said so. Your grandmother, she cried when she gave him the key. And my father cried. They had known each other forty years. Nobody knew how to do it better, then."
I did not know what to say. My mother said, "Thank you for telling us." Mesake nodded.
Before we left, the granddaughter, who had been silent and staring for two hours, came up to me and said in very careful English, "Is it true in America you can be anything?"
I looked at Mesake, who was smiling a little, and at my mother, who was looking at me.
"Mostly," I said. "If people let you."
She nodded seriously, as if that were the answer she had expected, and ran off.
We went to Suva for two days at the end. Suva is on the wet side of the island, and it rained the whole time, a warm gray rain that made the colonial buildings along Victoria Parade look like old photographs of themselves and made the market smell of wet earth and fish. The National Archives of Fiji is in a plain concrete building near the government offices. I spent a day in its reading room with the immigration registers, big ledgers bound in faded cloth, and found the Elbe, and found number 211, and number 340, and touched the line where some clerk in 1896 had written man and wife. The archivist who helped me was a Fijian woman about my age named Litia, very quick and very dry, who had a degree from the university in Suva and an aunt in Oakland. When I showed her the Kaithi notebook her eyebrows went up and stayed there.
"Nobody here reads that," she said. "Not anymore. But there's a man in India." She was already typing. "A retired lecturer in Varanasi. He helped us with some old letters. He's very old and very slow and he answers every email. Do you want to scan it here?"
We scanned it on a flatbed scanner at the back of the archives, every page, forty-four of them, Litia turning them with a bone folder while I held my breath. She sent them that afternoon.
On our last evening my mother and I walked along the seawall out toward Suva Point. The rain had stopped and the clouds were breaking up over the harbor and the light came through them low and gold, lighting up the water of the bay and, far out to the east toward the reef, a low flat island with a few palms on it.
"That one," my mother said. "Isn't that Nukulau?"
It was. We stood and looked at it. You could not see anything there. A line of palms, a strip of sand. A hundred and thirty years ago Phulmati and Bechan had stood on that sand and had a clerk write them down as man and wife.
"Mummy," I said. "I have to tell you something."
She did not look at me. She kept looking at the island. "Is it a boy?" she said.
"His name is Daniel."
She was quiet for a long time. A man went past us on a bicycle with a fishing rod over his shoulder, ringing his bell.
"Is he Indian?"
"No. Mexican American. His grandmother's from Michoacán. He teaches history."
"How long?"
"Almost three years."
She closed her eyes. Then she opened them and looked at me, finally. She did not look angry. She looked tired, and frightened, and something else that it took me a long time afterward to recognize, which was relief.
"Almost three years," she said. "And you carried this alone."
"Nitin knows. Tanvi knows."
"Tanvi knows," she said, and made a sound that was very nearly a laugh. "Of course Tanvi knows." Then she turned back to the island. "Don't tell your father yet," she said. "Let me think. Let me think how."
We stood there until the light went.
Thirty Years Is a Long Time
Built from two papers kept folded together in Aaji's tin: a lease of native land, Nine Mile, Ba, twelve acres, signed in 1969 for thirty years, Lessee Ramsewak Narayan, with the stamp of the board that managed native land and the landowning family's names written in; and a typed letter of 1998 saying that the lease would not be renewed. Both are photographed now and pinned to Nine Mile on the family map.
Phulmati died in the cool season of 1961, on the veranda at Nine Mile, in the afternoon, on her mat, with a bowl of peas beside her that she had not finished. The new bride found her. That bride, Kalawati, my Aaji, was twenty-one then and had a son of one, and she sat down beside the old woman and finished shelling the peas before she called anyone, because, she told me, it seemed to her that Phulmati would have wanted the work done.
Two weeks before, Phulmati had given her the notebook in its red cloth, and told her to keep it.
The farm at Nine Mile went on. It was twelve acres by then, the eight that Bechan had leased in 1905 and four more that Ramdeo added in 1931 from the same Fijian family. It grew cane for the mill at Rarawai and rice in the wet bottom by the river, and the family kept bullocks and two cows and chickens and a vegetable garden of eggplants and chilies and okra and long beans. Every year in the crushing season, from June to November, the cane was cut by gangs of men from the farms around who helped each other in turn, and loaded on the cane trucks, and pulled by the little trains to the mill, and the whole valley smelled of burnt sugar.
In 1966 Kalawati's second son was born on that veranda during a storm. They named him Vinod. In 1970, when he was four, Fiji became independent, on the tenth of October, and at Nine Mile they listened to the ceremony on a radio with a battery the size of a brick and Ramsewak stood up when the new flag was raised in Suva, though nobody at Nine Mile could see it, and so everybody else stood up too.
