
The Bakery on Colaba Lane
Two Unmarried Parsi Siblings in Their Sixties, Their Parents' 1931 Brick Oven, a Developer with a Six-Crore Offer, a Court Order on Wood Fuel and a Secret from 1983 Nobody Baked Into the Recipe
by V. Ashtapad
Foreword
This is a work of fiction. Colaba, the Causeway, Cusrow Baug, Sassoon Dock, the Parsi bakeries and Irani cafés of Bombay, Navroz, the 1944 explosion in the Victoria Dock, the city's push to move old bakeries off wood fuel, cess buildings and their redevelopment, and the MahaRERA project register are real. Colaba Lane, Pavri & Co., Galaxy Habitat, the Karachi branch and every named person in the story are invented.
For the people who light the oven before anyone else is awake.
Dilnavaz: Five-Fifteen
The oven is lit before I am. That is the first rule of Pavri & Co., and it has been the first rule since 1931, and I am sixty-four years old and I have never once beaten Benedict down the stairs.
"Good morning, Dilnavaz-bai," he says, without turning round. He is on his knees in front of the firebox with a casuarina log in each hand, feeding it the way you feed a baby who does not want to eat, one spoon at a time. "It is sulking today."
"It sulks every Tuesday."
"Today is Wednesday."
"Then it is confused," I say, and I go to the sink and put on my apron, which is the same blue checked apron my mother wore and her mother-in-law before her, or at least the same pattern, because the cloth man on Abdul Rehman Street keeps a bolt of it for us and nobody else in Bombay wants it.
I know the city is called Mumbai. I write Mumbai on the GST forms. But at five-fifteen in the morning with flour on my hands it is Bombay, and anybody who wants to argue with me about it can come down and knead forty kilos of pav dough first.
The bakery is on Colaba Lane, which is not on any map you will find, because the municipal people gave it a number in 1962 and a different number in 1979, and the post office uses a third. Everybody who lives here calls it Colaba Lane. It runs off the Causeway between a chemist and a shop that sells phone covers with the faces of cricketers on them, and it is narrow enough that when two handcarts meet, one of them must go backwards, and there is always a fight about which.
Our shop is the third door on the left. Pavri & Co. Bakers and Confectioners. Est. 1931. The board is green with gold letters, and the gold has gone the color of weak tea, and twice a year Kaizad tells me he will get it repainted, and twice a year I tell him, "Touch that board and I will put you in the oven."
By five-thirty the dough is in the troughs. By six the first trays of pav go in, and the smell comes up through the floor into every flat in the building, and the building wakes up whether it wants to or not. Mrs. Villoo Contractor on the second floor has complained about the smell every year since 1988. Every year at Diwali she also orders three kilos of nankhatai. I have stopped pointing this out to her.
"Your brother," says Benedict, sliding the first peel of pav into the dark, "comes tonight?"
"Tonight."
"Eleven?"
"The flight lands at nine-forty. Then the immigration line. Then he will argue with the prepaid taxi man. Then he will sit on the Sea Link and complain about the toll. Eleven-thirty."
"Should I keep some bun maska?"
"He is coming from London, Benedict. They have bread in London."
Benedict looks at me over his shoulder. He is fifty-eight, from Saligao in Goa, and he has worked for this family since he was nineteen, which means he has been in this room for thirty-nine years, longer than I was married to nobody, as my mother used to say, which was her joke and not a good one. He has arms like a stevedore and the softest voice on the lane.
"I will keep some bun maska," he says.
---
The bun maska goes out at six-forty-five in a stainless steel tray to the Irani café on the corner, which is not Irani anymore, it is owned by a man from Udupi, but it still has the bentwood chairs and the mirror with the crack shaped like Sri Lanka and the sign that says NO COMBING HAIR. The pav goes out in plastic crates on the backs of two bicycles: forty dozen to the pav-bhaji stalls near the Gateway, eighteen dozen to the hostel near the Navy Nagar gate, twelve dozen to a vada pav man at the bus depot who pays on Saturdays, sometimes.
At seven the shutter goes up. The noise of the shutter is the noise of my whole life. A long rattling roar and then a bang, and then the lane can see in.
"Bai! Two khari, one mawa!"
That is Iqbal, the taxi man, who parks his black-and-yellow Santro at the mouth of the lane every morning to the fury of the chemist. He has been eating two khari and one mawa cake every morning since his taxi was a Padmini, and the Padmini died in 2023 along with all the other Padminis, and there was a parade for them with garlands, and Iqbal cried on the news.
"Thirty-five for the mawa, Iqbal."
"Since when thirty-five?"
"Since butter."
"Butter is my enemy," says Iqbal, and pays.
Then the schoolchildren, who want the cream rolls and get the khari because their mothers have told me. Then Mr. Kapadia, the retired judge, who asks for bun maska "with a proper amount of maska, not a Marwari amount," and whom I have told forty times that the man who supplies our butter is a Marwari and will be offended. Then the Navy boys, cadets in white, with their hair cut so short their ears look surprised. Then the Instagram girls.
The Instagram girls are new. They have been coming for two years, since a woman with eighty thousand followers put a picture of our mawa cakes online and wrote, Old-world Parsi magic tucked away off the Causeway!! Since then they come in twos and threes, and they stand in front of the glass case for ten minutes taking photos of the cakes from above, and from the side, and with their hand in front, and with a coffee they have brought from somewhere else in a paper cup with their name spelled wrong on it.
"Aunty," says one of them this morning, "can I get a picture of you?"
"No."
"Just one? With the oven?"
"The oven is shy."
She laughs, which means she thinks I am joking, which means she will try again tomorrow.
---
At nine the morning is over and the second morning begins, which is the accounts.
I do the accounts at the back table under the calendar from the Bharat Flour Mills, which has a picture of a happy wheat field in a place that does not look like India. My mother did the accounts here for sixty years in a hardback ledger. I do them in a hardback ledger too, and then Kaizad puts them in the computer on Saturdays, and then the chartered accountant in Fort tells me what I already know.
Today there is a letter.
It came on Monday, and I have read it nine times, and I have put it under the ledger so I do not have to look at it while I eat my breakfast, which is a cup of tea and the end of yesterday's bread with a scrape of Amul.
It is from the municipal corporation, ward A. It is two pages, in English and Marathi, and it refers to an order of the High Court, and it says, in the language of people who have never stood in front of an oven at five in the morning, that all bakeries in the ward using wood, coal or other solid fuels are directed to convert to cleaner fuel, gas or electric, within a period of six months from the date of this notice, failing which the establishment's license is liable to be.
Liable to be.
I understand the reason. I am not a stupid woman. The air in this city in November looks like milk tea. Benedict coughs. I cough. Every bakery on this side of the city is a little chimney.
But I have had three men come to look at the oven since Monday. The first said fourteen lakh for an electric deck oven, plus the wiring, plus the load sanction from the electricity company, plus, plus. The second said gas would be cheaper, nine lakh, but the gas pipeline does not come into Colaba Lane, so I would need cylinders, commercial ones, at eighteen hundred rupees each, and a license for the cylinder bank, and a wall knocked down. The third looked at the oven for a long time with his hands on his hips and then said, "Aunty, this is a beautiful oven," and went away without giving me a quote at all.
It is a beautiful oven. My grandfather Behram built it with a bricklayer from Navsari in 1931. It is a brick dome as long as a taxi, and its mouth is an iron door with a handle shaped like a horse's ear, and the inside of the dome is black and smooth as a pot. You cannot convert it. You can only stop it.
I put the letter back under the ledger.
My mother would have known what to do. My mother died five weeks ago on a Thursday afternoon at the age of ninety-three, sitting in the chair by the window upstairs with a bowl of custard on her lap that she had not touched, and I came up at four to take the bowl away and she had gone, quite politely, the way she did everything. Her will was read in a lawyer's office on Rampart Row by a man with nasal hair and a fountain pen, and it said, in two lines, that Pavri & Co. and all its goodwill and stock and fittings, and the tenancy of the premises at Colaba Lane, were left to her two children, Dilnavaz Jehangir Pavri and Farokh Jehangir Pavri, in equal shares.
Equal shares. To me, who has stood in this room for forty-two years, and to my brother, who has lived in Harrow since 1983 and who used to phone on Sundays and say, "Is it hot?" as if the answer would ever be no.
I am being unfair. I know I am being unfair. He came for her last birthday. He came in 2019 when Pappa's anniversary fell on a Sunday. He sends money at Navroz which I put in a separate account and do not touch, out of pride, which is stupid, because the account is now quite large.
And he has sent me an email.
Kaizad printed it for me. It is in capital letters because Farokh does not know how to turn the capitals off on his phone, or he knows and does not care.
DILNAVAZ. ARRIVING WEDS NIGHT. HAVE BEEN LOOKING AT OPTIONS. WE MUST DISCUSS PROPERLY. NOT IN FRONT OF BENEDICT. LOVE F.
Options. A man from London is coming to my oven with options.
---
At eleven-twenty that night I am sitting on the step of the shop with the shutter down behind me and a moth trying to commit suicide on the tube light over the door. The lane is quiet. The phone-cover shop has its shutter down too, with a padlock as big as a fist. Two dogs are asleep under the handcart that belongs to the coconut man. Somewhere toward the Causeway a party is going on in a flat with its windows open, and someone is singing an old Kishore Kumar song very badly, and everyone is clapping.
It is March, and the heat has come back early. My blouse is stuck to my back. The air smells of the dock at Sassoon, which is fish and diesel, and of jasmine from the flower woman's basket that she leaves under the stairs, and of our oven, which is still warm and will be warm until morning, because a brick oven like that never gets truly cold, not once in ninety-five years.
A taxi stops at the mouth of the lane. Iqbal's taxi, as it happens, because Iqbal does the airport run at night when his son drives the day shift. The back door opens and a man gets out, a thin man with gray hair that is too long at the back and a raincoat over his arm, in March, in Bombay.
He stands there for a moment looking at the lane. Then he pays Iqbal, and there is an argument, which I can hear but not understand, and which ends with both men laughing.
He comes down the lane pulling two suitcases. One of the wheels squeaks. He stops in front of me.
"Hullo, Dilu," says my brother.
"You are late."
"Iqbal says the Sea Link toll is now a hundred and something. A hundred and something, Dilu! For a bridge!"
"It is a long bridge."
He puts down the suitcases. He looks tired, and old, older than in 2019, and his face has the London color, which is the color of a potato before you cook it. He is holding a plastic bag. He holds it out.
"I brought biscuits," he says.
I look at the bag. Marks & Spencer. All-butter shortbread. Two packets.
"Farokh," I say. "This is a bakery."
"I know it's a bakery," he says. "They're for you. Not for the bakery. For you."
I take the bag. Then I stand up, because my knee is hurting and if I sit any longer it will set like cement, and I put my arms around my little brother, who smells of airplane and of whatever soap they give you in London, and he puts his arms around me, and for a moment neither of us says anything at all, because Mamma is not upstairs, and we both know it.
"Benedict saved you some bun maska," I say into his shoulder.
"Of course he did," says Farokh.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Farokh: Options
I want to state for the record, before my sister tells you otherwise, that I am not a monster.
I am a retired claims assessor. For thirty-four years I worked for an insurance company in the City of London, on the eleventh floor of a building on Fenchurch Street with a view of another building on Fenchurch Street, and I looked at what had gone wrong in other people's lives and calculated what it was worth. A warehouse in Thurrock that burned down. A yacht that sank in the Solent with nobody on it. A restaurant in Leicester whose walk-in refrigerator failed on the night before a wedding of four hundred people. I was good at it. I was careful and I was fair, and I was known on the eleventh floor as the man who would find out what really happened, which is a different thing from what people say happened, nearly always.
So when I say I have been looking at options, I mean that I have been doing what I am trained to do. I mean that I have read the letter from the municipal corporation that Kaizad photographed and sent me on WhatsApp. I mean that I have read about the landlord. I mean that I have had a phone call from a man named Hitesh Gala.
I did not mean to keep that from Dilu. I just had not found a good moment to tell her, and between the arrival at eleven-thirty and the bun maska and the business of carrying two suitcases up two flights of stairs with a knee that is sixty-one years old, the good moment did not come. And then at a quarter past eight the next morning, Mr. Hitesh Gala came instead.
---
I should describe my room first. It was my room from the age of six. It is above the bakery, at the back, and the floor is old teak boards with gaps between them, so that the heat of the oven comes straight up through the gaps from five in the morning, along with the smell, and the noise of Benedict singing Konkani songs to the dough. I used to lie in this bed as a boy and feel the floor get warm under me, and that was how I knew it was morning, not from any light.
Last night I lay in this bed again and listened to a city I had forgotten was so loud. Motorbikes. A dog fight. The party with the Kishore Kumar. Then at three, a sudden silence, so total that I could hear the tap dripping in the bathroom down the hall. Then at four-forty, a crow. Then at five, Benedict's footsteps and the scrape of the firebox door.
I lay on my back and felt the floor warm up under the bed, and I thought: I am a sixty-one-year-old man who has been to the Lake District and to Vienna and to a conference in Dubai, and I have a pension and a Freedom Pass and a flat in Harrow with double glazing, and the moment the floor gets warm I am six.
That is the problem with this building. That has always been the problem with this building.
---
Hitesh Gala came at eight-fifteen in a white Toyota Fortuner with tinted windows which could not, of course, come into the lane, so it stopped at the mouth and blocked Iqbal's taxi, and the chemist came out to watch, delighted, because now someone was blocking Iqbal.
Mr. Gala is perhaps forty-five. He wore a white linen shirt that had been ironed by a professional, and loafers without socks, and a watch that was trying to tell me something. He had two young men with him carrying folders. He walked into the bakery like a man walking into a house he has already bought.
"Farokh-ji," he said, holding out both hands to me. "Welcome home. My condolences on your mother. A great lady. A great Bombay lady."
"You didn't know my mother," said my sister from behind the counter.
"Everybody knew your mother, Aunty," said Mr. Gala, smiling at her with very white teeth. "Everybody in Colaba."
"She didn't know you."
Mr. Gala laughed as if she had made a delightful joke. The young men with the folders laughed too, a bit late.
I took him to the back table because there was nowhere else. Benedict was sliding a tray of khari out of the oven, and the smell came across the room like a hand on the back of the neck. Puff pastry and butter, baked until it shatters. Mr. Gala looked at the khari the way a man looks at a woman he is not supposed to look at.
"May I?"
"Forty rupees," said Dilnavaz.
He paid. He ate one standing up. He closed his eyes. Then he opened them and was a businessman again.
"Farokh-ji. Let me be very simple, because I know you are a numbers man. This building is a cess building, built 1921, under the repair board. It is falling down, slowly, like all of them. The landlord is a trust. The trust has agreed terms with my company for redevelopment. We will build a tower of twenty-two floors. Every residential tenant will get a new flat, bigger, with a lift, with parking, free, plus a rent allowance for the three years of construction. Already sixty-one percent of tenants have signed. The commercial tenants, there are four, you, the chemist, the phone-cover shop and the tailor, we offer two options."
He held up two fingers. His nails had been buffed.
"Option one. A commercial unit of equal area in the new building, ground floor, after completion. Plus a rent allowance during construction. Option two. Surrender of tenancy. One-time payment."
He took a folder from one of the young men and opened it on the table in front of me. He had put a little yellow sticky note on the page with the number.
Six crore, twenty lakh rupees.
I am a numbers man. I did the conversion in my head before I could stop myself. It is roughly six hundred thousand pounds. My flat in Harrow is worth three hundred and ten thousand pounds on a good day.
"And what if we say no to both?" I said.
"Then, Farokh-ji," said Mr. Gala gently, "you will have a beautiful old bakery in a building that is coming down around it. And the municipal people will come for your oven in six months anyway. I'm only saying. I'm not threatening. I'm saying what is."
"Get out," said my sister.
Everyone turned. She was standing at the end of the counter with a pair of steel tongs in her hand, the long ones Benedict uses for the khari trays, and she was holding them not like a weapon, exactly, but not like tongs either.
"Dilnavaz-bai," began Mr. Gala.
"You have eaten your khari. You have paid. Now you are a customer who has finished. Please, the door is there, and please tell your driver he is in Iqbal's place."
Mr. Gala stood up. He was not offended, I think. He was a man who had been told to get out of a great many places in Bombay and had come back to all of them. He left the folder on the table.
"Think, Farokh-ji," he said to me, very kindly. "You are an educated man. Think about what is best for your sister."
And he went, with his young men, and the Fortuner backed out of the lane into the Causeway with its reverse beeper playing a tune, and the chemist applauded.
---
My sister did not speak to me until eleven.
At eleven she came and sat down across the table from me and put a cup of tea in front of me, which is how I knew she was angrier than I had thought. When Dilu is mildly angry she does not give you tea. When she is very angry she gives you the best tea, in the good cup, the one with the gold rim, so that you will understand the size of what you have done.
"You knew," she said.
"He rang me in London. Two weeks ago. Kaizad must have given him my number. I didn't think anything would come of it."
"Kaizad did not give him your number. Kaizad would sooner give his number to a snake. Mrs. Villoo gave him your number. Mrs. Villoo has signed. Mrs. Villoo wants a lift."
"She is eighty-two, Dilu. She lives on the second floor. Of course she wants a lift."
"I know what she wants."
I drank the tea. It was very good tea. It always is in this house, made with milk boiled twice and lemongrass from the pot on the window, and a pinch of something my mother never told anybody.
"Six crore," I said.
"I heard."
"Dilu. You are sixty-four. You get up at four-forty-five. Your knee is bad, don't tell me it isn't, I watched you go up the stairs last night like a woman climbing the Matterhorn. The oven has to be replaced in six months or the license goes, and it will cost you more than you make in two years. The building is coming down whatever you decide. I'm not saying we must take it. I'm saying we must think."
"You are saying we must take it."
"I'm saying it's an option."
"Options." She said the word like something that had gone bad in the fridge. "You know what the bakery makes, Farokh? On a good day? Thirty-eight thousand. Good day. Bad day, nineteen. Out of that comes Benedict, and Raju and Sanjay, and the flour, and the butter, and the mawa, and the logs from Vasai, and the electricity, and the rent, which is four hundred and twelve rupees a month because of the tenancy law, and that is the only reason we are still alive."
"I know that."
"You don't know that. You know a number in an email."
"I'm trying to know it. That's why I'm here."
She looked at me for a long moment. Her eyes are our father's, dark and heavy-lidded and very hard to argue with.
"You're here," she said, "because Mamma died."
And she took the good cup away, though I had not finished.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Kaizad: The Counter, Mostly
My name is Kaizad Bharucha, I am nineteen years old, I am in the second year of a commerce degree at a college in Churchgate that I will not name because they would not want to be associated with my attendance record, and I have worked the morning counter at Pavri & Co. since I was fifteen, for which I am paid three thousand rupees a month and all the broken khari I can eat.
Technically I am not a Pavri. My grandmother was a Pavri. She was Dilnavaz-aunty's and Farokh-uncle's first cousin, the daughter of their father's brother, and she married a Bharucha and moved to Dadar, and her daughter, who is my mother Shernaz, married my father Gustad, who sells water purifiers, and we live in a two-bedroom flat in Cusrow Baug, which is a Parsi colony on the Causeway, seven minutes' walk from the bakery or four if Iqbal gives you a lift.
So the old people at the bakery are my mother's mother's cousins. I call them Dilu-aunty and Farokh-uncle. In our community everybody is your aunty or uncle unless they are your mamaiji, and you can work out the exact relationship later, at a wedding, on a napkin.
I'm telling you this because there's been a lot of discussion this week about who is family and who has a say, and I want to make it clear from the start that I have no say. Nobody has asked me. I'm the boy at the counter.
But I see everything from the counter.
---
What I've seen this week is two old people circling each other like cats who've been put in the same room.
Farokh-uncle has been here five days. He's tried to help. This has been a disaster. On Thursday he reorganized the glass case so the mawa cakes were at the front, "for visibility," and Dilu-aunty put them all back at the side, "because the sun comes in at ten and melts the icing on the cream rolls if they're in front," and they didn't speak until lunch. On Friday he tried to buy the butter from a different supplier who was eleven rupees cheaper per kilo and Dilu-aunty phoned the different supplier and cancelled the order, and then phoned the usual supplier, Mr. Agarwal, and apologized to him for fifteen minutes. On Saturday he wanted to know why Raju and Sanjay sleep in the loft over the store room and whether this is legal. Dilu-aunty said, "Ask them."
So Farokh-uncle asked them. Raju is twenty-two and from a village near Darbhanga in Bihar, and Sanjay is his cousin, twenty, and they've worked here three years, and they sleep in the loft because it's free and it's dry and it's two minutes from the oven, and they send eleven thousand rupees home every month each, and they would rather die than pay rent in Bombay.
"But is it legal?" said Farokh-uncle.
Raju thought about it.
"Uncle," he said politely, "in Bombay, what is legal?"
Farokh-uncle went upstairs and didn't come down until Benedict knocked on his door with a plate of dhansak at one.
---
I like Farokh-uncle, actually. I want to say that. He's funny in a dry way that takes a while to notice, and he's very polite to everyone, including the Instagram girls, whom he calls "the photographers," and he asks questions and writes down the answers in a small black notebook with an elastic band around it. He wrote down what Iqbal pays for CNG. He wrote down the price of a crate of eggs. He wrote down the name of the cat.
The cat doesn't have a name. It's a ginger cat with half a tail that lives in the alley behind the bakery and comes in through the back at eight to sit in the warm patch by the oven door. Dilu-aunty calls it "that animal." Benedict calls it "Sir." Raju and Sanjay call it something in Maithili which they say means "the landlord."
Farokh-uncle wrote down all three.
---
Every afternoon at four, Aunty Roshan comes for tea.
Aunty Roshan is eighty-nine. She's Dilu-aunty's and Farokh-uncle's father's sister, the last one left of that generation, and she lives alone in a flat in Cusrow Baug two buildings from ours, with a woman named Mangala who cooks for her and a parrot who says "Chup!" whenever the phone rings. She walks to the bakery every day at four with a cane made of something black and shiny, wearing a printed dress that stops just below the knee and white canvas shoes and a pair of enormous sunglasses that make her look like an insect, a very glamorous insect. She sits at the back table in my great-grandmother's chair, and I bring her tea in the gold-rim cup, and a slice of the plain sponge, not the mawa, because the mawa is "too rich after three o'clock," and she tells everybody what they're doing wrong.