The lease of 1969 came under a tenancy law passed a few years before, and with the extensions a later law added, it would run thirty years. Ramsewak signed it at the district office in Ba at a table with a fan turning slowly overhead. Across the table, there for the landowning family, sat a Fijian man of about forty, Mesake's father, the great-grandson of Seru the boatman. They had known each other since they were boys swimming in the same river. They signed, and shook hands, and went out together into the hot street and drank a bottle of soft drink each at a shop on the corner, and Ramsewak said thirty years was a long time, and the other man said it was, and they both believed it.
Vinod was very good at school. He was good at mathematics in a way that made his teachers come to the farm on bicycles to talk to his father. In 1984, at eighteen, he sat the exams and passed well enough for a place at the university in Suva, which was the only university in Fiji then and the only one most families could imagine. He wanted to study engineering. He wanted it the way his great-grandmother had once wanted to find a husband in a mill town in Bengal: past reason.
His father said no.
His father said no for the reasons fathers on farms all over the world have said no, and for one more. The farm needed him. His elder brother had gone to work in a garage in Lautoka and would not come back. The lease had fifteen years left on it and a man needed sons on the land to work it. And there was the other reason, which was not said, which did not need to be said in a house like that: a son who left the land for books in Suva was a son people would talk about, a father whose son would not farm was a father people would talk about. It was a smaller pressure than the one on daughters. It was still a pressure. Vinod stayed. He drove the tractor that the family bought secondhand in 1983. He cut cane. He read engineering books that his old teacher lent him at night by a kerosene lamp, and fixed every engine in the valley, and was paid in fish and favors and once in a goat.
On the fourteenth of May 1987 Vinod was twenty-one. He was in Ba town that morning buying a part for the tractor at a hardware shop when the man behind the counter turned up the radio. Soldiers had walked into the parliament in Suva and taken the new government away at gunpoint. The government had been elected only a month before, and Fiji Indians had voted for it in great numbers and sat in its cabinet. Over the next days the radio played music and the announcements changed and there were roadblocks on the Queens Road manned by young soldiers, and in Suva there were crowds and shops with smashed windows, and in September there was a second coup, and a new constitution was promised that would keep power away from people like Vinod forever.
At Nine Mile nothing happened. That was what Aaji always said, and it was true, and it was the strangest part. The cane grew. The river ran. Mesake's father came on Sunday with fish as he always did and sat on the veranda with Ramsewak and neither of them said very much. But in the town things had changed. Fiji Indian teachers and doctors and shopkeepers and clerks began to apply for visas, to Australia and New Zealand and Canada and the United States, in hundreds and then in thousands. Families who had been in Fiji for four generations sold their houses for what they could get and left. Vinod's elder sister, Saraswati, married with two children, went to Sacramento in 1988 with her husband, who had a cousin there with a job for him in a warehouse, and from Sacramento she began to write letters.
Vinod stayed six more years. He married Kamala in December 1993, at Nine Mile, under a tent in the yard with the mango tree hung with lights from a car battery. She was twenty-two and from Lautoka and her family were Tamil, which some of the relatives at Nine Mile found worth remarking on and Kalawati told them to stop remarking on. The two of them had met at a wedding in Lautoka the year before, and the families had done the rest. In 1995, on Saraswati's petition, they went to Sacramento.
Kalawati packed Vinod's suitcase herself. She put in a bag of masala she had ground, and a photo of the farm, and a shirt she had sewn for him, which he never wore and still has.
Ramsewak died in 1999 in the hospital at Lautoka of his heart, at sixty-five, with Kalawati beside him. In the same year the lease ran out.
The typed letter had come in 1998. It was polite. It came through the government body that managed native land, and it said that the landowning unit had decided not to renew. There were reasons. The landowners had their own families, who needed land. There had been thirty years of rent at rates set by law that many Fijians felt had been too low. There was the whole long argument that had been going on in the country since 1987 and long before, over who the land was for, which was a real argument with real grievances on more than one side, and which had come down, at Nine Mile, to two old friends who had shaken hands in a hot street in 1969 and were now not allowed, by everything around them, to shake hands again in the same way. Across the cane belt, from Ba to Labasa, the leases signed in the late 1960s were running out one after another, and thousands of Fiji Indian farm families were packing up, and some got renewals and many did not.