On Monday she told Benedict the pav was too pale. She told Raju his hair was too long. She told me my phone was rotting my brain. And she told Farokh-uncle he had become an Englishman.
"I have not become an Englishman, Roshan-fui."
"You say 'sorry' when you bump into a chair. A chair, Farokh! Only an Englishman apologizes to furniture."
She said this to me later too, when Farokh-uncle had gone up, while I was clearing the cup.
"He was always the soft one," she said. "Even as a small boy. Dilnavaz would hit him and he would apologize to her. Jehangir worried about him all the time. My brother. Your great-grand-uncle. You know he was a terrible worrier?"
I didn't know. I didn't know much about him at all, except that his photograph is on the wall above the till, a man with a long serious face and a black cap, and that Dilu-aunty touches the frame every morning before she puts up the shutter, very quickly, as if checking it's still there.
"Tell me about him," I said.
Aunty Roshan looked at me over the top of the insect sunglasses.
"Why?"
"I want to know."
"Since when does your generation want to know anything?"
"Since now, Aunty."
She considered me. Then she said, "Sit," and I sat, and I took out my phone, and she said, "Put that thing away," and I said, "Aunty, I want to record it, so that it's kept," and she said, "Kept where? In the phone? The phone will be in the gutter in a year."
"Not in the phone. In the family folder. Mummy set it up. Only family can see it. It's private. Every cousin has a login. When Mamaiji died, all her videos were there. The ones where she sang."
Aunty Roshan was quiet for a moment. Then she took her sunglasses off, which she never does indoors, and tucked them into the pocket of her dress.
"Your Mamaiji had a horrible voice," she said. "Like a door. Go on, then. Press the thing."
I pressed the thing.
---
What she told me that first afternoon was about Behram Pavri, her father, Dilu-aunty's grandfather, who came from Navsari to Bombay in 1928 with one oven tin and one recipe and nineteen rupees in a cloth tied round his waist.
He was twenty-two. He had worked in his uncle's bakery in Navsari since he was eleven. The uncle had four sons, so there was no future for a nephew. He came on the train with his tin wrapped in a dhoti, and he worked for three years in a bakery in Bhendi Bazaar run by an Irani from Yazd, sleeping on the flour sacks, which is exactly what Raju and Sanjay do now, Aunty Roshan pointed out, so Farokh can stop worrying about whether it is legal. In 1931 he had saved enough, with a loan from a Parsi charitable fund and another loan from the Irani, who liked him, to take the tenancy of this shop. He built the oven himself with a bricklayer called Kanji from his own village. It took them four months. They tested it on Navroz morning, the twenty-first of March, 1931, with a batch of pav, and the pav was burnt on one side and raw on the other, and Behram sat on the floor and laughed until he cried.
"Why did he laugh?" I asked.
"Because it was his," said Aunty Roshan. "Burnt and raw. But his. Write that down. No. You're recording. Good."
She talked for forty-one minutes. I know because the phone told me. She talked about the recipe for the mawa cake, which she said was the Irani's, not Behram's, "but don't tell Dilnavaz." She talked about the war, when there was no butter and they used Dalda, and the customers complained, and Behram put up a sign that said, WE ARE ALSO SUFFERING. She talked about the Navy officers who came in the fifties and sixties, the Englishmen who stayed after Independence, who wanted their bread sliced, and how Behram bought a slicing machine from a firm in Byculla and it took the end off his finger in the first week.
"Which finger?"
"This one." She held up her left hand and bent the little finger. "He used to say he had paid the oven in advance."
Then Mangala came to take her home, and Aunty Roshan put her sunglasses back on and stood up, very slowly, on her shiny cane, and said to me, "Same time tomorrow?" and I said yes, and she said, "Bring a better question," and walked out of the shop into the heat of the lane without looking back.
---
That night I uploaded the recording to the family folder and wrote a caption: Roshan-fui on Behram Pavri and the oven, Part 1. Recorded at the bakery, back table.
By eleven-thirty it had been listened to by my mother, my mother's sister in Pune, a cousin in Toronto I have never met, a cousin in Auckland who wrote "!!!!!!!" under it, and Farokh-uncle, who listened at 11:14 p.m., in his room above my head, in the bed where the floor gets warm.
He didn't write anything. But in the morning, when I came in at six-thirty to open the till, he was already down there in a vest and pajama pants, sitting on an upturned flour crate in front of the oven with a cup of tea, watching Benedict feed the firebox.
"Sir," said Benedict to the cat, who had arrived early.
"Sir," said Farokh-uncle to the cat as well, and the cat, for the first time in its life, looked at him as if it were considering an answer.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Dilnavaz: The Ledger
My brother wants to see the books.
He asked on Thursday, nicely, and I said no. He asked again on Saturday, nicely, and I said I would think about it. On Sunday he did not ask. He came down at nine with his little black notebook and sat at the back table across from me while I did the accounts and did not say anything at all, just sat there with his hands folded on the notebook like a boy waiting outside the headmaster's office.
After twenty minutes I turned the ledger round and pushed it across.
"Don't write in it."
"I wouldn't dream."
"And don't lick your finger to turn the pages. Pappa used to lick his finger. The corners are all soft."
He turned the pages with the very edge of a fingernail, like a man handling a butterfly. I watched him read. He reads fast, Farokh. Faster than me. He always did. When we were children he would read a whole Enid Blyton in an afternoon on the cool floor of the landing and then tell me the ending to make me cry.
He read March, and February, and January. He read the flour column and the butter column. He went back to October and read the Diwali weeks. He made small notes in his notebook in handwriting so tiny I could not read it upside down, though I tried.
"Who is A.R.?" he said.
"Which A.R.?"
"There's a line every month. Two thousand rupees. A.R. No explanation."
I took the ledger back and closed it.
"That's private."
"Dilu, it's the business. There's no private in the business."
"Then it's not the business," I said. "It's me."
He looked at me. I looked at the calendar with the wheat field. After a while he said, quite gently, "All right," and wrote something in his notebook and closed it and snapped the elastic band round it.
A.R. is Ashok Rane. He was our delivery man from 1979 to 2011. He has emphysema and lives with his son in a one-room place in Kalachowki and cannot work, and the son drives an Ola and is not a good son, and so every month on the fifth I give Ashok's wife two thousand rupees in an envelope, as Pappa did for the man before him and Mamma did after Pappa. That is not a line in the business. That is just what we do. But I could not see how to say it to a man from Fenchurch Street with a notebook without it sounding like a story about being good, and I am not good, I am just used to things.
---
The truth about the numbers, which my brother knows now, because he is not stupid, is that we are alive but only just.
Flour has gone up nineteen percent in three years. Butter, thirty-one. Mawa, which is milk boiled down until it is a soft fudge and which we buy from a man in Bhuleshwar who has made it in the same iron pans since before Independence, has gone up so much I do not like to say it. Casuarina logs from Vasai, sixty percent, because the trucks cannot come into the city in the day anymore, only at night, and the drivers want night money.
We have not put up the price of pav since 2022. Pav is twenty-four rupees for a packet of six. The pav-bhaji men at the Gateway sell a plate for a hundred and sixty. If I put up the price of pav they will go to the factory bakery in Wadala, whose pav is made by machine and tastes of cotton wool, and their customers will not know the difference, or they will know and not care, because they are tourists from Pune and they are only here for one day.
So we make our money on the mawa cakes and the khari and the nankhatai and the Navroz orders and the Christmas plum cakes, and the cream rolls the schoolchildren want and do not get, and the wedding orders for lagan nu custard in big foil trays. And the pav keeps the lane fed, and keeps the oven warm for the things that pay.
Farokh understood all that in forty minutes. I watched him understand it. At the end he sat back in Mamma's chair, which he should not sit in, and rubbed his eyes under his glasses.
"You're running a charity with a side business in cake," he said.
"I'm running a bakery."
"And the oven?"
I did not answer.
"Dilu. The oven. Fourteen lakh. Where is it going to come from?"
"There is an account," I said, before I could stop myself.
"What account?"
"The account where I put the money you send at Navroz."
There was a silence. Benedict, at the trough, stopped kneading. Raju, carrying a sack, stopped carrying it. The cat, by the oven door, did not stop doing anything, because the cat does nothing, but I felt it listening.
"You put it in an account," said Farokh.
"Every year."
"Since when?"
"Since you started sending it."
"That's 1991."
"I know when it is."
"You never touched it?"
"Why would I touch it? It's yours."
My brother took off his glasses. Then he put them back on. Then he said something in English very quietly that I will not repeat, and got up, and went out of the back door into the alley where the cat lives, and stood there for a long time with his hands on his hips, looking at the wall of the next building, which has a peepal tree growing out of a crack at the second floor and a sign painted on it from the 1970s that says, in faded red, BEST TONIC FOR WEAKNESS, CALL 2836.
---
That evening I found him on the roof.
The roof of our building is flat, with a water tank and a lot of television dishes nobody uses, and Mrs. Villoo's drying lines, and a broken wooden chair someone carried up in the 1990s and nobody has carried down. From the edge, if you stand on the parapet, which you must not, you can see over the next buildings to the sea at Colaba Point, a gray stripe, and the lights of the boats at Sassoon Dock, and on the other side the lit-up crown of the Taj hotel looking pleased with itself.
Farokh was sitting on the broken chair. I sat on the edge of the water tank's concrete base, which is too low for my knee, so I sat down in three parts, like a camel.
"How much is in it?" he said, without looking at me.
"About eleven lakh. With interest."
"Eleven lakh." He laughed, not happily. "I used to send it so you'd buy yourself something. A trip. A holiday. Mamma said you never went anywhere."
"I went to Udvada in 2004."
"For two days, Dilu."
"It was a nice two days."
The sea wind came over the roof, warm, smelling of salt and dried fish and, faintly, of the mango seller on the Causeway, because it is March and the first Alphonsos have come in from Ratnagiri, twelve hundred rupees a dozen, which only the Instagram girls and the Navy officers' wives can buy.
"I used to think," said my brother, "that you thought I'd run away."
"You did run away."
"Pappa sent me."
"Yes," I said. "He did."
He turned to look at me then. I could not see his face properly in the dark. I could see the shape of his head and the light from the Taj on the side of his glasses.
"Why did he?" said Farokh. "You know, don't you. You've always known. Why me and not you?"
I looked at the sea. It is a thing I have been asked once before in my life, by my mother, on the day Farokh left, in 1983, and I did not answer her then either.
"It's late," I said. "Benedict lights the oven at five."
"Dilu."
"Five, Farokh," I said, and I got up in three parts, and went down.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Farokh: Sassoon Dock
I could not sleep, and so at four-fifteen I got up and went out.
You can walk in Colaba at four-fifteen in the morning. It is not like London, where four-fifteen is the hour of the foxes and the night buses and men being sick into bins. In Colaba at four-fifteen the city is already starting. The milk vans are out. The newspaper men are sitting on the pavement outside the Regal circle sorting the Times of India and the Mid-Day and the Marathi papers into piles with their bare feet holding down the corners. A man is washing a BEST bus at the depot with a hose. A pair of policemen in khaki are drinking tea from a flask on their motorbike.
I walked down the Causeway past the shuttered shops, the ones that sell kurtas and hippie trousers and bags with elephants on them to the backpackers, and past the shuttered café where Pappa used to take us on our birthdays for a raspberry soda in a glass bottle, which is now a bar called something like Lounge. I walked down past the bus depot and the electric company, and the smell found me before I saw anything: the dock.
Sassoon Dock is the oldest wet dock in Bombay, built by a Baghdadi Jewish merchant in the 1870s, and it smells exactly as it did in 1972. That is to say it smells like a fish's whole life and death in one breath. Prawns and bombil and pomfret and ice and diesel and rope and wet wood and the black water of the harbor, and the sweat of five hundred people, because at four-forty-five in the morning the boats are in, and the auction has started.
I stood at the gate and was nearly knocked down by a Koli woman with a basket of prawns on her head the size of a cartwheel. She was wearing a green nine-yard sari tucked up between her legs and a great deal of gold, and she said something to me in Marathi that I did not catch but whose meaning was clear. I said sorry. She looked at me in disbelief and moved on.
Roshan-fui is right. I apologize to everything.
---
My father used to bring me here.
Not Dilu. Me. On Sunday mornings when I was eight and nine and ten, to buy pomfret for the Sunday lunch, because Mamma trusted him to choose fish and nothing else in this world. He would walk me down the Causeway holding my hand, in his white shirt and his black cap and his chappals, and he would make me look at the gills of the fish to see if they were red, and press the flesh with my thumb to see if it came back. He bargained badly. He always paid too much. The fish women adored him.
"Farokh," he said once, here, standing at the edge of the dock where the boats came in, "you have to learn one thing in this life, and it is to tell the difference between something that is alive and something that only looks alive."
I was nine. I thought he was talking about fish.
Later, much later, in London, in my flat in Harrow with the double glazing, I wondered if he had been talking about the bakery. If he already knew, in 1974, that he would send me away.
---
He sent me in September 1983. I was eighteen. I had finished my B.Com at Sydenham College and I was going to join the bakery, that was always understood. Dilu was twenty-one and had finished her own degree, home science, at a college in Marine Lines, and she was already in the bakery every morning, already better at the mawa cake than Mamma.
One evening in July, Pappa called me into the front room where he did the accounts. He had a letter on the desk from a cousin in London, Hormuz, Roshan-fui's husband's nephew, who had a small accountancy practice in Ealing.
"Hormuz will give you articles," said Pappa. "You will study for the English exams. You will live with him for one year, and then you will find your own place."
"I don't want to go to London."
"You are going."
"Why? Dilu is—Pappa, I want to work here."
My father looked at me for a long time with his heavy eyes. He had a pencil behind his ear, as always. He took it out and turned it over in his fingers.
"There is not enough here for two," he said. "One of you has to go. You are the one who is good with numbers. You are the one who hates the heat."
"Then why not Dilu? Dilu can go and get married somewhere. Girls go."
I am ashamed to write that down, but I said it. I was eighteen.
My father put the pencil back behind his ear.
"Dilnavaz stays," he said. "That is decided."
And that was all. I went to London in September in a brown suit Mamma had made by the Bohri tailor on the Causeway, which was too warm for Bombay and not warm enough for London, and I lived with Hormuz and his English wife Margaret in Ealing for a year, and I passed my exams, and I found a bedsit in Shepherd's Bush, and then a job at the insurance company, and then a flat in Harrow, and forty-three years went by the way a bus goes by when you are standing at the wrong stop.
I never married. People ask. There was a girl here, Freny, before I left, and we wrote letters for two years and then she married a dentist in Pune, and I don't think either of us was heartbroken, exactly. There was a woman in London, Celia, from the office, for six years, and then she wanted to live in Norfolk and I did not, and that was that. I was busy. I was careful. I was, if I am honest, waiting to be asked back.
Nobody asked. Not Pappa, not Mamma. Not Dilu.
---
I bought nothing at the dock. I did not know what to buy. I walked back up the Causeway as the sun came up behind the buildings, orange, already hot, and the shops started to open, and the man at the Regal circle sold me a Times of India, which costs five rupees now, and a cup of cutting chai from a kettle on a stove, ten rupees, in a small glass thick as a jam jar.
When I got back to the lane, the shutter of Pavri & Co. was halfway up and Kaizad was crawling under it with the float for the till. The smell came out under the shutter and down the lane to meet me. It is the smell of every morning of my childhood. Wood smoke and hot bread and burnt sugar and the particular sweetness of mawa when it hits the oven.
I went in. Benedict was taking out the first tray of mawa cakes, the little ones, baked in fluted tins, each with a single almond on top, the way they were always done. He put one on a saucer and handed it across without a word. I ate it standing by the oven, as I used to before school.
It was exactly the same.
That was the thing I could not bear. I had been gone forty-three years. I had lived a whole life somewhere else. My father was dead and my mother was dead and my hair had gone gray and I had a pension and a bad knee and a flat with double glazing. And the mawa cake was exactly the same. The same crumb, close and tender. The same edge, a little crisp from the tin. The same taste of milk that has been cooked for a very long time by someone patient, and cardamom, and a breath of nutmeg, and something underneath I have never been able to name.
"Benedict," I said. "What's in it?"
"Uncle, you know what's in it."
"There's something else. There always was."
Benedict looked at me, then at Dilu, who was at the counter with her back to us, counting change into the till, and pretending not to listen.
"Ask Dilnavaz-bai," he said.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Kaizad: The Tree
I am in serious trouble with forty-one people, and it is all because of a calendar.
Let me explain.
On Wednesday, at four o'clock tea, I brought Aunty Roshan a better question, as instructed. The question was: who exactly is in our family?
It sounds like a simple question. It is not a simple question if you are Parsi. There are only about fifty thousand of us left in the whole of India, and we are all related to each other, mostly twice, and every one of us has a great-aunt in Navsari or Surat or Karachi who knows exactly how, and none of us has ever written it down.
Aunty Roshan sent me to her flat with Mangala to fetch "the calendar."
The calendar turned out to be a 1987 calendar from the Bombay Dyeing company, the kind with a photograph of a model in a bedsheet for each month. On the back of each page, in pencil and then in blue ballpoint and then in green felt-tip, somebody had drawn a family tree. It started on the back of January with Behram Pavri and his wife Jerbai, and by the back of June it had gone through four generations and spread to Pune, Karachi, Calcutta, Aden, Toronto, Melbourne and a place in England called Slough, and by the back of December it had run out of paper and was continuing up the margins in tiny writing with arrows.
"Who drew this?"
"I did," said Aunty Roshan. "Over thirty years. Whenever somebody was born or married or died, I added them. Your mother is on September. You are not on it. You were born after I lost the felt-tip."
I spent Wednesday night and all of Thursday putting it into the family tree app. My mother set it up years ago, with the same login as the family folder, and it had about twelve people on it, mostly her side. By Thursday evening it had a hundred and sixty-three.
Then I made the mistake.
I shared the link in the family WhatsApp group.
---
The family WhatsApp group is called PAVRI PARIVAAR. It has forty-one members. It was created in 2017 for my Mamaiji's eightieth birthday and nobody has ever left it, because leaving a family WhatsApp group in our community is like faking your own death. You can do it but everybody will find out and you can never come to a wedding again.
Usually it is good-morning messages with roses on them, and forwarded videos about the health benefits of methi, and a man in Toronto called Zarir-uncle who sends a photograph of his lawn every Sunday.
On Thursday night I sent the link to the family tree with a message: Please check your branch and add anyone missing! Made from Roshan-fui's 1987 calendar.
By Friday morning there were two hundred and eleven new messages.
It turned out that Roshan-fui had made decisions. Thirty years of decisions, in pencil, about who was who. She had put a cousin's second husband on the tree and not her first. She had put one branch in Aden that the Pune branch said had never been in Aden, they had been in Mombasa, and the Mombasa branch, who were apparently on the group under a different surname, said they had been in Aden and Mombasa, and anyway the Pune branch had been in Nagpur until 1961 and had no business talking. Somebody in Melbourne pointed out that her grandmother had been spelled with one R on the tree and should be spelled with two. A man I had never heard of joined the group from Karachi.
His name was Behram too. Behram Pavri the second, eighty-four, grandson of Behram's younger brother Ardeshir, who had gone to Karachi in 1935 to open a branch and stayed after Partition. He wrote in very formal English with no punctuation.
Dear All I am Behram of Karachi I was told about this tree by my granddaughter I am very happy to see my grandfather's name and the name of the Bombay shop which I visited in 1958 as a boy and ate a cake there I am attaching a photograph
He attached a photograph.
It was a black-and-white photo of a shop front with a wooden board, and on the board was painted, in English and Gujarati, PAVRI & CO. BAKERS NAVSARI—BOMBAY—KARACHI.
Nobody in Bombay had ever seen it. Dilu-aunty did not know there had been a Karachi branch. Farokh-uncle did not know. Even Aunty Roshan, when I showed her the photo on my phone at four o'clock on Friday, put on her reading glasses under the insect sunglasses and stared at it for a long time.
"Ardeshir," she said finally. "The cheat."
"Why a cheat?"
"He took the recipe. The mawa cake. My father gave it to him to take to Karachi and he never paid the royalty. One anna a cake. My father wrote to him every Navroz for twelve years asking for the anna." She took off the reading glasses. "Is the shop still there?"
I asked the group. Behram of Karachi replied in four minutes.
No it closed in 1977 my father died and I was a banker I did not want to bake I am sorry
Aunty Roshan read it twice. Then she laughed, a big croaking laugh that made the Instagram girls at the case turn round.
"Sorry," she said. "He's sorry. Ninety years later. Write back, Kaizad. Tell him he owes us one anna a cake for forty-two years. Tell him we accept PayPal."
I did not write that. I wrote, Thank you, Behram-uncle, this is wonderful, and Aunty Roshan told me I had no backbone.
---
Then on Saturday it got worse, because someone in the group asked the question.
It was Zarir-uncle in Toronto. Between a photo of his lawn and a video about turmeric, he wrote:
So is it true the Colaba shop is being sold??
I don't know how he knew. Probably Mrs. Villoo. Mrs. Villoo is on the group because her late husband was somebody's cousin's brother-in-law, and she reads everything and replies to nothing.
The group exploded again. Two hundred and forty messages by lunch. Everyone had an opinion. The Pune branch said sell, property is property, think of Dilnavaz's retirement. The Melbourne branch said never sell, it's our heritage, what would Behram say. The Aden-or-Mombasa branch wanted to know how much. A cousin in Slough sent a long voice note in Gujarati that nobody could hear because there was a washing machine going behind her. Somebody posted a link to a newspaper article about a Parsi café in Fort that had closed. Somebody else posted a link to an article about one that had reopened as a cocktail bar, with a photo of a cocktail called The Bawaji.
And then my mother, who never posts anything except birthday wishes, wrote:
Has anybody asked Dilnavaz?
Silence. Four minutes of silence, which in PAVRI PARIVAAR is like a total eclipse.
Then Zarir-uncle posted a photo of his lawn.
---
I showed Dilu-aunty the messages at closing time, on Saturday, when she was wiping down the glass case and Farokh-uncle had gone out to buy a SIM card. I thought she'd be angry. She just scrolled. She scrolled for a long time with her thumb, holding the phone too far from her face, the way old people do.
Then she gave it back and said, "Who is Behram of Karachi?"
I showed her the photo of the shop front.
She held the phone close to her face for a while. Then her face did something I have never seen it do before, which was go soft, all at once, like dough when you stop kneading it.