Kalawati and her younger son Anil stayed on at Nine Mile for a time after the lease ended, by an arrangement with Mesake's father that was written down nowhere. Then, on the nineteenth of May 2000, a group of armed men walked into the parliament in Suva and took the prime minister and most of his cabinet hostage. The prime minister was a Fiji Indian, the first one there had ever been. The hostages were held for nearly two months. In Suva the shops on the main streets were looted and burned on the first afternoon. In some districts in the east, Fiji Indian farm families were driven from their houses by gangs, their animals taken, their crops burned, and they lived for weeks in a camp for displaced families. In Ba it was quieter. But at Nine Mile nobody slept well, and Anil sat on the veranda at night with the lights off and the radio on low, and in the mornings Kalawati found him there asleep in the chair with the cane knife across his knees, exactly as Phulmati had once sat in the doorway of the lines.
Mesake's father came on the Sunday after the hostages were taken, with fish, as he always did. He sat on the veranda. He said, after a long time, "This isn't us." Kalawati said, "I know." He said, "I'm sorry." She said, "I know." That was all.
In 2001 Kalawati sold the bullocks and the tractor and the furniture and gave the key to Mesake's father at the gate, and they both cried, and she filled Phulmati's old dented lota from the tank and sprinkled the water on the dust of the yard, which is a thing her own mother had done when she left a house. Then she dried the lota on the end of her sari and put it in the trunk. "It's been everywhere," she told Anil. "It can go to America." And she got into a hired truck with the trunk and a sewing machine and the biscuit tin with the ship on its lid, exactly as she had arrived in 1958, and went to Nadi, and got on a plane.
She was sixty-one. She had never been on a plane. Vinod met her at the airport in San Francisco in a borrowed suit, with Kamala and a three-year-old girl in a red dress who had been told for a week that her Aaji was coming from Fiji and who hid behind her mother's legs when she saw her.
That was me. I don't remember it. Aaji does. She says I peeked out and looked at her for a long time and then said, in Fiji Hindi, with an American accent, "You're small."
She says that was when she knew she would be all right.
Let Them Say It
The email from Varanasi came on the seventh of August, a Friday, at four in the morning Sacramento time, which I know because I was awake. It had forty-four attachments, one for every page, and a letter at the top in a formal, careful English, like a letter in an old schoolbook. Mr. Ramakant Tiwari was eighty-three. He had taught Hindi literature for thirty-eight years at a college in the city and had spent his retirement reading Kaithi documents for anyone who asked: land deeds, court papers, account books of shopkeepers. He apologized for the delay. His eyes were not good and the brown ink was faded. He had done his best. He had found the notebook "very moving" and hoped I would forgive him for having read it twice before he began to translate, "once as a scholar and once as a grandfather."
Most of the notebook was songs. Phulmati's verses, the ones she made up in the lines and at Nine Mile, written down by Bechan over forty years in a hand that changed from young and quick to old and shaky. There were sixty-one. Mr. Tiwari had transcribed each into Devanagari and then into English, with notes. Some I knew from Aaji: the horse, the mother-in-law's hair. Most I had never heard. There were songs about the cane fire season, about the punt on the river, about the first time she saw the sea from the lines road, about Ramdeo learning to walk on the earth floor of the room ten by seven, about a Fijian woman who taught her to weave a mat and laughed at her fingers. There was one about Ramdei and Chhotu leaving for India from the jetty at Ba, which Mr. Tiwari said in a note was "of great beauty, in the old bidesiya form, but reversed, so that it is the one who stays who is singing to the one who goes."
Some pages were accounts. Rations, wages, fines. Five shillings, 1899, in Bechan's hand, with a line under it.
And on page thirty-one, in the young quick hand, was the letter.
Mr. Tiwari's note said it appeared to be a copy, or a draft, of a letter written for Phulmati to her mother, probably in 1901 or 1902, judging from the hand and the mention of a son. He said the language was the Bhojpuri of the Basti region with some words that were already Fiji words. He said he had translated it as plainly as he could. That afternoon I put all forty-four pages, with his English, under Bechan's name in the family tree.
I printed it. I could not read it on the screen. I took it downstairs at six in the morning and found Aaji already in the kitchen in her cardigan, with the kettle on, and I sat her down at the dining table on the plastic over the lace and I read it to her, first in English and then, slowly, badly, from Mr. Tiwari's Devanagari, in something like the words Phulmati had said.
To my mother, in Mahuawa, from your daughter Phulmati, who is in the island of Fiji. I am alive. Tell everyone I am alive. I did not find him. There is a sea between here and there that takes three months. I have a husband here who is good to me and a son. His name is Ramdeo. He is fat. I work in the cane. The work is hard and the pay is small but I eat every day. Mother, I know what they say at the well. Let them say it. I am too far away to hear. Tell my father the scar on my wrist has not opened. Tell my sister to sing the songs. If this letter comes, send one back through the man who brings it. If this letter does not come, I am still alive.
Aaji did not say anything for a long time. The kettle boiled and clicked off. Outside, the sprinklers came on in the front yard with their hiss and tick.
"Itna sa," she said finally, and held up her hand at the height of her shoulder. "And she says let them say it."
I had the copy of the pass in my folder, and the line from the court return, and the lease, and now the letter. I put them on the table side by side. It was the first time I saw her whole. Not a gray circle with a name under it. A small, sharp, funny, frightened, stubborn girl who had walked away from the well, and sung rude songs about the overseer's horse, and told her mother to let them talk.
Two weeks later, on the twenty-second of August, Usha Auntie and Rakesh held an evening at the hall.
It had been Rakesh's idea, and Usha Auntie had said yes, and between them they had asked the committee, and the committee had agreed. It was called, on the printed flyer, A Family Evening: Talking About What We Don't Talk About. There was a counselor from a clinic in the city, a Fiji Indian woman from Hayward who had come up for it, and a man from the recovery program where Rakesh worked, and there was food, and there was supposed to be some music at the end. I was asked to sing.
About eighty people came. In a hall that holds three hundred it looked like a handful. They sat spread out on the folding chairs as if they had each come alone and were not sure they should be seen, which was true. Some were older people, parents. Some were young, my age and younger, in hoodies, at the back. Aaji came, and my mother. My father did not. Kaka Anil and Kaki Prem came with Tanvi. Ashneel Deo came, alone, from Stockton, and sat near the back and nodded to me.
Nisha came from Oakland.
I had written to her in July, after Fiji, the first time in years. She is a nurse now, in the emergency department of a big hospital there, with a partner and a cat and a small apartment near the lake, and she wrote back the same day: I'll come. I didn't know if I could, but I'll come. She walked into the hall at seven, in scrubs, straight from a shift, and stood at the door for a moment looking at the brown carpet and the marigold arch somebody had left up from a party, and then came and sat next to me and took my hand and held it so hard my rings hurt.
Her parents did not come. Her mother had been told she would be there. Her mother had said, to the person who told her, that she did not have a daughter. Nisha knew this. She said it to me herself, in a flat voice, before the evening began. "Some people don't change," she said. "I've stopped waiting. Mostly."
Usha Auntie spoke first. She stood at the front with a sheet of paper she did not look at, and in Fiji Hindi and then in English she said her son's name, Avinash, and his age, nineteen, and said that he had died nine years before and that she had never once since then heard anyone in the community say his name to her face. She said she did not blame anyone. She said nobody knew what to do. She said she had not known either. She said that if her son had felt he could tell her he was struggling without bringing shame on the family, she believed he might be alive. She said she was not sure. She said she would never be sure. She said she wanted the mothers in the room to tell their children that there was nothing, nothing at all, that they could ever tell their parents that would be worse than losing them.
Then she sat down next to Aaji, and Aaji put her hand on her knee.
Rakesh spoke. He told the Los Angeles story. People laughed at the right places, a little, which surprised me, and then were quiet. The counselor from Hayward spoke about pressure and depression and what to watch for, about where to go and what to say. The man from the recovery program spoke about pills. A woman my mother's age at the back stood up and said, in a shaking voice, that her son was in a program right now in Fresno and that she had told the community he was at a job in Texas, and that she was sorry, and sat down, and the woman next to her put an arm around her.
Then it was my turn. I had brought the letter. I had not planned to read it. I read it. I read it in English and then I sang one of Phulmati's songs from the notebook that Aaji and I had worked out the tune for using one of the old bidesiya melodies, the song about the one who stays singing to the one who goes. My voice was not good. It did not matter. Halfway through, Aaji began to sing with me, and then Mrs. Bhagwati Prasad, the tiny woman in the white sari from the Kumars' mehndi night, who had come with her granddaughter, began to sing too from three rows back, and then a few others who knew the old melody, though not these words, hummed under it.
Nisha was crying with her face in her hands.
Afterward, while people stood in small groups with paper cups of tea, a girl of about seventeen whom I did not know came up to me and asked, very quietly, whether I could send her the words of the letter. Then she asked whether I knew anyone she could talk to about college, because her parents said she had to stay in Sacramento and she had been admitted to a summer program in Boston and they would not let her go. I gave her the counselor's card and my email. She held the card in both hands, the way Bechan held letters.
My father found out about Daniel the next morning.
My mother told him. She had waited seven weeks, thinking how, and in the end there was no how, there was only a Sunday morning in the kitchen with the dosa pan on and my father reading the Fiji news on his phone and my mother putting a plate down in front of him and saying, "Vinod, Reshmi has someone. He's a teacher. He's Mexican. They've been together almost three years. She told me in Suva."