"There was a Karachi branch," she said.
"There was."
"Did they use the same oven?"
"I don't know, Aunty."
"Ask him," she said. "Ask Behram of Karachi if the oven was brick, and how long it was, and whether the door had a horse's ear." She pushed the glass case's sliding door shut with a bang. "And don't tell your Farokh-uncle I asked."
I didn't. But I didn't have to. When I uploaded Behram of Karachi's photo to the family folder that night, with the caption, Pavri & Co. Karachi branch, about 1958, photo from Behram Pavri of Karachi, the first person to look at it, at 11:02 p.m., was Farokh-uncle, and the second, at 11:03, from a phone that until that night had never logged in to anything, was Dilu-aunty.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Dilnavaz: Navroz
Navroz falls on a Saturday this year, which is the worst possible day, because everybody is free, and everybody wants a mawa cake, and everybody wants it at nine in the morning.
For a Parsi bakery, the week before Navroz is like the week before Christmas for a turkey farmer, except that the turkey is me. Orders start coming in on the fifteenth of March. By the eighteenth there are eleven pages of them in the order book, in my handwriting and Kaizad's, and the order book smells of butter because everybody who writes in it has butter on their fingers.
Six kilos mawa cake, Mrs. Dalal, Cuffe Parade, delivery by ten.
Four kilos nankhatai, two kilos khari, Dr. and Mrs. Wadia, Malabar Hill, will collect, DON'T GIVE TO THE DRIVER, he eats them.
Twenty-four mawa cakes, the old-age home in Andheri, Farokh paying. (I don't know when he did that. I found it on page nine in his tiny handwriting.)
Two lagan nu custard, large tray, Cusrow Baug A block, for the Engineer family, who are having fifty people and have ordered custard for thirty, I know because I know the Engineers.
Benedict and Raju and Sanjay and I start at three in the morning on the Thursday before and do not stop until Saturday at noon. We sleep in turns. Benedict sleeps sitting up on a flour sack with his arms crossed, like a sentry. Raju and Sanjay sleep in the loft for ninety minutes at a time. I do not sleep, because I am sixty-four and I have stopped needing to, or because my knee wakes me up when I lie down, one or the other.
And my brother, who has never in his life worked a Navroz week, comes down at three on Thursday morning in his pajama pants and says, "Right. What do I do?"
---
What he does, it turns out, is the counter.
I would not have guessed it. I would have put money that Farokh would be useless at the counter. He is too polite, and too slow, and he will want to discuss things.
But he spent thirty-four years talking to people on the worst day of their lives. People whose warehouses have burned and whose boats have sunk. People who are shouting. He has a way of standing, with his hands flat on the glass, and leaning forward very slightly, and listening, that makes a shouting woman from Cuffe Parade stop shouting in the middle of a word.
"Aunty," he says, "I understand completely. You ordered six kilos and you've been given five. That is not acceptable. Let me look at the book."
He looks at the book. The book says five.
"Ah," he says. "You're right. The book says five, but I can see from your face you meant six. Benedict, could we possibly—"
And somehow Benedict could possibly, and somehow the woman from Cuffe Parade leaves with six kilos and the impression that she has won a war, and Farokh writes something in his little notebook, and I say, "You can't do that for everybody," and he says, "I won't do it for everybody. Only for the ones who'll tell their friends."
By Friday afternoon the queue goes out of the shop and down the lane to the Causeway. The chemist has put a chair outside for the old people waiting. The phone-cover man is selling bottled water at twice the price. Iqbal has given up on parking and is taking orders for delivery in his taxi, for a fee, which he did not discuss with me. Someone from a TV channel is there with a camera and a girl with a microphone, asking people what Navroz means to them, and a small boy in a white dagli and a velvet cap, who has come with his grandmother, looks straight into the camera and says, "Mawa cake," and the girl with the microphone laughs so much she has to start again.
The Instagram girls have come too, but they are not taking photos today. There is no room. They are standing in the queue like everybody else, pressed between an old Parsi gentleman in a coat and a Marathi fruit seller with his basket, holding their paper coffee cups in the air so they don't spill.
At four, Aunty Roshan arrives with Mangala and cannot get in. Farokh sees her over the heads and goes out, through the side, and brings her round the back through the alley, past the cat, and puts her in Mamma's chair at the back table, and makes her tea himself in the good cup.
"Too much sugar," she says.
"Yes, Roshan-fui."
"And you've boiled the milk only once."
"Yes, Roshan-fui."
"It's quite good," she says.
He comes back to the counter looking as if he has been given a medal.
---
On Navroz morning itself there is a lull at seven. There always is. The people who have ordered have collected, and the people who are coming to buy have not come yet, because they are at home in their new clothes doing whatever it is families do on Navroz morning, which in our house, when I was small, was Mamma drawing chalk patterns at the door, and Pappa putting on his best dagli, and the smell of ravo, semolina pudding cooked in milk with sugar and ghee and fried raisins, coming from the kitchen upstairs, and sev, the thin vermicelli cooked sweet and dry with nuts on top.
I have not made ravo since Mamma got too old to come down. I have not had the time.
At seven this Navroz, Farokh comes down the back stairs carrying a steel dish with a lid. He puts it on the back table in front of me and takes off the lid.
Ravo. Pale gold, glossy, with the raisins on top fried until they have puffed up like tiny balloons, and the almonds slivered, and a smell of cardamom and nutmeg that goes straight into the backs of my knees.
"I found Mamma's book," he says. "Upstairs. In the drawer with the bills. It's in Gujarati, which I can barely read anymore, so I phoned Roshan-fui last night at ten and she read it to me over the phone. She shouted the quantities."
"You made this."
"I made it three times. The first two were for the cat."
I take a spoon. It is too sweet, and there is not enough nutmeg, and the semolina has been roasted a little too long so there is a faint burnt edge underneath the sweetness.
It is my mother's ravo, almost exactly. It is the best thing I have eaten in five weeks.
"Sal Mubarak, Dilu," says my brother.
"Sal Mubarak," I say. And I eat the whole dish, standing up, at seven in the morning, in front of Benedict and Raju and Sanjay and the cat, and nobody says a word.
---
The second rush comes at nine-thirty and goes on until two. By two there is nothing left in the case but crumbs and one nankhatai that broke in half. We pull the shutter down to waist height, which on the lane means: closed, unless you are family or you are very persuasive.
I go into the back to get the broom.
I do not remember falling. I remember my right knee making a sound like a wet branch, and then the floor of the bakery, close to my face, and the smell of the floor, which is flour and old wood and the cat. And then Benedict's face, upside down, very close, saying my name in a voice I have never heard him use, and behind him Farokh, white as a sheet of maida, with a phone in his hand saying, "Ambulance, what's the number for an ambulance, what's the number in this country?"
"One-oh-eight," says Raju.
"Don't," I say from the floor. "Don't call. It's Navroz. They'll be busy. Get Iqbal."
"Dilu—"
"Get Iqbal," I say, and then the pain arrives, all of it at once, like the queue at nine-thirty, and I stop being able to give instructions.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Farokh: The Oven Has Moods
The orthopedic surgeon at the Parsi General Hospital on Bomanji Petit Road is a woman called Dr. Shireen Gandhi, no relation, she says before anyone can ask, and she has small hands and a very large voice and looked at the X-ray of my sister's knee the way I used to look at the photographs of a burned warehouse.
"How long has she been walking on this?"
"I don't know," I said. "I live in London."
Dr. Gandhi looked at me as if living in London were a symptom.
"Five years," she said. "At least. Probably more. There's no cartilage left. It's bone on bone. She has been standing on concrete twelve hours a day on a knee that should have been replaced in 2021. She must be in pain every minute."
"She never said."
"They never say," said Dr. Gandhi. "Your community especially. Parsi women would rather die than mention a knee. I'm one. I know."
She explained what happens now. A total knee replacement. A titanium and plastic joint. The operation is common; it is done thousands of times a day all over the world; the risks are small but they are not nothing. After the operation, four days in hospital, and then six weeks of physiotherapy, walking with a frame, then a stick. No standing for long periods for three months.
"Three months," I said.
"At least. Who will run the bakery?"
I didn't answer, because I didn't know, and because Dilu was in the next bed behind a green curtain, awake, and could hear everything.
"Nobody," said Dilu through the curtain. "Nobody will run the bakery. I'll run it sitting down."
"You'll run it sitting down," said Dr. Gandhi, "over my dead body, Dilnavaz-ben."
---
They did the operation on the Wednesday after Navroz. I sat in the corridor for three hours on a plastic chair under a ceiling fan that ticked on every rotation, next to a family from Dahanu whose grandfather was having his hip done, and they shared their dhebra with me, flatbreads made with millet and fenugreek, out of a steel tiffin, and the grandmother told me in Gujarati that I looked like I needed feeding, which is the first thing Gujarati grandmothers tell everybody.
Kaizad came at noon with Aunty Roshan, who sat in the corridor in her insect sunglasses and gave orders to the nurses. Benedict came at one, still in his apron, with a box of mawa cakes for the nurses, and stood at the end of the corridor without coming nearer, turning his cap round in his hands.
At two-fifteen Dr. Gandhi came out in green scrubs and said it had gone well, very well, and the joint was in, and Dilu was in recovery and swearing at the anesthetist.
Benedict put the cap back on his head and went back to the bakery without a word, because the afternoon pav was due at four.
---
That was three weeks ago. I have run the bakery since then.
I want to be accurate. Benedict has run the bakery. Raju and Sanjay have run the bakery. Kaizad has run the counter in the mornings, before college, and after college, and sometimes instead of college, and I have not told his mother. I have stood in the middle of it all with a notebook, getting in everybody's way, and learning, very fast, all the things I did not learn at eighteen.
I have learned that the oven has moods.
It is not a figure of speech. Benedict has been telling me this for three weeks, and I thought he was being romantic, the way Goans are about anything that involves fire or the sea. He is not being romantic. The oven is a brick dome ninety-five years old and it does not heat evenly, and how it heats depends on the weather, and the humidity, and which wood came on the last truck from Vasai, and whether the wind is coming off the sea or off the land, and whether the firebox was cleaned out properly the night before.
On a dry morning with the wind from the land, it is hot at the back and cool at the front left, and you put the pav at the back and the khari at the front and the mawa cakes in the middle on the right.
On a damp morning, which in March is rare but happens, it is sullen and slow everywhere, and you must feed it for an extra forty minutes, and the khari will not rise properly whatever you do.
On a morning like the second Monday after Navroz, when the wind changed at five-thirty, it is hot at the front right, very suddenly, for no reason anybody can explain, and if you do not notice, and I did not notice, you will put forty-eight mawa cakes in that corner and take out forty-eight small black discs that smell like a car fire.
"Uncle," said Benedict, looking at the tray.
"I know."
"The front right."
"I know, Benedict."
The cat, from its warm patch, looked at the tray and left the room.
---
I have learned that the khari is folded seven times. Not six. Not eight. Seven, with the butter cold and the dough cold and Benedict's hands cold, which is why Benedict washes his hands in iced water from the steel matka before he starts, and why the khari is made at three in the morning, before the room gets hot. If you fold it six times it is bread. If you fold it eight it is cardboard. Behram Pavri decided on seven in 1931, and nobody has ever argued with him, and I am not going to start.