I was on the stairs. I heard it all.
My father did not shout. My father has never shouted at me in my life. He was quiet for so long that I came down the last steps to see if he was all right. He was sitting with the plate in front of him and his hands flat on either side of it.
"Three years," he said, to me, not to my mother.
"Almost."
"And you didn't tell me."
"No."
"You told your mother. In Suva."
"Yes."
He looked at his hands. Then he said the thing. He did not say it angrily. He said it in a voice of real bewilderment, like a man reading a sign in a language he doesn't know.
"What will people say?"
I had thought for twenty-eight years about what I would answer when someone finally said it to my face. I had a hundred answers. I said none of them. I said, "Papa, Phulmati's own mother never wrote back."
He looked up at me. He did not understand. I did not explain. I went upstairs and called Daniel and asked him if he would help me look at apartments.
I moved out on the thirtieth of August, a Sunday, into a one-bedroom on the second floor of an old brick building in Midtown with tall windows and a radiator that clanked and a view of a sycamore and the back of a taqueria. Daniel and Nitin, who drove up from San Diego for it, carried my bed and my desk and the box from the closet with the UCLA letter in it. My mother came, with a cooler of food. Aaji came, and sat in my one armchair by the window and told everybody where to put things.
My father did not come. He was at the shop, my mother said. Working. A Sunday.
The last thing I unpacked was the lota. My mother had brought it in her bag without telling me. She put it on my windowsill in the afternoon sun, with its dent toward the room, and stood and looked at it and said, "It's been everywhere. It can go to Midtown."
Part of the Way
My father came to the apartment on the second Saturday of September, without calling, at eight in the morning, with his toolbox.
I opened the door in my pajamas. He stood on the landing in his work jeans and a faded Fiji rugby shirt, holding the red metal toolbox he has carried since 1996, and looked past me into the room.
"Your mother says the radiator makes noise," he said.
It did. It clanked all night like someone hitting a pipe with a spoon, though it was still ninety degrees outside and the heat was not on. The building manager had said it was the building settling. My father put the toolbox down, knelt beside the radiator, put his ear against it, and listened like a doctor. Then he took out a wrench and a rag and a small screwdriver and got to work, and for forty minutes neither of us said anything except "Hold this" and "Here."
I made tea, the way he likes it, with condensed milk. I put out cream crackers and butter on a plate because I had them, because I had bought them without thinking the week I moved in. He saw the crackers and stopped working for a second.
When the radiator was quiet he sat back on his heels and wiped his hands and drank the tea standing at the window, looking at the sycamore and the back of the taqueria, where a cook in a white apron was hosing down the steps.
"In 1984," he said, "I got a place at the university in Suva. Engineering."
"I know, Papa. Aaji told me."
"My father said no." He turned the cup in his hands. "I was so angry I didn't speak to him for a month. I slept in the shed with the tractor. Then I stopped being angry, because what was the use, and I cut cane. And then I came here and fixed cars." He drank. "I'm good at it. I like it. I'm not sorry. But I used to think, every year, if I had gone to Suva."
He looked at me.
"When the letter came from Los Angeles," he said, "I said no to you the same way. Not no. Just so many reasons. I thought I was keeping you safe. I thought, she's a girl, it's different, people will talk. I heard myself. I heard my father. I didn't stop."
I did not say anything. I was afraid that if I did he would stop.
"Your Aaji told me something last week," he said. "She said Phulmati's mother never wrote back. She said maybe the letter didn't arrive. Or maybe her mother was too ashamed to answer. Because of what people would say at the well." He put the cup down on the windowsill next to the lota. "I don't want to be the one who doesn't write back."
"Papa."
"I'm not ready to meet him," he said quickly. "Not yet. Your mother likes him. She says he carried the desk." He picked up the toolbox. "Give me a little time."
He went down the stairs. Halfway down he called back, "And you should put a rubber washer under that tap in the bathroom, it drips," and then the street door banged.
Aaji's eighty-sixth birthday was on Sunday the twentieth of September. It has been on the family calendar since I made it, with a cake symbol next to it, and with a note I added in March: Born 1940, Ba. Married 1958. Came to America 2001. Every relative's phone reminded them a week before, and then a day before, and then that morning, so there was no excuse, and nearly sixty people came to the house, which holds about thirty. They overflowed into the yard under strings of lights my father put up in the lemon tree, and into the carport, where Kaka Anil set up the grill and a folding table full of food.
Aaji had made one request for her birthday. She had made it to my father, at dinner, in front of my mother, the week after the radiator.
"I want Reshmi's boy to come," she said.
My father put down his roti.
"It's my birthday," Aaji said. "I invite who I want. I'll be eighty-six. How many more birthdays am I going to have? Fifteen?"
"Aaji," my father said. "People will be there. Everybody."
"Good," said Aaji. "Let them see."
Daniel came at four with a bunch of yellow roses and a tray of his grandmother's tamales in a cooler, because, he said, you don't go to a grandmother's birthday empty-handed, which made Aaji look at him with deep approval. He wore a blue button-down shirt that he had ironed himself and that was already wrinkled from the drive. He was nervous. He hid it the way he does, by asking questions. Within twenty minutes he was sitting on a plastic chair next to Aaji in the yard asking her about the river at Nine Mile, and she was telling him about the floods, and he was telling her about his grandfather in Fresno who had picked grapes and peaches up and down the valley for forty years and had a bad back from it and three children who went to college, and Aaji said, in English, "Same story. Different fruit."
The aunties watched. Of course they did. Shanti Auntie arrived at five in a purple sari and saw Daniel and stopped walking for a full second. Then she came over and said hello to him very sweetly and asked him where he was from, and he said Sacramento, and she said no, where are you from, and he said Sacramento, his parents were from Fresno and his grandmother from Michoacán in Mexico, and Shanti Auntie said, "Ah," and went to tell everyone.
Sereana came at six with Jone and a bundle of waka tied with string, which Jone held out to my father at the carport in both hands while Sereana said a few words in Fijian. My father, who had grown up eating Mesake's mother's fish on the veranda at Nine Mile every Sunday, took it in both hands and said, "Vinaka," and for a second looked about twelve years old. Aaji watched from her chair. Later, when Sereana had gone into the kitchen to argue with my mother about the chutney, Aaji said to me, "In Ba, Mesake's mother was in her garden before I was at the stove. Every day. Forty years." She was quiet for a while. "We said they don't work. We said it so much we stopped seeing." Then she said, "Give her gulgula to take home," and I understood that this was as near as she would come to saying sorry, and that it was near.
My father was at the grill with Kaka Anil. He did not come over for an hour. I watched him not come over. Then my mother went to the grill and said something to him, and he wiped his hands on a towel and came across the yard, slowly, the way he walks into the shop on a Monday.
Daniel stood up. My father held out his hand. They shook. The yard did not go quiet, exactly, but it went less loud.
"Vinod," my father said.
"Daniel. It's very good to meet you, sir."
My father looked at him for a long moment. Then he said, "Reshmi says your grandfather was a farmworker."
"Yes, sir. Forty years. Grapes, mostly."
My father nodded. "My great-grandmother came to Fiji to cut cane," he said. "She was four feet ten." He held his hand out flat at the height of his chest.
"I know," Daniel said. "Reshmi showed me the pass."
My father looked at me, and then back at Daniel, and something in his face shifted very slightly, the way a tight bolt does just before it turns.
"Come," he said. "Eat something. Anil's burning the chicken."
That was all. They did not become friends that afternoon. My father went back to the grill, and Daniel ate chicken and goat curry and Aaji's gulgula and his own grandmother's tamales, which Aaji ate three of, and he stayed until nine and helped fold the chairs. When he left my father was in the carport. He looked up from the grill he was cleaning and said, "Okay. Bye. Drive safe," and lifted a hand with a scrubbing brush in it. That was the part of the way he could go. I have learned to count it.
Later, in the kitchen, when only family was left and the dishwasher was running and Aaji was asleep in her chair in the living room with a paper crown from Tanvi on her head, Kaka Anil came and stood next to me at the sink while I dried the big pots.
"Tanvi wants to apply to schools next year," he said. "Far ones. Massachusetts. Georgia. One in Pennsylvania."
"I know, Kaka."
"Of course you know." He picked up a towel and started drying with me. "After Houston," he said. "After that card from the judge. I thought, okay. She's not a little girl. And then last month at the hall. Usha's evening." He dried the same pot for a long time. "I'm not going to be the father who says she can't go and then she goes anyway and doesn't call me."
He put the pot down.
"Apply," he said. "I told her last night. Next fall, apply to all of them. Start the summer programs now. We'll see where she gets in. We'll see what it costs. We'll talk. But apply."
Tanvi, it turned out, had been listening from the hallway. She came in and put her arms around her father from behind, around his whole big chest, and pressed her face against his back, and he stood there holding a dish towel with his eyes shut.