I have learned that the pav-bhaji men at the Gateway want their pav slightly underbaked, so that it can be toasted on the tawa with butter without burning, and that the hostel at Navy Nagar wants theirs well baked, because the cadets keep it in their lockers. I have learned that the vada pav man at the bus depot does not pay on Saturdays. He pays on Tuesdays, when his brother-in-law pays him, and Dilu has always known this, and has written "Saturday" in the book for eleven years so as not to embarrass him.
I have learned that Mrs. Villoo Contractor on the second floor, who has signed Mr. Gala's papers and wants a lift, comes down at seven-thirty every morning in a housecoat and buys one plain bun, and that Dilu has never once charged her for it, since her husband died in 2016, and has never once told her she was not charging her. Mrs. Villoo thinks she has an account. She does not have an account. I looked.
I have learned that I like this. That is the worst thing I have learned.
I like the dark at four-thirty and the cold water from the matka and the slap of the dough on the trough. I like the first peel going in. I like the shutter going up at seven with that long rattling roar and the lane looking in. I like Iqbal's two khari and one mawa and his complaints. I like the cat. I am a sixty-one-year-old retired claims assessor with a flat in Harrow and I like the cat.
I did not come here to like anything. I came here to look at options.
---
I went to see Dilu every evening at six, first in the hospital and then, after the fourth day, at home, in Mamma's old room upstairs, where Kaizad and Raju carried her up the stairs in a plastic chair like a maharani, with her shouting directions at them the whole way.
She lies in Mamma's bed with her new knee straight out in front of her under the sheet, and a frame next to the bed that she refuses to use, and her ledger on her lap.
"How was the takings?"
"Thirty-one."
"Thirty-one! On a Tuesday?"
"The khari came out well."
She looked at me suspiciously. "Who made the khari?"
"Benedict."
"Who folded it?"
I didn't answer. She narrowed her eyes.
"How many times?"
"Seven, Dilu," I said. "Seven. I'm not a barbarian."
And my sister, who has not laughed at a single one of my jokes since 1983, put her head back against Mamma's pillow and laughed until she had to hold her new knee with both hands.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Kaizad: The Night of the Explosion
On the fourteenth of April, which was a Tuesday, Aunty Roshan didn't come for four o'clock tea.
She sent Mangala instead, with a message that she would see me at her flat at six, and that I should bring the recording thing, and that I should not bring Farokh, and that I should not tell Dilnavaz.
I went at six. Aunty Roshan's flat is on the first floor of her building in Cusrow Baug, with tall windows and green shutters and a ceiling so high you could put another flat inside it. It's full of furniture that's too big for it: a carved blackwood sofa, a dining table for twelve where she eats alone, a glass cabinet with china in it nobody has used since 1970, and on every wall, photographs. Weddings. Navjotes. Men in black caps and women in saris with borders, standing very straight in front of painted backdrops of palm trees.
The parrot said "Chup!" when I came in. Nobody had phoned. It just felt like saying it.
Aunty Roshan was in an armchair by the window with a shawl over her knees, though it was thirty-three degrees.
"Sit," she said. "Press the thing."
I pressed the thing.
"Do you know what today is?"
"Tuesday, Aunty."
"It's the fourteenth of April. On the fourteenth of April, 1944, I was seven years old. And the docks blew up."
---
I knew about the explosion. Everybody in Bombay knows a little bit. There's a memorial at the fire brigade headquarters in Byculla, and every year on the fourteenth the firemen have a parade, and it's in the newspaper for one day. A ship full of cotton and ammunition caught fire in the Victoria Dock during the war and exploded, twice, and hundreds of people died, and gold bars from the ship's cargo rained down on the city.
That's what I knew. That's what everybody knows. The gold bars.
Aunty Roshan didn't talk about the gold bars.
She talked for an hour and twelve minutes. I'm going to write some of it down here, though it's all in the recording, because I want to remember how she said it, not just what.
"It was afternoon, about four. I was at the back table, in my mother's chair, doing sums on a slate. My father was at the oven. The first explosion we did not hear so much as feel. The floor jumped. The bottles on the shelf jumped. My father dropped a tray. Then we heard it. Like the whole sky had been torn. And then, maybe half an hour later, the second one, bigger, and the window at the front, the big glass window with PAVRI & CO. painted on it in gold, came in. Into the shop. All of it, in a thousand pieces, across the counter and the cakes.
"My mother pulled me under the table. We stayed there. I don't know how long. People were running in the lane. Shouting. The sky went black to the north. Black smoke, and then the sun was red through it, like a coin.
"My father went out. My mother said, Behram, don't go, and he went. He was gone until midnight. When he came back his white shirt was gray and his eyebrows were gone, burnt off, and he did not speak. He sat at the back table and my mother gave him tea and he did not drink it.
"Then at one in the morning he got up and he lit the oven.
"My mother said, Behram, what are you doing? And he said, There are people at the dock. Thousands. Firemen, sailors, coolies, the dock people, the families looking for the people who are missing. Nobody has eaten. The fires will burn for days. They need bread.
"And he baked. All night. My mother kneaded. I sat on a flour sack and watched. He baked pav, plain pav, as fast as the oven would take it, and at five in the morning he put it in sacks and loaded it on a handcart, and he and the boy who worked for us then, Ganpat, pushed it all the way up to the docks. Three miles. Through the glass and the smoke and the soldiers who tried to stop them. And he gave it away.
"He did that for nine days. Nine days, Kaizad. Day and night. He used all the flour we had and then he borrowed flour from the Irani in Bhendi Bazaar and then he bought flour on credit from a man who charged him twice the price, because it was wartime and everybody was a thief. He nearly lost the shop. It took him six years to pay off the debt. My mother never forgave him for the flour man. She forgave him for everything else."
She stopped there. She looked out of the window, at the garden of Cusrow Baug, where some boys were playing cricket in the dusk with a tennis ball wrapped in electrical tape.
"Why didn't anyone ever tell me this?" I said.
"Because nobody asked." She turned back to me. "Your generation thinks we old people are sitting on stories like hens on eggs, waiting for someone to come and collect them. We are not. We are just sitting. If you don't ask, we die and that's the end of it."
---
Then she said the other thing. The thing she had told me not to bring Farokh-uncle for.
"Now. I'll tell you something else, and then you will decide what to do with it, because I am eighty-nine and I am tired of deciding things."
I waited.
"In 1983," she said, "my brother Jehangir did not send Farokh to London because Farokh was good with numbers. Farokh thinks that. Farokh has thought that for forty-three years and it has made him sad and it has made him polite. He was sent because Dilnavaz asked."
I didn't say anything. I couldn't.
"She came to me first. Here, to this flat, in June 1983. She was twenty-one. She sat where you're sitting. She said, Fui, there is only enough for one of us. Pappa will give it to Farokh because he is the boy. But Farokh doesn't love it. He loves it because it's home, not because it's the oven. And I love the oven. If Farokh stays, he'll be unhappy all his life and I'll get married off to some engineer in Pune and I'll be unhappy all my life. If he goes, one of us is happy. Maybe both.
"She asked me to talk to Jehangir. So I talked to Jehangir. He shouted at me. Then he thought about it for a month. Then he wrote to Hormuz in London."
Aunty Roshan pulled the shawl up over her knees.
"She has felt guilty for forty-three years. And he has felt sent away for forty-three years. And neither of them has ever said a word about it to the other one, because they are Pavris, and Pavris would rather bake for nine days than have one conversation."
"Why are you telling me?"
"Because you have that thing." She pointed at my phone. "And because they're going to sell the shop over it. They don't know that's what they're doing. But that's what they're doing."
I looked at the phone. The recording was still going. 1:12:36. 1:12:37.
"Do I put this part in the family folder?" I said.
Aunty Roshan put her sunglasses on, though it was nearly dark.
"That," she said, "is what I'm too tired to decide."
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Dilnavaz: Bone on Bone
A titanium knee is a strange thing to own. It is colder than the rest of you. In the mornings it is stiff, and then it warms, and then it is better than the old one, so much better that I stand at the top of the stairs and bend it and straighten it and feel like a girl, and then I go down three steps and it reminds me that it is new and I am not.
I have been upstairs for five weeks. Five weeks in Mamma's room, in Mamma's bed, with a physiotherapist called Sachin who comes at ten every morning and makes me lift my leg off the bed eleven times, and walk to the window and back with the frame, and then to the bathroom and back, and who says "Very good, Aunty, very good" in the voice people use for dogs.
From Mamma's window I can see the lane. I can see the mouth of the lane where Iqbal parks and the chemist shouts. I can see the shutter go up at seven. I can see the queue on Saturdays. I cannot see inside the shop, but I can hear it, through the floor, the way Farokh used to feel the oven through the floor of his room. I can hear the peel scraping. I can hear Benedict singing to the dough. I can hear my brother's voice at the counter, saying "Good morning" in his London way, as if the customers had arrived for a meeting.
He is good at it. That is what I cannot bear. He is good at it, and I am lying upstairs with a titanium knee, listening.
---
On Thursday evening he did not come at six. He came at eight-thirty, with Kaizad behind him, and Kaizad's face was the face of a boy who has done something and is waiting to find out what it was.
"What," I said.
Farokh pulled Mamma's dressing-table stool to the bed and sat on it. It was too low for him, and his knees came up nearly to his chin, and for a moment he looked exactly like he looked at nine, sitting on the landing with an Enid Blyton.
"Kaizad has a recording," he said. "Of Roshan-fui. From the fourteenth. About the dock explosion, and about Behram. I listened to it this afternoon, all of it. You should listen to it too. It's in the family folder. But there's a part he didn't put in the folder. He played it to me in the store room. He says Roshan-fui left it up to him."
I looked at Kaizad. He looked at the floor.
"I'm sorry, Aunty," he said.
"Play it," I said.
---
I won't write down what Roshan-fui said. It is in the phone. I listened to it once, and I will not listen to it again, because I was there, in 1983, in Roshan-fui's flat with the high ceiling, sitting in the chair where Kaizad sat, and I know every word, and I know that it is true.
When it finished, nobody said anything. Kaizad put his phone in his pocket. Somewhere in the lane a motorbike went past with its horn playing a tune. Mrs. Villoo's television was on, upstairs, a Gujarati serial with a lot of crashing music.
"Kaizad," said my brother. "Would you go down and help Benedict close?"
Kaizad went. He shut the door very carefully, the way you shut a door on someone sleeping.
Farokh sat on the low stool with his knees up by his chin.
"You asked him," he said.
"Yes."
"You asked Pappa to send me to London."
"Yes."
"Why didn't you ever tell me?"
I looked at the ceiling. There is a damp stain on Mamma's ceiling in the shape of Africa, more or less. It has been there since the monsoon of 2005, the year the whole city flooded, when the water came up the lane to the second step.
"Because you'd have stayed," I said. "If I'd told you, you'd have stayed out of spite. Or out of kindness. With you it's the same thing. And then you'd have been in the bakery all your life, hating the heat, being polite to the flour, and I'd have been in some engineer's flat in Pune making his mother's dhansak, and we'd both have been miserable, and it would have been my fault. This way it was only half my fault."
"Half."
"Pappa decided. I only asked."
"Dilu," said my brother. "I've spent forty-three years thinking Pappa didn't want me."
"I know."
"You knew?"
"Mamma told me. After the first year. She said you wrote letters as if you were in prison. She said, Dilnavaz, what have you done. I said, I've given him a chance. She said, You've given him a life sentence. She never forgave me. Not completely. She was very polite about it."