Not every family. I want to say that plainly, because the story is not true otherwise. On the same Sunday, across town, Nisha's mother was at her own sister's house for a birthday, and Nisha was not there, and had not been for twelve years, and would not be. The girl from the hall with the summer program in Boston did not go; her parents said no and she stayed and took a class at the community college instead, and wrote to me that it was fine, and I do not know if that is true. Shanti Auntie told nine people before Monday that Vinod's girl had moved out to live with a Mexican, which was not true, and which they all believed.
I know. I lived in one of those houses for twenty-eight years. It is also the house where I learned every song I know.
If This Letter Does Not Come
Fiji Day fell on a Saturday that year, the tenth of October, fifty-six years to the day since the flag went up in Suva and my grandfather stood up beside a radio at Nine Mile. In Sacramento it was the first cool morning of the fall. The sky over William Land Park was a clean hard blue, the sycamores were just starting to go yellow at the edges, and by nine o'clock the grass between the picnic shelters was covered in pop-up tents and folding tables and coolers and children.
The community has held a Fiji Day picnic in that park for as long as I have been alive. There is a cricket match on the far field that nobody watches and everybody argues about. There is a stage, which is a flatbed trailer, where Fijian choirs from West Sacramento sing in harmony, and Fijian dancers from a cultural group in Elk Grove perform with fans and grass skirts and painted faces, and children from the Saturday language class recite poems in Fiji Hindi with their hands at their sides. There is a tent where old men sit on a woven mat around a wide wooden bowl of kava, passing the coconut shell, and anybody who comes near is waved in and given a shell, and told bula, and told to clap once before and three times after. There is food from every family: curry and rice and dhal and roti, and cassava cooked every way, and fish in coconut milk with lime, and sugarcane cut into sticks for the children to chew, which nobody's mother allows and everybody's grandmother provides.
That year there was also a table under a blue tent with a hand-lettered sign that said, in English and Fiji Hindi, GIRMIT FAMILIES: BRING YOUR STORIES.
It was my table. The committee had asked me after the Girmit Day talk, and I had said yes before I could think of all the reasons to say no. On it I had Phulmati's pass, the copy, in a plastic sleeve, and the line from the court return, and the lease of 1969, and Mr. Tiwari's printout of the letter, and a framed print of one page of the Kaithi notebook. I had a laptop with a scanner and a recorder with a little microphone. I had a sign-up sheet. I had, beside me, my cousin Tanvi, who had volunteered and who had made a second sign in her own handwriting that said ASK ME ABOUT THE SHIP.
They came all day. Shanti Auntie, who had come by twice to tell me I looked thin, came a third time without a word and put down a photograph of her mother at a treadle sewing machine in Nausori, and asked, very quietly, whether I could find out what ship her mother's grandfather came on. She held my wrist while I wrote down the two names she had. Kimi sent photographs from Union City of the pages her mother had written down about their grandmother's stories of the lines, with a note: For your table. Radhika says hi. An old man from Labasa with his grandfather's ship number written on the back of an envelope. Two sisters in their sixties from Nausori who had their great-grandmother's emigration pass in a frame and had never been able to read the district name. A young father with a baby in a carrier who said his family had always said they came from Madras but he did not know where in Madras or when or how, and could I find out, and I said I could try, and I wrote down everything he knew, which was two names and a ship that might have been the Sutlej. Three teenage boys who came because Tanvi waved them over and who stayed for half an hour asking how you would find a ship list online. Mrs. Bhagwati Prasad, ninety-one, in her white sari and gray cardigan, who sat down in my chair without being asked and said, "Record me. I have a lot to say," and recorded for forty minutes about her mother's estate near Ba and the horse song and a sirdar named Ganga who wore a bowler hat in the heat. When she finished she patted my hand and said, "Now you keep that. My grandsons don't care. Someday they will. Keep it for when they care."
I asked every person before I recorded them. Some said no. That was fine. Some said yes, and then said things they asked me not to keep, and I deleted them while they watched. Most just talked.
Sereana came after lunch with her younger son carrying a long roll of masi, the bark cloth her bubu had beaten and printed in Nadroga, black and rust-red on cream, with the family's own pattern along the border. She wanted it photographed properly, she said, and she wanted to write down what each part of the pattern meant before her aunt, the last one who knew all of it, got any older. We spread it on the grass behind the table and her son held one end and Tanvi held the other, and Sereana's aunt talked on a video call from Nadroga while I typed, and it was the best hour of my day.
Around noon my mother brought her phone to the table with Paati on it, from Lautoka, where it was seven in the morning on Sunday. Paati was sitting on her front step in her cardigan with the brown dog beside her and, below her feet, a new kolam drawn in rice flour, larger than usual. She held the phone so we could see it: interlocking diamonds, the old pattern, with a small figure in the middle that she had never drawn before, a little ship with three masts.
"Fiji Day," she said. "For your table."