He laughed. It was not a laugh exactly. He took off his glasses and pressed the heels of his hands into his eyes.
"And London," I said. "Was it a life sentence?"
He was quiet for a long time.
"No," he said finally. "No. It was fine. It was a life. I had a good job. I was good at it. I went to the Lake District. I had a friend called Celia for six years. I have a pension and an allotment where I grow beans that the slugs eat. It was a life." He put his glasses back on. "But I was always waiting to come back. And nobody asked me."
"I couldn't ask you," I said. "I sent you away. How can you send someone away and then ask them back? You can't do both."
"Mamma could have asked."
"Mamma was waiting for you to ask yourself. She told me so. She said, he'll come back when he wants to, and he won't want to until there's nothing to come back to, because that is what Jehangir's people are like. They only arrive for funerals." I looked at him. "She was right. You came for a funeral."
My brother sat with that for a while.
"And now," he said, "there's a man with a Fortuner who wants to give us six crore so we can have nothing to come back to at all."
"Yes."
"And I've been telling you to take it."
"Yes."
"For your sake. I thought. Your knee. Your retirement. I had it all in a spreadsheet." He laughed again, properly this time. "Dilu, I am such an idiot."
"You're an Englishman," I said. "It's not your fault."
He stood up from the low stool, with difficulty, in three parts, like a camel. Then he leaned over the bed and kissed me on the forehead, which he has not done since we were children, and which I did not stop him doing.
"Tomorrow," he said, "I'm going to look properly at Mr. Gala."
"What does that mean?"
"It means," said my brother, "that I was the man on the eleventh floor who found out what really happened. And I haven't done my job."
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Farokh: What Really Happened
There is a website run by the Maharashtra Real Estate Regulatory Authority where every building project in the state must be registered, with its promoter, its approvals, its promised date of completion and every quarterly update the developer is obliged to file. It is not a beautiful website. It looks as if it was designed in 2009 by someone who disliked people. But it is public, and it is searchable, and a man who spent thirty-four years reading the fine print of other people's disasters can sit at a back table in a bakery with a laptop balanced on a sack of sugar and read it for three days straight.
Which is what I did.
Hitesh Gala's company is called Galaxy Habitat Private Limited. It has an office in Lower Parel with a glass door and a receptionist with a headset, which I know because I went there on Monday in a taxi with Iqbal and sat in the lobby for forty minutes reading a brochure, and nobody asked who I was, because I was wearing my London raincoat and looked like a man from a bank.
The brochure showed six completed projects, all in the suburbs, all with swimming pools on the roof and young couples laughing on balconies with their arms around each other.
The MahaRERA website showed eleven.
Of the five that were not in the brochure, three were redevelopments of old tenanted buildings in the island city. Girgaon. Byculla. Dadar. One was registered in 2016 with a completion date of December 2019. It has filed quarterly updates every three months since then. The most recent says: Plinth work in progress. Revised completion date: December 2028.
I went to Girgaon. I found the site. It is a plot behind a corrugated tin fence painted with pictures of a tower that does not exist, and inside the fence there is a hole, and a rusty crane that has not moved in some time, and a watchman asleep on a charpoy under a blue tarpaulin. I found the tea stall across the road. The man at the tea stall knew all about it. The tenants of the old building, he said, were moved out in 2017. They were promised rent allowance of twenty-two thousand a month until the new flats were ready. The allowance was paid for two years. Then it was paid late. Then it was paid in half. Then, since the pandemic, mostly not at all.
"Where are they now, the tenants?"
He shrugged and poured my tea from a height.
"Virar. Nalasopara. Kalyan. Wherever the rent is less. Some have died. One old man still comes every Sunday and stands at the fence."
---
I went back to the bakery and I did what I have done ten thousand times on Fenchurch Street. I made a file. I printed every quarterly update for all three stalled projects at the cyber café on the Causeway, two rupees a page, and put them in order in a plastic folder. I wrote a summary, one page, in plain English and then, with Kaizad's help, in plain Gujarati, and then, with Raju's help and a man at the cyber café, in Marathi. I put the summary on top.
I did not put in any adjectives. On the eleventh floor we were taught never to use adjectives. You put down what happened, with dates, and you let the reader be angry on their own.
Then I asked Mrs. Villoo Contractor if I could come up and see her.
---
Mrs. Villoo is eighty-two and lives alone on the second floor in a flat full of plants. There are plants on every windowsill, on the floor, on the dining table, in old Dalda tins and paint buckets and a chamber pot. The flat is cool and green and smells like a greenhouse. She gave me tea in a glass and a Marie biscuit on a saucer and sat across from me in a cane chair with her feet, in socks, on a stool.
"You've come about the lift," she said.
"I've come about Mr. Gala."
"Same thing."
I gave her the folder. She put on her glasses and read the summary. Then she read the Girgaon updates, every one, holding each page up to the window light. It took twenty minutes. I ate the Marie biscuit and looked at the plants.
When she finished, she took her glasses off and looked at me.
"Your sister should have shown me this."
"My sister didn't know. I didn't know. I only looked last week."
"Hm." She put the folder on her lap. "You know why I signed?"
"For the lift."
"For the stairs. Two flights. Thirty-eight steps. I counted. Since Kersi died, I go down once a day, for my bun, and come up once, and it takes me ten minutes and I have to stop on the landing and hold the wall. And I think, one day I will fall on these stairs, and nobody will find me until Dilnavaz notices I haven't come for my bun." She looked out of the window. "That Gala boy came up here and sat where you're sitting and said, Aunty, in three years you'll have a lift, and a new kitchen, and a window that doesn't stick. And I thought, three years. I can manage three years."
"In Girgaon it's been nine."
"I can read, Farokh."
We sat for a while. A crow landed on the windowsill, looked at us, and left.
"What will you do?" she said.
"There's a meeting of the tenants on Saturday. On the stairs. I'm going to give everyone this folder."
"And then?"
"And then I don't know."
Mrs. Villoo looked at me over her glasses.
"Your mother," she said, "used to give me a free bun every morning. Since Kersi died. She thought I didn't know. I knew. I let her, because she wanted to. And then your sister did the same, and I let her too, because she wanted to. Now you." She put the folder on the table. "I'm not a fool, Farokh. I'm only old."
---
The tenants' meeting was on Saturday afternoon on the first-floor landing, because that is where the building's meetings have always been, since nobody's flat is big enough and the landing has a window. There are fourteen residential tenants in our building. Eleven came. The chemist and the tailor came. The phone-cover man sent his son, who stood at the back looking at his phone.
I gave everyone the folder. I gave Mrs. Villoo's copy to her last, and she held it up and said, "I've read it. It's true. I'm withdrawing my consent," before I had opened my mouth, which was not the order I had planned but was better.
There was an argument, of course. It was a Bombay building meeting. There was shouting about the drains, which had nothing to do with anything, and an old quarrel between the second floor and the third about a water tank, and the tailor, who is a very quiet man named Mr. Shaikh, stood up and said that his grandfather had sewn the uniforms for the Navy band from this shop since 1948 and that he would rather the building fell on his head than move to a container in Wadala for nine years, and sat down, and everyone clapped.
By the end, five tenants had said they would write to the trust and withdraw consent before the development agreement was registered. Mr. Gala needed fifty-one percent. He had had sixty-one. If the five did what they said, he had forty-seven.
"He'll come back," said the chemist to me afterwards, on the stairs. "They always come back. With more money."
"Then we'll read his next folder," I said.
---
My sister was waiting for me at the top of the stairs. She had come down from Mamma's room for the first time without the frame, holding the banister, with Kaizad one step below her in case she fell. She had heard the whole thing through the floor.
"Forty-seven," she said.
"If they write the letters."
"They'll write. Mr. Shaikh will make them." She looked at me. "And the oven?"
"Is still going to cost fourteen lakh."
"Eleven of which," said Dilu, "is in an account that belongs to a man who sends money every Navroz and doesn't ask what happens to it."
"And three of which," I said, "is going to come from a flat in Harrow with double glazing, which I am going to put on the market on Monday."
My sister stood very still on the stairs.
"Farokh."
"I've been thinking about it since the ravo," I said. "Possibly since the mawa cake. Possibly since the floor got warm on the first night. The estate agent says it'll sell in a month. First-time buyers. Near the Metropolitan line."
"Where will you live?"
"There's a room above a bakery," I said, "where the floor gets warm at five. I'm told it's rent-controlled."
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Kaizad: Khamir
The new oven came on a Tuesday in July, in the middle of the monsoon, on a truck that could not get into the lane, so it was unloaded on the Causeway in the rain by six men and a crowbar while traffic went round them honking and Iqbal directed everything from under a black umbrella as if he had been hired to.
It is an electric deck oven, three decks, stainless steel, from a company in Pune. It has a digital panel with buttons and a screen that shows the temperature of each deck, and a steam injector for the pav, and a timer that beeps. It is very clean and very ugly and it cost thirteen lakh eighty thousand rupees plus GST, plus the load sanction from the electricity company, which took eleven visits by Farokh-uncle to an office in Colaba where he sat on a bench in his raincoat until a clerk took pity on him.
It does not have moods. Benedict hates it.
"It has no feeling," he says. "It does what you tell it."
"Isn't that good?" I said.
"For a machine," said Benedict. "Not for an oven."
But he has learned it. He has learned it in three weeks, the way he learned the old one in thirty-nine years, by standing in front of it at five in the morning and paying attention. He says the pav comes out too even. He says the khari is better than ever, because the heat is steady and the layers rise straight. He won't admit the mawa cakes are the same. They are the same. I have tested this personally, many times.
---
The old oven we did not take out. You can't. It is part of the building. The brick dome goes into the back wall and under the floor of Farokh-uncle's room, and to take it out you would have to take down half the building, which is what Mr. Gala wanted to do, and which, for now, nobody is doing. The repair board came in June and put steel props under the third floor and new plaster on the stairwell and a notice on the door saying the structure has been certified safe for a further period, which Mrs. Villoo photographed and sent to the family WhatsApp group.
So the old oven stays where it is, cold, with its iron door shut and its horse's-ear handle polished, and the new oven stands next to it like a young man standing next to his grandfather at a wedding, looking slightly embarrassed.
But before it went cold, we lit it one last time.
That was the night before the new oven came. Benedict asked for it. He said, "Dilnavaz-bai, one more batch. Only pav. For the lane." And Dilu-aunty, who was down in the shop by then, walking with a stick with a silver top that Aunty Roshan had given her and that used to belong to Behram, said yes before he had finished asking.
So at four in the morning on the last Monday in July, in the rain, Benedict lit the firebox with the last of the casuarina from Vasai, and fed it, slowly, one spoon at a time, for an hour and a half, while we all sat on flour crates and watched. Dilu-aunty. Farokh-uncle. Raju and Sanjay. Me. The cat. And at five-thirty, without anyone asking her, Aunty Roshan, who had made Mangala bring her in a taxi in her nightdress and a raincoat and the insect sunglasses, in the dark, in the rain.
"I was here for the first one," she said, sitting down in her chair. "I'll be here for the last one."
"You weren't here for the first one, Fui. You weren't born."
"I was here in spirit," said Aunty Roshan. "Hand me a cup."
Benedict made the pav the way Behram made it, the way he had made it every morning for thirty-nine years. The dough in the wooden trough. The rounds in rows on the black trays, touching, so that in the heat they grow together and come out as one loaf you pull apart by hand. The peel. The iron door with the horse's ear. The dark.
When the first tray came out, the smell went up through the floor into every flat in the building, and lights came on, one after another, all the way up. Mrs. Villoo came down in her housecoat. Mr. Shaikh the tailor came down. The chemist, who lives in Chembur and should not have been there at all, arrived at six, soaked, saying he'd heard from Iqbal.
We gave the pav away. All of it. Forty dozen, to anybody who came down the lane. The pav-bhaji men from the Gateway came with their crates. The vada pav man came from the bus depot. The cadets came from Navy Nagar in their raincoats, running, because someone at the hostel had heard. Iqbal took a sack to the taxi stand at the Regal circle and handed it out through the window of his Santro.
I photographed everything. The fire. Benedict's hands on the peel. Aunty Roshan in the chair with a pav in each hand. Dilu-aunty with her stick at the oven door. Farokh-uncle with flour on his glasses. And the last tray, coming out at seven-ten, and the iron door shutting behind it.
That night I put the photographs in the family archive with captions. Last firing of the Behram Pavri oven, built 1931. Colaba Lane. Benedict Fernandes at the peel. And under the one of Aunty Roshan: Roshan Pavri, 89, who was here in spirit for the first one.
Behram of Karachi replied within the hour, in the group.
Our oven in Karachi was brick also forty feet no only twenty feet but the door had a horse's ear I remember it I am very glad to see this
Aunty Roshan, when I showed her, said, "Twenty feet. Typical Ardeshir. Always half of everything."
---
The family app my mother uses has a word of the day. It's a small thing. Every morning it shows a word from the family's language, Gujarati in our case, with a little speaker you can tap to hear it said, and a sentence. Mostly it's words like "rotli" and "pani" that everybody knows. My mother likes it. She says it's for my generation, who can't count past ten in Gujarati.
The morning after the last firing, the word was khamir.
It means leaven. Yeast, the thing that makes bread rise. It comes from Persian, the app said, the same as half the Parsi Gujarati words, from when our people came from Iran to Gujarat more than a thousand years ago and kept their old words in their pockets.
The sentence was: Without khamir, the dough stays flat.
I sent a screenshot to Farokh-uncle. He was in the room above my head, in his bed where the floor no longer gets warm at five, because the new oven is against the other wall and doesn't leak heat through the boards.
He replied: Ha.
Then a minute later: Tell Dilu.
Then: Actually, don't. She'll say it's obvious.
---
Here is what nobody asked me, all this time, and what I'm going to say anyway, because it's my chapter.
I want to run the bakery.
Not now. Not instead of Dilu-aunty, who is back at the counter five days a week, sitting on a tall stool with her stick hooked over the edge of the glass case, as much in charge as ever. Not instead of Farokh-uncle, who does the accounts now, and the suppliers, and the electricity company, and has made a spreadsheet so beautiful that the chartered accountant in Fort asked if he could have a copy.
But after. When they're older. When Benedict retires, which he says will be never, and when Aunty Roshan stops coming at four, which she says will be never as well.
I told Farokh-uncle first, because he's easier. It was at the back table, at nine, doing the books. I said it very fast, the way you jump into cold water.
He didn't look up from the spreadsheet.
"I know," he said. "Dilu knows too. We discussed it on Thursday. You'll finish your degree. You'll do two years somewhere else first, a hotel or a big bakery, a proper one with an HR department. You'll hate it. Then you'll come back. We'll make you a partner. Ten percent. Rising."
"You discussed it."
"For about four minutes. Dilu wanted to give you twenty. I'm an insurance man. I said ten."
"Rising."
"Rising," said Farokh-uncle. "Now go and open the shutter. Iqbal's waiting and he's blocking the chemist again."
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
Dilnavaz: Ninety
Roshan-fui turns ninety on the eleventh of October, which is a Sunday, and she has told everyone in the family she does not want a fuss, which in our family means she wants a very large fuss, organized by someone else, that she can complain about.
So we are having it at the bakery.
Kaizad has done the invitations, on the family WhatsApp group and on the family tree app, which sends a little reminder to everyone on the tree who is still alive. Two hundred and nine people are on the tree now. Behram of Karachi is on it, with his granddaughter, who is a dentist and is coming with him, if the visas come through, which with Pakistan is a big if. Zarir-uncle is coming from Toronto, and has promised not to bring photographs of his lawn. The Aden-or-Mombasa branch is coming from Nairobi and has stopped arguing about which. The cousin in Slough is coming without her washing machine.
They will not all fit in the bakery. They will not all fit in the lane. We have asked Mr. Shaikh if we can use the front of his shop, and the chemist if we can use the front of his, and Iqbal is going to keep the mouth of the lane clear with his taxi, which is the first time in history he has been asked to block something on purpose.
The cake is mine.
---
I have been making it for three days. I do it at the old back table, sitting down, which Dr. Gandhi allows, as long as I stand up and walk to the door and back every forty minutes. Sachin the physiotherapist set an alarm on my phone. When it rings I get up and walk to the door, and look out at the lane, and walk back, and sit down. It is very annoying. I have walked to the door perhaps two hundred times in three months. I know every crack in the floor between the back table and the door. There are fourteen.
The cake is a mawa cake. Not the little ones in the fluted tins. A big one, a tier, the way we make them for weddings, round, with marzipan roses on top and Roshan-fui's name in pink, and a ninety in silver balls, because she is ninety and she will want to count them.
I have made the mawa cake perhaps a hundred thousand times. I do not need a recipe. But this week I wrote one down, for the first time, in the ledger, at the back, on the empty pages after December.
Kaizad's is the hand that will need it. And my brother asked, in March, what was in it. I never told him. I said ask Benedict, and Benedict said ask me.
So I wrote it all. The mawa from Bhuleshwar, and how to tell when it is fresh, which is by the smell, like milk that has been in the sun. The butter, Mr. Agarwal's, soft but not oily. Sugar, caster, the fine one, never the coarse. Eggs, at room temperature, which in Bombay is not a problem. Flour, sifted twice. Cardamom, ground in the stone mortar that was Jerbai's, never in the mixer. Nutmeg, grated on the small side of the grater, just before.
And then the other thing. The thing underneath that my brother could never name.
A spoon of rose water and a spoon of the khamir from the pav dough. Just a spoon. A little sourness, a little life from the oven, from the bread that has fed the lane every morning since 1931, folded into the cake for the rich people. Behram did it because the Irani in Bhendi Bazaar did it, and the Irani did it because somebody in Yazd did it, and nobody knows why except that the cake is better.
I wrote that down. Then underneath, in smaller letters, I wrote: This is the Irani's recipe, not Behram's. Don't tell anybody. And I wrote my name and the date.
---
At four o'clock on the eleventh of October, Roshan-fui arrives at Colaba Lane in Iqbal's taxi, which has been washed for the occasion and has a garland of marigolds on the bonnet.
She is wearing a gara sari, black, with pink and white flowers embroidered on it in silk, the one she wore at her own wedding in 1959, which still fits her, she says, because she has always been careful, by which she means she has always been thin. She is wearing her insect sunglasses and her white canvas shoes and she is holding Behram's stick, which she gave to me in July and has borrowed back for the day.
The lane is full. There are people from Nairobi and Toronto and Pune and Navsari. There are people from the building, Mrs. Villoo in her best housecoat, Mr. Shaikh in a waistcoat he has sewn himself. There are the pav-bhaji men from the Gateway and the vada pav man from the bus depot, who has paid his account in full, on a Saturday, for the first time in eleven years, as a birthday present. There are the Instagram girls, who have been told no photographs and are obeying, mostly. There is Behram of Karachi, eighty-four, whose visa came through on Thursday, standing in the doorway of the bakery with his granddaughter, looking at the old oven with tears running down his face, saying, "Twenty feet. It's forty. It's forty feet. Ours was half."
And there is my brother, in a white shirt and a black cap, our father's cap, which he found in a trunk in Mamma's room, standing behind the counter with flour on his glasses, saying to everyone who comes in, "Good afternoon, welcome, sorry about the queue."
Roshan-fui sits in Mamma's chair, which Kaizad has carried out into the lane, and Benedict brings the cake.
She looks at it for a long time. She counts the silver balls. There are ninety.
"Too many roses," she says.
"Yes, Fui."
"And the pink is too pink."
"Yes, Fui."
She takes the knife from Kaizad. Her hand is very steady. She cuts the first slice herself and puts it on a plate and eats one bite, and closes her eyes, and the whole lane, two hundred people from four continents and a chemist, goes quiet.
"Rose water," she says, with her eyes closed. "And the khamir. You put the khamir in."
"I always do."
"I know you always do," says Roshan-fui. "I'm only checking you remember." She opens her eyes. She looks at me, and then past me at my brother behind the counter in our father's cap. "Farokh!"
"Yes, Roshan-fui?"
"Have you boiled the milk twice?"
"Yes, Roshan-fui."
"Good," she says. "Then I can die."
"Not today, Fui," says my brother. "We're out of mawa till Tuesday."
And Roshan-fui laughs, the big croaking laugh, and the lane laughs with her, and Iqbal honks his horn three times, and somewhere in the noise Kaizad holds his phone up high over all our heads and records it, every second of it, for the family folder, with the caption he will type that night: Roshan-fui's 90th, Colaba Lane. Everyone was here.
I go behind the counter. My knee is titanium and it is cold and it holds. My brother moves over to make room. There is not enough room behind that counter for two people, there never has been. Pappa was right about that.
We stand there anyway, side by side, sixty-four and sixty-one, and sell mawa cake to our relations at thirty-five rupees a slice, because Farokh says that if we give it away nobody will value it, and I say that is the most English thing I have ever heard, and he says thank you.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
If this book stayed with you
Closing Stock
One Night in a Leicester Corner Shop, by Way of Kampala and Porbandar
Another family shop at the moment it might be sold, counted item by item by the people who kept it open.
About this book

Dilnavaz Pavri has stood behind the counter of Pavri & Co. since 1984. Her brother Farokh has lived in Harrow since 1983. When their mother dies at ninety-three, the will leaves the Colaba bakery, its ninety-five-year-old brick oven and its four-hundred-and-twelve-rupee tenancy to both of them, in equal shares.
Farokh arrives from London with a raincoat, two packets of shortbread and a word his sister cannot stand: options. A developer in a white Fortuner is offering six crore to surrender the shop. A municipal letter says the wood-fired oven must go in six months. And Dilnavaz's knee is held together by stubbornness.
Meanwhile their nineteen-year-old grand-nephew, who works the morning counter for three thousand rupees and all the broken khari he can eat, starts recording their eighty-nine-year-old aunt at four o'clock tea. She has stories about the 1944 dock explosion. She also has one about 1983 that neither sibling wants played.
Forty-one relatives on a family WhatsApp group have opinions. A ginger cat with half a tail has none. Who gets to decide what a family bakery is worth?
Members can react to this book and talk about it in the members' Library.
Ownership
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.
This book is owned by CRUNOD LLC. It is free to read on EternalCurrent.Online. No part of it may be copied, reprinted, sold, recorded or adapted, including as audio, film or translation, without written permission from CRUNOD LLC.
© 2026 CRUNOD LLC. All rights reserved.