Then my mother, standing in the middle of the Fiji Day picnic in William Land Park with three hundred people around her and a cricket ball going over somebody's tent, held up the phone and sang the thalattu. All of it. The refrain and the verse about the girl and the parrot and the pearl, and two new verses Paati had remembered in August, after weeks of trying, and sent in voice messages at strange hours. My mother sang it badly and all the way through. Paati sang with her from Lautoka, a quarter-second behind, so that it sounded like an echo across the sea. People around the tent stopped talking. Tanvi recorded it on my phone. When it was finished Paati said, "Good. Now you have it," and hung up to go and feed the dog.
Daniel came at one. My father was at the kava bowl. I watched Daniel see him, and hesitate, and my father look up and see Daniel, and hesitate. Then my father lifted his hand and waved him over, and made room for him on the mat, and one of the old men handed Daniel a coconut shell, and my father said, "Clap once. Then drink it all. Then clap three times," and Daniel did, and made a face, because kava tastes like muddy pepper water, and the old men laughed, and my father laughed with them and slapped Daniel on the back. That was all. From across the grass, that was all it looked like. I knew what it was.
Later in the afternoon, when the shadows were long and the sycamores had gone gold in the low light and people were packing coolers, Aaji came to the table. She had been in a lawn chair under the kava tent all day, holding court. She sat down in my chair and looked at the pass in its sleeve for a long time.
"I want to do the thing," she said. "The thing for later."
I knew what she meant. I had made the family a place in the spring where anyone could leave a message to be opened at a certain date, years ahead, by a certain person. My mother had left one for Nitin's first child, if he ever has one. Kaka Anil had left one for Tanvi's college graduation and would not tell anybody what was in it. Aaji had refused, until now, saying she did not know what to say to people who did not exist.
I clipped the microphone to her cardigan. She asked me who would hear it.
"Whoever you want," I said. "Tanvi's children. Mine. Whoever is in the family in thirty years."
She thought about it. Then she spoke for nine minutes in Fiji Hindi into the little microphone, while Tanvi and I sat on the grass and did not listen, on purpose. When she was done she unclipped the microphone herself and handed it to me.
"Open it in 2056," she said. "Two hundred years. Not of me. Of the girmit. More or less."
I did the arithmetic in my head. The Leonidas came in 1879. Phulmati in 1896. "Aaji, that's not two hundred years from anything."
"It's two hundred years from her mother," Aaji said. "From when her mother was a girl at the well. More or less." She stood up with her cane. "I said more or less."
We packed the table at six. Tanvi carried the framed Kaithi page to the car as if it were made of glass. I drove Aaji home and then drove back to Midtown, to my apartment with the quiet radiator and the dripping tap I still had not fixed, and the lota on the windowsill, and I sat at my desk in the dark and opened the folder called Family.
Phulmati is still a gray circle. There are no photographs. There never will be. But under the circle there are now her height and her mark and her five shillings and her man and wife and her sixty-one songs and her letter to her mother. Under Valli's circle there is a lullaby, sung by her great-granddaughter in a park in California, and more than two hundred kolam from a step in Lautoka. Under my own circle there is a line I added that night, the only thing I have ever written about myself in that tree. It is the last line of Phulmati's letter, in her Bhojpuri, as Mr. Tiwari wrote it down, with my own voice beside it, singing it to the old bidesiya tune, badly.
If this letter does not come, I am still alive.
I sang it twice more to the empty room. Then I opened the window. The air was cool and smelled of the taqueria and the river and the first rain somewhere far off in the hills, and down on the street somebody was laughing in a language I did not know, and I sang it again, a little louder, the way she would have, so that it would carry.
About this book

Reshmi Narayan is twenty-seven, an archivist in Sacramento, and the only daughter everyone in the Fiji Indian community is watching. The aunties want to know when she will marry. Her brother lives in San Diego with a surfboard and nobody asks him anything. She has a boyfriend her family has never heard of.
Then a copy of an emigration pass arrives from Suva. Her great-great-grandmother Phulmati was nineteen, four feet ten and a half inches tall, with a scar on her wrist and a husband who had vanished into the Calcutta jute mills. She went to find him, and found a ship.
Moving between Reshmi's year and the documents that bring her ancestors back, from the depot at Garden Reach to the cane lines at Rarawai, from a Tamil lullaby in Lautoka to a notebook in a forgotten script, Black Water, Sweet Cane follows two indentured families across five generations, three coups and an ocean. It is a story of songs carried in memory, of a community that held on tight to survive and now has to learn to let go, and of a young woman who keeps her culture on her own terms.
Members can react to this book and talk about it in the members' Library.